ArbNation Join free

The 10-20-30 rule for urban tree diversity: where it came from and what studies say

The rule caps any one species at 10 percent of a city's trees, any genus at 20 percent and any family at 30 percent. Studies of city inventories find that most cities fail the rule.

Checked against the sources at the bottom of this page on October 16, 2026. Rules, fees and pay change: the source has the last word.

The 10-20-30 rule is a rule of thumb for urban forest diversity. It is also written 30-20-10, and it is the same rule.

What the rule sets

Kendal and colleagues state it this way: municipal forests should comprise no more than 10 percent of any particular species, 20 percent of any one genus and 30 percent of any single family. They credit the proposal to Santamour. They add that targets based on the rule have helped make urban forests more diverse and resilient in many cities.

The three caps
LevelShare of the urban forest
SpeciesNo more than 10 percent
GenusNo more than 20 percent
FamilyNo more than 30 percent

Where it came from

An Illinois Extension educator on the Good Growing podcast traces the rule to Dr. Santamour, a research geneticist with the US National Arboretum. In her account, his paper cites the guide, and the same paper says he was not the one who proposed it. He does not name who did. Santamour gets the credit for popularising it.

The educator says the rule was put forward to encourage diversity so that catastrophic tree events can be avoided or their risk reduced. She names Dutch elm disease, emerald ash borer and oak wilt as species-specific threats.

What the studies found

Kendal, Dobbs and Lohr, in Urban Forestry and Urban Greening (volume 13, issue 3, 2014, pages 411 to 417), looked at 151 urban forest inventories from 108 cities around the world. Their results:

  • The relative abundance of the most common taxon predicted diversity well.
  • At species level, the most common species was far above the 10 percent benchmark.
  • At genus and family level, the most common taxa were comparable with the benchmarks of 20 and 30 percent.
  • Diversity was consistently lower in Continental climates and in streetscapes, and higher in Temperate climates and in urban forests spanning several land uses.

Mark Ambrose of North Carolina State University and the USDA Forest Service gave a Wetmore Practitioner Lecture at the University of Illinois on October 25, 2022. In the published summary he tested cities against Santamour's rule using more than 1,500 North American urban forest inventories, and found that the vast majority of cities failed. He also modelled the abundance of common tree genera that host invasive pests, to see where risk was highest and how pests might spread. He flags the difficulty of using inventories originally collected for non-research purposes.

Limits of the rule

The Illinois educator points out a gap in the rule. A city that meets 10-20-30 can still have 20 percent of its trees in one genus, and threats such as emerald ash borer attack at the genus level. Her example is a city with 20 percent ash and 20 percent maple: losing the ash and then the maples would take out 40 percent of the urban forest. The rule also leaves room for as few as 10 species and 5 genera in a city. She adds that she knows one large community that has met the rule and is looking at the neighbourhood scale, where some neighbourhoods hold high shares of oak even though the community as a whole has met the goal.

Species lists that cities publish are collected in the guide to street tree diversity.

Sources