ArbNation Join free

Benefit-cost studies of street trees: what the USDA Forest Service Center for Urban Forest Research reports

The Forest Service's Center for Urban Forest Research published municipal tree studies for Cheyenne in 2004, Charlotte and Boulder in 2005 and New York City in 2007. Their benefit-cost ratios run from 2.09 to 5.60.

Checked against the sources at the bottom of this page on October 19, 2026. Rules, fees and pay change: the source has the last word.

Each study asks the same question about one city: do the benefits of the municipal tree population justify the annual spending on it? The Pacific Southwest Research Station's Center for Urban Forest Research answered it with a tree inventory and a benefit-cost model. The reports price energy savings, stormwater interception, carbon dioxide, air quality and property value, then divide total benefits by total tree costs.

The four studies side by side

Benefit-cost results as printed in each Forest Service report
City, report yearTrees, benefits and cost per yearRatio
Cheyenne, 200417,010 trees in the 1992 inventory. Benefits US$686,000 (about US$40 a tree). Cost US$327,897 (US$19.28 a tree)2.09
Charlotte, 2005About 85,000 trees. Benefits US$5.9 million (US$69 a tree). Cost about US$1.8 million (US$21 a tree)3.25
Boulder, 200535,502 trees. Benefits US$2.7 million (US$77 a tree). Cost US$752,606 (US$21.20 a tree)3.64
New York City, 2007592,130 street trees. Benefits US$121.9 million (US$209 a tree). Cost US$21.8 million (US$37 a tree)5.60

The New York report prints 5.60 in its summary text and its results section. A figure caption in the same summary reads US$5.80 in benefits for every US$1 spent.

Cheyenne, 2004

Peper, McPherson, Simpson, Maco and Xiao report that street and park trees returned US$2.09 for every US$1 spent. Street trees supplied US$1.27 of that and park trees US$0.82. Net benefits came to US$358,157. Energy savings were US$10.99 per tree, stormwater US$3.25, carbon dioxide US$1.71 and air quality US$0.70. Property value gains, at US$23.68 per tree, were the largest single item.

Charlotte, 2005

McPherson and colleagues put Charlotte's net annual benefits at about US$4.1 million, or US$48 per tree. The report compares its ratio of 3.25 with Glendale, Arizona (2.41), Fort Collins, Colorado (2.18), Cheyenne (2.09), Minneapolis (1.57) and Berkeley, California (1.37). Willow oaks were about 17 percent of street trees and supplied 40 percent of the benefits. Crapemyrtle was 14 percent of the population and supplied 1.8 percent.

The same report counts tree emissions of volatile organic compounds against air quality. Charlotte's trees remove 85,950 pounds of pollutants a year, but willow oaks emit enough to leave a slightly negative net effect, valued as a cost of US$36,270.

Boulder, 2005

Boulder's report finds about US$2 million in net annual benefits, or US$56 per tree. It compares its 3.64 ratio with Bismarck, North Dakota (3.09), Glendale (2.41), Fort Collins (2.18), Cheyenne (2.09) and Berkeley (1.37). Siberian elms gave the highest benefits among street trees at US$209 per tree. Large deciduous trees averaged US$105 per tree, against US$63 for large conifers and US$29 for small deciduous trees.

New York City, 2007

Peper and colleagues report US$100.2 million in net annual benefits, or US$172 per tree. Energy savings were US$27.8 million and stormwater interception 890.6 million gallons, valued at US$35.6 million. London planetrees, 89,425 of them, produced US$27.4 million, or 23 percent of all benefits. The report states that New York's ratio exceeds every other city studied to that date.

The Urban Forestry South library catalogues the report as published in April 2007 by the Forest Service, 72 pages. Its summary frames the question the same way: what benefits do the city's street trees accrue?

Limits stated in the reports

The Charlotte report notes that its assessment covers inventoried trees and may understate the full municipal forest. Cheyenne's figures rest on an inventory taken in 1992, with a partial update in 2001. Costs per tree differ: Cheyenne spent US$19.28, Charlotte US$21 and New York US$37.

Related figures on carbon appear in the guide to carbon in urban trees, and the model behind the studies is described in the guide to the i-Tree tools.

Sources