ArbNation Join free

Certificates of insurance: what state insurance departments say one is and is not

Four state insurance regulators say a certificate of insurance is a summary, not a policy, and cannot change the cover. Illinois goes further: a certificate that does so is void.

Checked against the sources at the bottom of this page on October 16, 2026. Rules, fees and pay change: the source has the last word.

This page reports what the official source says. It is not legal advice: ask the office named here. The four sources are bulletins and guidance from the insurance departments of Wisconsin, Nebraska and New Jersey, and the Illinois Insurance Code. Each state's department is the office to ask about its own rule.

A certificate is a summary

The Wisconsin Office of the Commissioner of Insurance (OCI) issued a bulletin on May 5, 2008. It calls certificates of insurance a way to give a third party proof of liability insurance and a summary of the policy terms, instead of the whole policy.

OCI says a certificate that states the cover accurately is not a form that needs filing with OCI, because it does not amend, extend or alter the underlying policy. It only summarises the coverages.

The Nebraska Department of Insurance guidance document IGD D3, issued October 20, 2022, takes the same line. It says certificates of insurance are not actual policies of insurance, and they do not and cannot amend, extend or alter the cover that policies or binders give. The document replaced an earlier Nebraska bulletin, CB-118 of December 7, 2010.

The New Jersey Department of Banking and Insurance, in Bulletin No. 11-04 of February 28, 2011, writes that certificates are used as proof that a policy is in effect and usually summarise its main terms, conditions and duration. It says certificate forms are not filed with the Department, though the policy forms they summarise are.

What a certificate cannot do

The four sources agree on the core point and differ on wording and penalty. The citations behind each penalty are Wis. Stat. s. 628.34 (1), Neb. Rev. Stat. s. 44-4059(1)(e) and N.J.S.A. 17:22A-40a(5).

What each source says a certificate of insurance cannot do
SourceWording and consequence
Wisconsin OCI, May 5, 2008Certificate language that amends or extends cover, or says cover is in force when it is not, is a misrepresentation. The insurer or agent may face administrative penalties, up to licence suspension or revocation
Nebraska, October 20, 2022A certificate cannot amend, extend or alter cover, or promise the holder notice of cancellation that the policy does not give. A producer risks licence suspension or revocation and penalties of up to one thousand dollars per violation
New Jersey, February 28, 2011A certificate is evidence of insurance in lieu of a copy of the policy and cannot amend, expand or alter its terms. A certificate that materially misstates policy terms can bring suspension or revocation of the producer's licence
Illinois, Section 155.45A certificate may not amend, extend or alter the cover, or give a person rights beyond those in the policy. A certificate or document made, asked for or required in violation is void

Illinois: the statute in detail

Section 155.45 of the Illinois Insurance Code defines a certificate of insurance as a document prepared by an insurer or insurance producer as evidence of property or casualty insurance cover. The definition excludes a policy, a binder, a policy endorsement and a motor vehicle insurance identification card.

The Section applies to a certificate issued in connection with a contract related to property, operations or risks located in Illinois. That holds wherever the policyholder, insurer, producer or requester is.

Subsection (e) says a person may not prepare, issue, request or require a certificate that contains false or misleading information about the policy, or that alters, amends or extends the cover. The ban reaches the party asking for the certificate and the one issuing it.

Subsection (f) bars a certificate from containing a warranty that the policy complies with the insurance or indemnification requirements of a contract. A contract number or description on the certificate does not warrant compliance.

Subsection (g) says a person is not entitled to notice of cancellation, nonrenewal or a material change unless the policy or an endorsement gives notice rights. A certificate does not alter those terms. The Director of Insurance can examine and investigate, and can impose penalties under Section 401 of the Code.

Certificate wording the regulators mention

OCI says a certificate should carry words such as: "This certificate of insurance neither affirmatively nor negatively amends, extends or alters the coverage afforded by the policies described herein." ACORD and ISO preprinted certificate forms carry a similar statement.

Contracts that ask for more

New Jersey's Bulletin 11-04 notes a concern the Department had already raised in Bulletin 98-05: some public or commercial organisations might be asking contractors for certificates that show terms inconsistent with the underlying policy or contract. The Department says it appears the practice may continue, and urges insurers to review their oversight of certificates.

Additional insured endorsements are outside what the four sources describe. Illinois treats a policy endorsement as a different document from a certificate, and the other three treat the policy itself as the place where cover is set.

Sources