Bare root, balled and burlapped, container and air-pruning stock: how the types differ
Penn State, Purdue and the Morton Arboretum sort nursery trees by how they are dug and sold: bare root, balled and burlapped, or container. Each type leaves a different share of its roots behind and has its own planting window.
Checked against the sources at the bottom of this page on October 15, 2026. Rules, fees and pay change: the source has the last word.
This page draws on what the named extension services, the Morton Arboretum and BSI publish. It is not training and does not teach the work. Penn State Extension separates the words by what they describe. Bare-root and balled and burlapped describe how a plant is offered for sale. Container-grown describes how it was produced before sale. All three types must be protected from moisture loss once they leave the nursery. The Morton Arboretum adds a fourth source of stock, trees dug by tree spade, and finds transplanting can succeed with every form.
The types compared
| Type and definition | Planting window | Drawbacks listed |
|---|---|---|
| Bare root. Harvested with no protection over the roots. Penn State reports that only small deciduous trees, shrubs and some ground covers were traditionally sold this way. City foresters have adopted larger bare-root street trees for planting programs. Penn State calls it less expensive and easy to handle. | Early spring or early fall, while dormant (Penn State). Purdue adds that the roots must stay moist and the tree goes in as soon as possible after delivery. | Not practical for large plants. Roots may dry out. Small plants are exposed to damage. Trees may need staking. |
| Balled and burlapped. Dug from the field with a ball of soil held by burlap, a wire cage or other material. Penn State counts any ornamental tree or shrub as suitable for this form. Purdue calls B&B the largest cultivated tree for purchasing. | Penn State: most safely moved when not actively growing, and sold in spring and early fall. Purdue: usually available year-round, with the best selection in spring and fall. | Heavy and hard to handle. Most roots stay in the field. Twine, wire and treated burlap must be removed or adjusted before planting, in Penn State's account. Purdue adds that many are planted too deep in the nursery. |
| Container. Grown in the container for the whole production cycle, so digging does not damage the roots. Purdue gives sizes from 1-gallon to 25-gallon pots. Purdue lists root control bags as a close relative. | Any time the soil is not frozen, though Penn State puts the better chance of success in spring or early fall. Purdue finds containers and bags usually the easiest to plant, letting trees establish in any season, summer included. | Circling or root-bound roots. Soilless mix that dries quickly. Penn State adds that they may cost more than field-grown plants. |
Share of roots left behind
The three Extension services print different figures. Penn State's planting guide says often over 95 percent of the roots are left behind when a tree is balled and burlapped. A second Penn State article puts the loss at approximately 90% for trees dug with a tree spade. Purdue counts as much as 80% or more of the roots left behind after digging. Penn State adds that a bare-root tree may keep more fibrous roots but still loses enough to cause major stress and mortality in the first year or two. A container tree has 100% of its roots.
Ball size and caliper
Penn State cites the nursery stock standards of the American Nursery and Landscape Association for minimum ball sizes. It gives three examples:
- A 1.5-inch caliper tree has a ball of at least 20 inches and a height of 10 to 13 feet.
- A 2-inch caliper tree has a ball of at least 24 inches and a height of 12 to 15 feet.
- A 3-inch caliper tree has a ball of at least 32 inches and a height of 13 to 18 feet.
Caliper is measured 6 inches above the ground for trees up to 4 inches, and 12 inches above for larger ones.
Root problems in container stock
Penn State's planting guide warns of black, slimy or smelly roots, dense masses of circled roots and roots reaching out of the drain holes. It treats moderate circling as manageable by scoring with a sharp knife at planting. Its container-stock article names air-pruning containers and containers coated with a copper hydroxide solution as ways nurseries reduce circling. Purdue notes that the round container forces roots to grow in a circle and can lead to stem-girdling roots. It describes shaving the outer inch of roots on all four sides and the bottom. The Morton Arboretum calls this boxing.
Planting season
For many species, Morton gives spring as the best season, with a longer growing season for roots to re-establish before winter. It lists bald-cypress, ginkgo, larch, magnolia, hemlock, sweetgum, tuliptree and willow among slow-to-establish species. Fall is also good, with six weeks before the ground freezes. Purdue calls early fall the optimum time for most species in Indiana, with late winter and early spring next best.
BS 8545 and young trees
BSI describes BS 8545, Trees: from nursery to independence in the landscape, as recommendations on transplanting young trees so they reach independence in the landscape. It covers planning, design, production, planting and management. It applies to trees with a distinct crown prepared in the nursery. It does not apply to whips, transplants, seedlings or other woody material. BSI lists the 2014 edition, published February 28, 2014, as current and under review.
Sources
- Penn State Extension, Planting Ornamentals, read October 15, 2026
- The Morton Arboretum, How to Plant Trees and Shrubs, read October 15, 2026
- Purdue Extension, Tree Installation: Process and Practices (FNR-433-W), read October 15, 2026
- BSI, BS 8545:2014 Trees: from nursery to independence in the landscape. Recommendations, scope page, read October 15, 2026
- Penn State Extension, Container Grown Trees and Shrubs: Fix Those Roots Before You Plant, updated August 25, 2025, read October 15, 2026
- Penn State Extension, Making Sure Your Young Shade Trees Survive, updated April 29, 2024, read October 15, 2026