ArbNation Join free

Aerial work platform, crane and rope compared as access methods

SafeWork NSW sets out five ways to reach the upper tree in one table. HSE and the UK industry code rank rope work against a lift platform and a crane.

Checked against the sources at the bottom of this page on October 21, 2026. Rules, fees and pay change: the source has the last word.

The named codes and training bodies are described here as published. It is not training and does not teach the work. SafeWork NSW's Tree works Code of Practice, in force from March 27, 2026, compares access methods in section 3.2. The Health and Safety Executive (HSE) and the Arboricultural Association's Industry Code of Practice for Tree Work at Height, second edition of May 2020, weigh the same choice for Great Britain.

The NSW comparison table

The NSW code says the person in charge of the business must pick the access method that removes the risk or, where that is not practicable, controls it. Its Table 2 lists the advantages and limitations of each method. The wording below is shortened from that table.

Tree access methods in SafeWork NSW Table 2
Access methodAdvantages listedLimitations listed
Elevating work platformWorker isolated from tree hazards, attached to the platform and shielded by the guard rail. Reaches the outer canopy. Less worker fatigue. Easy rescue.Site or terrain unsuitable for mobile plant. Cannot reach parts close to the trunk. Wires between platform and tree. Traffic limits. May not be appropriate for small, simple jobs. Falling trunks or branches can strike the platform.
Worker placed in the tree by craneMay reach areas a platform cannot. Worker isolated from tree hazards and attached to the crane hook. Reaches the outer canopy. Less fatigue.Needs a worker competent in harness use and in contact with the crane operator. Same site, terrain, wire and traffic limits as a platform. Cannot reach parts close to the trunk. Not appropriate for small, simple jobs.
Work positioning system (rope and harness, or rope, spikes, pole strap and harness)Suits a site with limited access. Allows movement through the canopy. Small equipment and infrastructure needs. Lets the climber inspect the tree on the way up. Can place lifting gear for a crane from inside the tree.Needs a trained climber and a trained rescue person. Not suitable where the tree's structure or condition makes climbing unsafe. Climber fatigue can impair decisions. Manual handling limits.
Individual fall arrest systemSuits reaching a tree from a roof or cliff edge where a fall is possible.Not suitable for use within trees. Anchor points can be hard to find.
Portable ladderAllows transit over vines such as ivy that block rope access. Reaches branches a climber cannot.Risk while the ladder is first connected to the tree. The user is often unstable. A cut branch can move and dislodge the ladder. Falling branches can dislodge the user.

The NSW code adds that the user of a ladder and the ladder should both be connected to the tree.

How NSW treats the crane method

Section 6 of the NSW code describes a competent worker in a harness who attaches to a crane hook and is lifted into position. The worker then connects to the tree and unhooks from the crane. The crane is used only to reach the tree.

The code says this method can raise the risk of falls from height, of being struck by falling objects, of contact with energised lines and of bites and stings. For that reason it asks that every other access method be considered first. A risk assessment must show the crane method brings no greater risk than climbing the tree or using plant made for tree access.

The code names two cases where the crane may suit: a climber who could tire in hot or humid weather, and a site where buildings, other trees or steep ground make other methods riskier. It points to a slewing telescopic boom crane. The person lifted holds a high risk work dogging licence if they direct the operator out of the operator's view. A saddle-type work positioning harness is required, and a rope access harness is called unsuitable.

Rope work in the HSE guidance

HSE states that the Work at Height Regulations 2005 do not ban climbing. Employers must plan the work and select equipment that makes it as safe as possible. Climbing on a personal fall protection system, with ropes and harness, is allowed only when three tests are met:

  • a risk assessment shows the work can be done safely on that system;
  • using safer equipment, such as a MEWP (a mobile platform lift), is not justified;
  • the user and enough other people have task-specific training, including rescue.

HSE names two families of climbing technique. Work positioning uses a harness, a friction knot and a climbing line. Rope access and positioning covers footlocking and single rope technique. Work positioning needs a suitable back-up. Rope access needs at least two separately anchored lines, one for working and one for safety. HSE allows a single line where a risk assessment shows a second line would add risk.

What the UK industry code adds

The Arboricultural Association code, section 3.8, says the work method is chosen after a risk assessment and a pre-work assessment. The planning weighs the hazards, access and egress, the distance and consequences of a fall, how long the exposure lasts, operator skill, the tree, the anchors and rescue. Its risk hierarchy in section 3.5 says justification for rope-based methods can rest on three points. Aerial work is required and no other means is reasonably practicable. The tree is in a structurally safe condition and suitable to climb. The tree offers suitable anchor points.

For a platform, the code calls it versatile collective protection that protects more than one person and works without action by the operator. It lists site, ground, reach, load and wind limits as planning points. Ladders are limited to low risk, short tasks, with a typical figure of under 30 minutes.

For a crane, the code says an appointed person plans the lift and the outcome should be a written lift plan. It says cranes are not built for raising and lowering a person in a tree climbing harness. A person goes up by crane only where a platform cannot reach the crown and a risk assessment fully justifies the plan. The code lists conditions for each lift, among them:

  • rated capacity at least twice the weight of climber, gear and accessories;
  • crane speed limited to 0.5 m/s;
  • constant two-way contact between climber, crane supervisor and operator;
  • no lifting of people in winds above 7 m/s (25 km/h), in thunderstorms, or in snow, sleet or ice.

More on the lifting side is in the personnel-lift rules for a crane basket and the Arboricultural Association guide to platforms in tree work.

Credit: the table restates material from SafeWork NSW, Tree works Code of Practice, March 2026, licensed under Creative Commons Attribution 4.0, with changes in wording and length. HSE material contains public sector information licensed under the Open Government Licence v3.0.

Sources