ArbNation Join free

Graft incompatibility and rootstock suckers: what extension services describe

A grafted tree can break at the union, decline or send up suckers from the rootstock. University of Maryland Extension, the Royal Horticultural Society and UC IPM describe the signs, the causes and the look-alikes.

Checked against the sources at the bottom of this page on October 21, 2026. Rules, fees and pay change: the source has the last word.

The RHS says many woody ornamentals and most fruit trees are propagated by grafting. The scion is the upper part and the rootstock is the lower part. Maryland Extension says the union of the two can fail through incompatibility, poor technique or environmental conditions. Other non-living causes of tree trouble are listed under weather, soil and chemical damage.

What graft failure is

The Royal Horticultural Society describes graft failure as the union ceasing to work, sometimes years after planting. Flow from the rootstock to the top growth then slows or stops. The top growth declines, gradually or suddenly. The RHS lists the main causes as poor formation of the graft, mechanical damage and graft incompatibility.

Maryland Extension notes that incompatibility is poorly understood. It may come from genetic differences between the grafted parts. Abnormal vascular tissue at the union and virus or phytoplasma infection are other possible causes.

The RHS gives more reasons for incompatibility: a genetic or biochemical reaction between rootstock and scion, virus or phytoplasma infection, and a weak cultivar grafted onto an excessively vigorous rootstock. It adds that the failure can be fairly immediate or delayed, perhaps twenty years or more.

UC IPM, writing about citrus, sees the same range. Some combinations show an incompatibility reaction soon after grafting. Others take 10 to 20 years after planting to develop. UC IPM says it can cause trees to decline and die early.

Signs on the tree

  • A smooth, clean break at the union, one, two or many years after grafting (Maryland Extension).
  • General ill health, shoot dieback, yellowing foliage in late summer and early leaf drop (Maryland Extension).
  • Growth that starts or ends at different times on scion and rootstock, with a distinct difference in growth rate (Maryland Extension).
  • Overgrowth at, above or below the union, seen as a visible difference in trunk diameter (Maryland Extension and RHS).
  • Rootstock and scion partly or fully separated, or a dark line or corky tissue along the union when cut vertically (RHS).
  • Decay of the wood around and below the union, which the RHS calls usually a secondary problem rather than the cause.

Maryland Extension says a tree can survive with one or more of these signs. A combination of many may lead to early death, and weakened trees may have to be removed.

UC IPM describes one citrus form, bud union crease. A crease or fold forms at the union from uneven growth, and the food-conducting tissue is compressed. Cutting off outer bark at the union commonly shows a dark line of dead inner bark and wood around it. UC IPM calls the result slow girdling. Either part can be the enlarged one: the scion trunk or the rootstock.

Normal bulging at the union

Not every swelling is a fault. Maryland Extension describes a slight bulge, swelling or crook in the trunk two to three inches above the soil line as normal healing. Callus tissue forms and new vascular cambium develops in the callus bridge. It says the union should remain above the soil line. A union buried in soil lets the scion form roots and lose the rootstock's influence.

Rootstock suckers

When the top dies, the root system often stays alive. The RHS says the rootstock may send up suckering shoots, and the rootstock is often of inferior quality to the plant that has died. Maryland Extension lists suckers from the rootstock among the symptoms, and its lead photo shows a cherry with scion and rootstock both growing from below the union.

What else produces the same decline

The RHS names look-alikes. Crown gall, a bacterial disease, causes decline of grape vines, roses and other trees and shrubs. Bacterial canker is a common problem of ornamental and fruiting Prunus. Root diseases such as honey fungus and Phytophthora kill woody plants. Establishment problems can explain poor growth of newly planted trees.

Combinations named as prone to overgrowth

UC IPM names citrus pairings prone to bud union overgrowth: Frost nucellar navel on trifoliate orange, lemon on Cleopatra mandarin, Eureka lemon or Satsuma mandarin on Troyer, and certain scion varieties on sour orange. This is a citrus list and not a rule for other trees.

Where the failure begins

The RHS lists the causes of a failed union. Anatomical mismatch of the two tissues, poor grafting technique, adverse weather and poor hygiene can all spoil the union. Damage to the union in transport, planting or later, including mower and strimmer strikes, is also listed. Maryland Extension says to use disease-free plant material for grafting.

Sources