Appealing a tree decision in the United States: what Portland, Seattle, San Francisco, Washington DC, Connecticut and Massachusetts set out
Six US codes and city pages say who hears an appeal after a refused tree permit, a notice of violation, a stop work order or a public tree removal, in Portland, Seattle, San Francisco, Washington DC, Connecticut and Massachusetts.
Checked against the sources at the bottom of this page on October 10, 2026. Rules, fees and pay change: the source has the last word.
This page reports what the official source says. It is not legal advice: ask the office named here. The sources are the Portland City Code, the Code of the District of Columbia, the Connecticut General Statutes, the Massachusetts General Laws, the Seattle Municipal Code and San Francisco Public Works pages. The United States has no single appeal route, and each city or state writes its own. It covers these six only. The wider permit rules for large cities are in the guide to tree permits in the largest US cities, and the Canadian equivalent is the guide to appealing a tree decision in Canada.
Who hears the appeal
| Place | Who the source names | Time limit the source gives |
|---|---|---|
| Portland, Oregon | The City Administrator for an administrative review, then the Urban Forestry Appeals Board | 14 days from the decision for the review, then 14 days from the review decision for the appeal |
| Seattle, Washington | The Director of the Department of Construction and Inspections reviews a notice of violation; later appeal as state law allows | 10 days after service of the notice of violation to ask for review |
| San Francisco, California | Public Works posts a tree removal; the Board of Appeals hears appeals of Public Works orders | 15 or 30 days of the posting date, per the Public Works page; 15 days of a date the order states, in a 2026 order |
| Washington DC | The Mayor reviews a stop work order, then the Office of Administrative Hearings | 10 business days to ask for review, then 10 business days from notice of the Mayor's decision to appeal |
| Connecticut | The town or borough tree warden holds a hearing, then the Superior Court | 10 days from the tree warden's decision |
| Massachusetts | A public hearing before removal; a damages claim under chapter 79 afterward | Chapter 87 section 3 gives none for the claim |
Portland, Oregon
Portland City Code Chapter 11.30 sets two permit types. For a Type A permit only the applicant may appeal. For a Type B permit the applicant may appeal, and where public notice is required the neighborhood association or any other person may appeal too. The code says the applicant first asks the City Administrator to review the decision, in writing, within 14 days of the decision, and names how the administrator erred. The appeal to the Urban Forestry Appeals Board is filed within 14 days of the review decision. Chapter 11.20 describes the Appeals Board as five members drawn from the Urban Forestry Commission, with public hearings.
The hearing is scheduled within 45 days of filing and notice goes out at least 14 days before. The board may affirm or reverse, and on a Type B permit may also remand to set mitigation. The code tells the board to give "due deference" to the City Administrator's professional judgment. Its decision is final and cannot be appealed to another review body within the City. Violations are a separate route: Chapter 11.70 sends an appeal of an enforcement determination to the Code Hearings Officer, and further appeals go by writ of review under ORS 34.010 to 34.100.
Seattle, Washington
Chapter 25.11 of the Seattle Municipal Code is the Tree Protection chapter. Section 25.11.120(E) says a notice of violation is final and not subject to further appeal unless an aggrieved party asks in writing for review by the Director within ten days after service of the notice. When the last day is a Saturday, Sunday or holiday, the period runs until 5 p.m. on the next business day. Additional information is due no later than 15 days after the Director tells the requester the request was received in time. After the review the Director may sustain, withdraw, modify or amend the notice, or continue the review to a set date. The Director's decision on that review is final, with a further appeal only where state law allows one. Section 25.11.115 on modifications of removal and replacement requirements refers to appeals to the Hearing Examiner and says the parties will have a further chance to make a record on factual issues. The Department of Construction and Inspections page on appeals covers Hearing Examiner appeals. They must be in writing, received before 5:00 p.m. on the deadline, and carry a US$120 filing fee payable to the City of Seattle. The Examiner may waive the fee for financial hardship. The wording is about land use decisions in general and does not name tree decisions.
San Francisco, California
San Francisco Public Works posts tree removals. Under Public Works Code Article 16, Section 806, a written appeal about the removal of a tree may be made within 15 or 30 days of the posting date, depending on the posting period. Appeals must state their grounds and go to the Bureau of Urban Forestry at its South Van Ness address or by email. Public Works also lists tree removals with active appeals at the Board of Appeals. A 2026 Board of Appeals hearing packet for the denial of a removal application prints Public Works' order language. The order and permit may be appealed to the Board of Appeals within 15 days of a date the order states. Public Works counts from the posting date, and the order counts from the date it states. Those are two separate clocks. Public Works cites Section 806 by number, and its text is not restated here.
Washington DC
Section 8-651.08 of the DC Code covers enforcement of the tree canopy law. A stop work order must describe the right to ask for review. The property owner or agent asks the Mayor for review within 10 business days, in writing with grounds. The Mayor affirms, modifies or reverses within 15 business days, and if the Mayor does not act in that time the stop work order is lifted. A final decision of the Mayor may be appealed to the Office of Administrative Hearings within 10 business days of notice. Separately, subsection (e) lets a person aggrieved by a final decision of the Mayor under subsections (c) or (d) appeal to the same office within 30 business days. Those subsections cover revoking a permit at a site where a Special Tree or Heritage Tree was harmed, denying a construction permit after a willful or reckless violation, and revoking a licence.
Connecticut
Section 23-59 of the Connecticut General Statutes covers trees in public roads and grounds. Unless there is an immediate public hazard, the tree warden posts a notice on the tree at least ten days before removal or pruning. A person who objects may appeal to the tree warden in writing, and the warden holds a public hearing. The warden decides within three days after the hearing, and the aggrieved party may appeal within ten days to the Superior Court for the judicial district of the town or borough.
Massachusetts
Chapter 87 section 3 of the Massachusetts General Laws says public shade trees are not cut or removed without a public hearing. Notice must be posted in two or more public places and on the tree at least seven days before, and published in a newspaper in two successive weeks. The section names no board or court for an appeal. A person injured in property by the officers' action on trimming, cutting, removal or retention of a tree may recover damages from the town under chapter 79.
Sources
- City of Portland, Title 11 Trees, Chapter 11.30 Tree Permit Procedures (amended effective January 3, 2025), read October 9, 2026
- City of Portland, Title 11 Trees, Chapter 11.20 Urban Forestry Commission and Appeals Board, read October 9, 2026
- City of Portland, Title 11 Trees, Chapter 11.70 Enforcement, read October 9, 2026
- Council of the District of Columbia, DC Code section 8-651.08 Enforcement, read October 9, 2026
- Connecticut General Assembly, General Statutes chapter 451 Public Shade Trees (section 23-59), read October 9, 2026
- Massachusetts Legislature, General Laws part I title XIV chapter 87 section 3, read October 9, 2026
- City of Seattle, Seattle Municipal Code Chapter 25.11 Tree Protection, read October 10, 2026
- City of Seattle, Department of Construction and Inspections, How to Appeal a Decision, read October 10, 2026
- San Francisco Public Works, Tree Removal Notifications, read October 10, 2026
- San Francisco Board of Appeals, hearing packet for an appeal of a Public Works tree removal denial, 2026, read October 10, 2026