ArbNation Join free

Conifer identification: needles, pegs, cones and the pine, spruce and fir test

Keys sort conifers by how the needles sit on the twig: in bundles for pine, on pegs for spruce, on smooth round scars for fir. Cornell, Ohio State, Michigan State and the Forestry Commission each give their version.

Checked against the sources at the bottom of this page on October 15, 2026. Rules, fees and pay change: the source has the last word.

This page draws on Cornell, Ohio State, Michigan State and the Forestry Commission. It does not identify trees from descriptions or photos and does not say what should be done with any tree. The conifers of North America and Britain are covered by four sources, and each describes its own region's trees.

Evergreen, conifer and cedar are loose labels

Cornell Small Farms points out that the common labels do not fit every tree. Evergreen applies to most, but eastern larch, or tamarack, drops its needles, and every species sheds some needles each year. Conifer applies because most fruit is a cone, yet the fruit of eastern red cedar and pasture juniper is a berry-like cone with fleshy scales grown together. Eastern red cedar is a juniper, in the cedar family Cupressaceae, along with northern white-cedar (Thuja). The Forestry Commission booklet notes that several kinds of tree yield timber sold as cedar. It adds that the hemlock tree owes its name to a supposed resemblance between the smell of its crushed foliage and that of the poisonous hemlock plant.

Ohio State Extension names pine, spruce and fir as medium to tall conifers, 60 to 200 feet, that are conical or pyramidal in shape. The extension fact sheet says even well-versed gardeners confuse them.

The first test: how needles attach

GenusNeedles, cones and other marks
Pine (Pinus)In bundles of 2, 3 or 5, called fascicles, wrapped at the base by a papery sheath. Cornell: the sheath persists on hard pines and drops in the first season on eastern white pine, the one soft pine in the Northeast. Cones hang down with thick, woody scales (Ohio State). Cornell: pine cones have few scales compared with other Pinaceae.
Spruce (Picea)Single, four-sided, stiff and sharp, on a short woody peg that stays on the twig after the needle drops (Cornell calls it a sterigma, about 1 mm long; Ohio State calls it a pulvinus). Needles roll between the fingers. Cones hang down with thin, papery scales that stay on the central stalk (Ohio State). Odor pungent to fetid (Cornell).
Fir (Abies)Single, flat, soft, set directly on the twig; a fallen needle leaves a smooth, round scar. Ohio State: the needle base looks like a suction cup. Cornell: citrus smell. Cones stand upright, and the scales and seeds fall away from the stalk on the tree (Ohio State). Cornell gives a 3 in. upright cone for balsam fir.
Hemlock (Tsuga)Cornell: eastern hemlock has two-ranked needles plus tiny ones sporadically on the upper side of the twig. Forestry Commission: needles of markedly varying lengths crowded along the twig. Cornell: marble-sized, pendant cones with scales that stay on; a drooping leader; no citrus smell.
Larch (Larix)Clustered on woody spur shoots (Cornell), 20 to 30 to a knob (Forestry Commission); the only common deciduous conifer. Cornell: cones about hemlock-sized but held erect; European and Japanese larch have much bigger cones than the native species.
Cedar and cypress (Thuja, Chamaecyparis)Scale-like and flattened, hugging the twig so that twig and buds are hidden, like a fern frond (Forestry Commission). Cornell: needles are keeled. Forestry Commission: Western red cedar has small, slender brown cones; Lawson cypress has globular cones. Cornell: northern white-cedar cones look like miniature wooden roses.
Juniper (Juniperus)Awl-like or scale-like (Cornell); sharp needles in threes all round the stem (Forestry Commission). Berry-like cone; pasture juniper's may be twice the size of eastern red cedar's (Cornell).

Ohio State puts the sequence in three questions: whether needles attach singly or in groups, whether a single needle attaches directly or through a wooden peg, and whether it is flat or angled. The Forestry Commission booklet follows a similar route. It sorts first by fern-like foliage that hides the twig, then larch clusters, then juniper in groups of three, then pines in groups of two, three or five, then hemlock and yew. For the rest it asks whether the needle stands on a peg, which marks a spruce. If the needle leaves a small round scar, it is a silver fir of the genus Abies or a Douglas fir. The booklet separates Douglas fir by slender, brown, papery buds, where the silver firs have blunter and often resinous ones.

Name confusions the sources flag

  • Western red cedar and Lawson cypress: the Forestry Commission says they look so much alike that they are often confused. Cedar twig tips feel stout and fleshy, and cypress tips are thin. Cedar is yellowish-green with an acrid scent when crushed, and cypress tends to be bluish-green and smells more resinous.
  • Fir and hemlock: Cornell says eastern hemlock resembles balsam fir except for its cones, its piney smell and its dwarfed needles on the upper twig.
  • Cedar and juniper: eastern red cedar is a juniper, and the cedar family also holds Thuja, as described above.
  • Genus names versus common names: Cornell notes that every genus has more than one common name, and the Forestry Commission points to Latin scientific names, used internationally, for the same reason.

Limits

The Forestry Commission booklet warns that its characteristic leaf patterns do not appear on upright leading shoots, young seedlings or many ornamental garden strains, which carry juvenile foliage of a different pattern. It says to ignore the youngest bit nearest the tip and not to rely on a single feature. Michigan State Extension's upper-peninsula key calls conifers the easiest group on which to learn keys, and warns that words such as often and usually do not mean always. Its key covers white, red, jack and Scots pine, tamarack, northern white-cedar, white and black spruce, Canada yew, eastern hemlock and balsam fir. It names Austrian pine, Colorado blue spruce, Norway spruce, Douglas-fir, European larch, eastern red-cedar, juniper, white fir and Fraser fir as alien conifers not included.

Cornell leaves identification to the species level to a good book, and Ohio State lists bark, needle length, color and further cone details as the next tools. The bark side is in bark identification. A conifer with a regional page on this site is eastern white pine.

Sources