Climate-ready street trees: how the Chicago-region assessment, the US handouts and TDAG rate species
The Chicago region scored 163 tree species for climate vulnerability, the Climate Change Response Framework copied the method to 22 US urban areas, and TDAG published a UK species guide covering over 280.
Checked against the sources at the bottom of this page on October 15, 2026. Rules, fees and pay change: the source has the last word.
The Climate Change Response Framework handouts describe themselves as a complement to other tree selection resources.
The Chicago region assessment
The Northern Institute of Applied Climate Science, the U.S. Forest Service and partners including The Morton Arboretum, The Field Museum, the Chicago Botanic Garden and the Chicago Region Trees Initiative used the Chicago region as a test case. Leslie Brandt and colleagues described the work in the December 2017 issue of Arborist News. The U.S. Climate Resilience Toolkit case study says the partners assessed more than 150 species that were growing in the region or recommended for planting.
Three inputs fed the rating. For native trees, the team used modelled habitat suitability from the Forest Service. For non-native trees and cultivars, it compared each species' known heat and hardiness zone range with current and projected zones. It then scored each species' adaptability, meaning its tolerance of disturbance and its capacity to cope with different urban sites. The article gives the example of a species tolerant only to Heat Zone 7, which counts as negatively affected because the area may reach Heat Zone 8 within a tree's lifespan.
Most of the region's trees had low or low-moderate vulnerability, but many of those were invasive, such as European buckthorn and Amur honeysuckle. Many native species at the southern edge of their range were vulnerable. The article prints three lists of ten.
| Group | Species as listed |
|---|---|
| Common species with high vulnerability | Balsam fir, black cherry, Douglas-fir, eastern hemlock, gray birch, jack pine, paper birch, quaking aspen, white pine, white spruce |
| Common species with low vulnerability | Amur honeysuckle (invasive), black locust, black oak, boxelder, bur oak, European glossy buckthorn (invasive), Freeman maple, ginkgo, littleleaf linden, northern hackberry |
| Species native to North America, not common in the area, that may gain suitable habitat | Black gum, chestnut oak, chinkapin oak, common persimmon, cucumbertree, mockernut hickory, pignut hickory, Shumard oak, sugarberry, yellowwood |
The case study reports that the Village of Riverside replaced some lost ash trees with resilient species such as buckeye and pecan. It says the Chicago Region Trees Initiative planned to update its recommended planting list toward climate-adapted species.
The Chicago handout
The Climate Change Response Framework handout for Chicago, Illinois, rates 163 species. Its adaptability score is positive for a species tolerant of many disturbances that can be planted on varied sites, and negative for one highly susceptible or limited to specific sites. Zone suitability tests each species against hardiness and heat zones through the end of the 21st century, under a low (RCP 4.5) and a high (RCP 8.5) emissions scenario.
| Period | Hardiness zone | Heat zone |
|---|---|---|
| 1980 to 2010 | 5 to 6 | 5 |
| 2010 to 2039 | 6 (low); 6 to 7 (high) | 6 (both) |
| 2040 to 2069 | 6 to 7 (low); 7 (high) | 7 (low); 8 (high) |
| 2070 to 2099 | 6 to 7 (low); 7 to 8 (high) | 7 (low); 9 (high) |
Of the 163 species, 50 score high on adaptability, 88 medium and 25 low. Twenty-six score high and are suitable for both emissions scenarios. Two of the 26 are marked invasive, and the handout marks 16 species as invasive in all.
- A to B: Allegheny serviceberry, Amur honeysuckle (invasive), bald cypress, black gum, blackhaw, bur oak, burningbush (invasive).
- C to D: chestnut oak, Chinese fringetree, Chinese juniper, common hackberry, common persimmon, downy serviceberry.
- E to J: eastern redcedar, ginkgo, ironwood, Japanese pagoda tree, Japanese zelkova.
- K to R: Kentucky coffeetree, musclewood, rose of Sharon.
- S to Y: saucer magnolia, smoketree, white fringetree, willow oak, yellowwood.
The 25 low-adaptability species include sweetgum, tuliptree, white ash, pecan and white oak. Robusta poplar is the only species marked unsuitable under both scenarios. The handout carries its own caution: some species have climate benefits but may be unsuitable for other reasons, such as invasive potential or susceptibility to pests or pathogens.
The same method in other cities
The Climate Change Response Framework page lists handouts for 22 urban areas.
- Midwest and Great Lakes: Ann Arbor, Ashland, Chicago, Des Moines, Detroit, Grand Rapids, Green Bay, Indianapolis, Middleton, Milwaukee, Monroe, Racine, Rochester (Minnesota), Stevens Point, the Twin Cities.
- Elsewhere: Austin, Boston, Lexington, New York City, Phoenix, Puget Sound (Seattle area), Washington, D.C.
Boston, Indianapolis, Phoenix and Providence also have a version with carbon and health detail. Most handouts were created in 2020 and 2021 and have not been updated. They were written for species planted in developed sites.
TDAG: a UK species guide
The Trees and Design Action Group page for Tree Species Selection for Green Infrastructure: A Guide for Specifiers describes a research-based decision tool covering over 280 species. It gives use potential, size and crown characteristics, natural habitat, environmental tolerance, ornamental qualities, potential issues and notable varieties. Andrew Hirons of University Centre Myerscough and Henrik Sjöman of the Swedish University of Agricultural Sciences wrote it, as the main result of a Natural Environment Research Council project. English, French and Dutch versions and a companion database are offered, and TDAG puts the dataset under a CC-BY-NC licence.
Sources
- Climate Change Response Framework, Urban Forests: Tree Species Vulnerability Handouts, read October 15, 2026
- Climate Change Response Framework, Climate Change Vulnerability of Urban Trees: Chicago, Illinois, handout, read October 15, 2026
- Leslie A. Brandt and others, Adapting Urban Forests to Climate Change in the Chicago Region, Arborist News, December 2017, read October 15, 2026
- U.S. Climate Resilience Toolkit, Fortifying Chicago's Urban Forest, case study, read October 15, 2026
- Trees and Design Action Group, Tree Species Selection for Green Infrastructure: A Guide for Specifiers, read October 15, 2026