ArbNation Join free

Biochar in urban tree soils: what the ISA journal review, EBC and IBI report

A 2022 review in the ISA journal found biochar can help tree establishment and survival, but results range from large gains to no effect and urban field trials are few. Certification comes from the EBC and IBI schemes.

Checked against the sources at the bottom of this page on October 15, 2026. Rules, fees and pay change: the source has the last word.

This summary describes what the named journal, certifier and research groups publish. It is not training and does not teach the work. The ISA material here is the journal review by Schaffert, Lukac, Percival and Rose in Arboriculture and Urban Forestry (volume 48, issue 3, May 2022, pages 176 to 202).

What biochar is

The review defines biochar as a product high in complex carbon compounds, made by pyrolysis of biomass at high temperatures (over 300 °C) in a low-oxygen environment. Cornell University's pyrolysis group describes pyrolysis as a thermochemical process that heats organic matter in an oxygen-deficient environment. It yields a solid (biochar), a liquid (biocrude or bio-oil) and a gas (syngas).

The properties of a biochar, including pH, nutrient value and stability, depend heavily on the original biomass. The review cites work finding feedstock has a stronger effect on plant growth than production temperature. Biochar is relatively inert and low in nutrients unless it comes from animal manure or has a large ash content. Its breakdown in soil usually takes thousands of years.

Trial results

The review opens with a plain statement of the evidence. Studies of biochar in agriculture and forestry show results from significant improvements in growth and health to no effect at all. Research on biochar for trees in the urban landscape is described as extremely limited, and the review found most studies focus on crops such as rice, wheat, tomatoes, rapeseed and corn.

Findings the review reports, by topic
TopicFinding as reported
Biomass across woody speciesOne meta-analysis found an average 41 percent increase in total biomass. Angiosperms responded more than conifers.
Transplanted pear treesA 20 percent reduction in mortality, a 28 percent larger crown and a 32 percent gain in leaf photosynthetic efficiency compared with untreated trees.
RootsPine waste biochar gave higher root biomass in small-leaved lime planted in late spring. Eucalyptus wood biochar had no significant effect on spotted gum roots, but coral gum in sandy soil grew more root.
Water in droughtA 3 percent by weight hardwood chip application raised biomass 73 percent in pot-grown chestnut-leaved oak under severe water deficit. Many of these trials used young potted seedlings, and the review urges caution in relying on them.
Biochar with compostIn a tropical urban trial, 10 percent compost with 5 percent biochar beat either alone. Tree growth index rose 33 and 50 percent after 30 months in two soil types.
Negative or mixed resultsWood chip biochar can be strongly water-repellent, and one study of biochar mixed with a clay substrate found lower soil water content and a shorter period of plant-available water in sandy soil. An Italian apple orchard trial found no effect on soil moisture in a particularly unretentive soil.

The review concludes that wood-based biochar has the potential to enhance tree establishment and survival. It says variability in physical and chemical properties limits universal application, and long-term studies in urban conditions are still needed. Biochar is called a promising complement to established techniques such as mulching and fertilization. Even a small gain in survival could make application cost-effective for local authorities or tree caretakers.

Certification and standards

The review notes that the International Biochar Initiative (IBI) has attempted to set standards for biochar used in soils, including a certification program meant to confirm the biochar is of sufficient quality and safe for soil. It lists IBI's test categories from version 2.1 of its standards (2015): categories A and B are required analyses, and category C is optional but recommended. IBI describes itself as a global collective voice for biochar, with a network in more than 50 countries.

Carbon Standards offers the European Biochar Certificate (EBC) for the production, processing and use of biochar. Carbon Standards says certified biochar comes from sustainably procured feedstock, meets emissions limits and is stored in an environmentally sound way. Limits for each use class (agriculture, materials, other) are monitored and documented.

A producer starts with a technical pre-audit of the process flows, emissions, pyrolysis technology and sampling plan. After that the first-year production batch can be registered. A third-party on-site inspection is the last step before EBC-certified biochar can be sold. Carbon Standards publishes related guidelines for the EBC and the WBC, plus a positive list of permissible biomass.

Sources