ArbNation Join free

Fire-damaged trees: crown scorch and bark char thresholds from OSU, ODF and USFS

Oregon State Extension prints species thresholds for crown scorch and bark char above which a fire-injured conifer has better than a 50 percent chance of dying. They run from 20 percent for western hemlock to 85 percent for incense cedar.

Checked against the sources at the bottom of this page on October 16, 2026. Rules, fees and pay change: the source has the last word.

The named agencies and standards are described here as published. It is not a diagnosis of any tree and does not say what should be done with one. Every figure below is for conifers in Oregon and Washington, from the Oregon State University (OSU) Extension publication EM 9557 of July 2025, which reproduces the thresholds of the 2020 USFS guide by Hood and others.

The three signs

OSU Extension names three observations: crown scorch, bark char and root damage. Crown injury is the first and most important. Crown scorch is the share of the pre-fire live crown killed by heat, even if the needles are not consumed. The Oregon Department of Forestry (ODF) fact sheet of November 2025 measures it as a proportion of crown volume or length, and bole char as a proportion of the bole circumference.

OSU sorts injury into three categories. Heavy or severe means little or no live crown, deep char, and deep basal char in all four quarters. Moderate means varying levels of scorch and char, and OSU calls those trees less predictable. Light means most of the crown intact and very little char.

ODF counts bole char by splitting the circumference into four quadrants and counting the damaged ones. It treats external char as a stand-in for cambium damage, which is harder to sample. It calls external char appropriate on thick-barked species such as ponderosa pine, incense cedar, Douglas-fir and western larch. On thin-barked species such as lodgepole pine, Engelmann spruce and some firs, ODF says sampling the cambium may be easier and more informative.

Thick bark and thin bark

OSU lists Douglas-fir, ponderosa pine, western larch and incense cedar as thick-barked species that resist fire damage, with high crown injury usually needed to kill them. It lists western hemlock, western redcedar, spruce and lodgepole pine as thin-barked species that are easily killed even with little crown damage. In the table below, western hemlock dies at 20 percent crown scorch and incense cedar at 85 percent.

Species thresholds

OSU states that a tree is likely to die, with a chance above 50 percent, if damage exceeds the criteria for either crown scorch or bark char. No single blanket figure appears in these publications. Sizes are tree diameter in inches.

Crown scorch and bark char thresholds, OSU Extension EM 9557
SpeciesCrown scorchBark char
Pacific silver firOver 30% of volume under 21 in; over 40% at 21 in and up50% or more, any char
Subalpine firOver 30% under 21 in; over 40% at 21 in and upOver 50%, any char
White fir70% or more75% or more, deep char
Red fir70% or moreOver 75%, deep char
Grand fir60% or more50% or more, any char (5 to 11.9 in); 75% or more, moderate or deep (12 in and up)
Incense cedar85% or moreOver 75%, deep char
Western larch80% or more of crown length if needles are on; if off, average char height over 70% of tree lengthOver 75%, deep char (5 to 11.9 in); not a predictive indicator at 12 in and up
Engelmann spruce, Sitka spruce75% or moreOver 75%, any char
Lodgepole pine, whitebark pine40% or more75% or more, any char
Sugar pine70% or moreOver 90%, moderate or deep
Western white pineOver 30%90% or more, any char
Ponderosa pineAfter bud break, 70% of crown volume killed with no new growthOver 90%, deep char
Douglas-firOver 65%Over 50% deep (5 to 11.9 in); over 75% deep (12 in and up)
Western red cedarOver 20% (5 to 11.9 in); over 40% (12 to 20.9 in); over 60% (21 in and up)Over 50%, any char (under 21 in); over 75% (21 in and up)
Western hemlock, mountain hemlock20% or more90% or more, any char

The ponderosa pine entry has a second, pre-bud-break criterion: 85 percent or more of needles scorched if under 10 percent are blackened, or over 40 percent scorched if over 10 percent are blackened.

Beetle and borer attack

OSU and ODF agree on one override. Where bark beetle or woodborer attack shows around more than 50 percent of the bole circumference, the tree will die whatever the fire injury. The signs are brown frass in bark crevices, and pitch streams on Douglas-fir and true firs or pitch tubes on pines. Red turpentine beetle in pine is the exception: ODF calls it a secondary pest that marks stress, with pitch tubes low on the bole.

ODF says bark beetles and woodborers are usually first into fire-damaged trees and may keep attacking a stand for two to four years. Its fact sheet adds that trees should be assessed in the first year, before crown symptoms change, because new growth and epicormic sprouts can hide the first damage. ODF's worked example is a 15 inch Douglas-fir: at 75 percent crown scorch it is more likely than not to die.

What the California data found

Sharon Hood, Sheri Smith and Daniel Cluck followed 5,246 trees from five California wildfires between 1999 and 2002 and published the results in USDA Forest Service General Technical Report PSW-GTR-203. Their models for incense cedar, Jeffrey pine, ponderosa pine, red fir and white fir all used percent crown length killed and cambium kill. Diameter was a significant variable in all but the red fir model. Light and deep bark char predicted live and dead cambium fairly accurately, but moderate char did not.

Limits stated by the agencies

ODF says its mortality marking guides are not exact, are a starting point, and should not stand in for hazard tree marking guides. OSU notes that trees which survive often grow weaker against insects and drought, and that fire scars can let decay in over time. Both name the full USFS guide (R6-FHP-RO-2020-02) as the complete reference.

Sources