ArbNation Join free

Decay detection by sound: sounding a trunk with a mallet

Sounding means striking a trunk and listening for hollow or abnormal tones. A US Forest Service report and a 2011 journal study treat it as an initial screen that depends on the evaluator's experience.

Checked against the sources at the bottom of this page on October 21, 2026. Rules, fees and pay change: the source has the last word.

This page draws on what the named agencies and journals publish. It is not training and does not teach the work. Three sources mention sounding: the USDA Forest Service San Dimas Technology and Development Center, a paper in Arboriculture and Urban Forestry, and a nondestructive testing paper on red pines.

What sounding is

The 2011 Arboriculture and Urban Forestry paper by Anthony Mucciardi, Christopher Luley and Kevin Gormally calls sounding a practical and widely accepted field technique for first establishing the presence or absence of internal decay. The arborist strikes the trunk with a mallet, hammer or other solid object and listens for abnormal characteristics linked to decay. The sound comes from vibration waves moving through sound wood, decayed wood or internal voids. The paper links the characteristic thud to hollow trees.

The Forest Service report

The San Dimas center compiled the equipment used to detect decay in standing trees. Under the heading Visual and Manual, it lists the mallet beside the increment borer. Tapping on a tree with a mallet, hard plastic recommended, while listening can sometimes indicate whether a cavity or dead wood is present. The report calls the mallet and the increment borer simple techniques. For the Visual and Manual group it lists one advantage, quick and easy to transport. Its listed limitation is the one it gives for all the equipment: it needs experience and knowledge of decay.

The report also states that detecting decay does not necessarily mean a tree is hazardous. Professional experience and sound judgment decide that. It cites a rule of thumb from Minnesota Department of Natural Resources and USDA Forest Service guidance of 1996, a 25 mm ring of sound wood for every 150 mm of stem diameter.

Limits the journal reports

  • Evidence: No research literature appears to address sounding with statistical rigor.
  • Skill: Sounding is a learned skill, and its effectiveness depends on the evaluator's experience with different species, bark thickness, trunk diameter and amount of decay.
  • Noise: The abstract cites subjective evaluation of the sonic variations from different wood species and densities, and varied ambient noise conditions.

The paper tested an accelerometer and a statistical classifier on 36 cut trunk samples. The classifier identified the decay status of 83 percent of them, 30 of 36. It was right for 14 of 15 sound samples, 93 percent, and 16 of 21 decayed samples, 76 percent. The authors state that the results cannot be transferred to real tree inspection without testing on standing trees.

Mallet sounding in a field test

Allison, Wang and Ross tested 10 red pines supporting a ropes course at the US Forest Service Nesbit Lake Camp in Michigan in September 2006. Their measuring and visual assessment tools included a steel tape, a rubber sounding mallet, binoculars and a hand trowel. The decay detection protocol had five steps:

  1. A visual tree assessment screening for suspect trees.
  2. A single-path stress wave test as a screen for probable defective trees.
  3. A multi-path stress wave tomography test on the trees and heights flagged by the screen.
  4. A parallel multi-path sonic wave test.
  5. A resistance micro-drill test at critical areas found earlier.

The mallet is listed as equipment but is not one of the five numbered steps. The authors concluded that single-path sonic testing with visual assessment, followed by tomography and micro-drilling, was a reasonable and effective method of detecting decay in red pine. Instrument-based methods are described in sonic and acoustic tomography, and the wider picture in how reliably arborists judge decay and stem failure.

Sources