ArbNation Join free

Decay resistance by tree species: heartwood ratings in the Wood Handbook and AS 5604

Two published rating systems sort species by how well cut heartwood resists decay fungi. The US Wood Handbook uses four groups, and the Australian standard AS 5604 uses four classes with service lives.

Checked against the sources at the bottom of this page on October 16, 2026. Rules, fees and pay change: the source has the last word.

Both ratings are for heartwood in timber, not for decay in a standing tree. Neither says anything about the state of any single tree. They are tables of how species perform when the wood is cut and used.

US Wood Handbook, Table 14-1

Chapter 14 of the Wood Handbook, report FPL-GTR-282, was written by Arango, Lebow and Glaeser of the US Forest Products Laboratory in 2021. The heartwood of common native species varies in natural decay resistance, and untreated sapwood of nearly all species has low resistance. Table 14-1 groups some domestic woods by average heartwood decay resistance.

Some domestic woods by heartwood decay resistance, Wood Handbook Table 14-1
GroupSpecies the table lists
Very resistantBlack locust, red mulberry, Osage-orange, Pacific yew
ResistantOld-growth baldcypress, catalpa, cedars (Atlantic white, eastern red, incense, northern white, Port-Orford, western red, yellow), chestnut, Arizona cypress, junipers, mesquite, white oaks, old-growth redwood, sassafras, black walnut
Moderately resistantYoung-growth baldcypress, black cherry, Douglas-fir, honey locust, western larch, old-growth eastern white, longleaf and slash pines, young-growth redwood, tamarack
Slightly or nonresistantRed alder, ashes, aspens, beech, birches, buckeye, butternut, cottonwood, elms, basswood, true firs, hackberry, hemlocks, hickories, magnolia, maples, other pines, spruces, sweetgum, sycamore, tanoak, willows, yellow-poplar

Precise ratings are not possible, the handbook notes, because wood differs within a species and service conditions vary. Old-growth wood is often more resistant than wood from younger trees. Resistance may be less in ground contact or in warm, humid climates. Table notes say more than one species is included for white oaks and for the other pines, and that limited durability data were available for some species.

AS 5604 durability classes

WoodSolutions, run by Forest and Wood Products Australia, publishes the four classes of the standard AS 5604. It defines natural durability as the resistance of heartwood to decay and insect attack, and counts sapwood as non-durable whatever the species.

AS 5604 durability classes, as WoodSolutions prints them
Class and ratingLife above ground and in groundSpecies listed
1, very durableMore than 40 years above ground; more than 25 years in groundSpotted gum, ironbark, tallowwood
2, durable15 to 40 years above ground; 15 to 25 years in groundBlackbutt, jarrah, silvertop ash
3, moderately durable7 to 15 years above ground; 5 to 15 years in groundVictorian ash, Tasmanian oak
4, non-durable0 to 7 years above ground; under 5 years in groundRadiata pine, slash pine

The life figures assume good detailing and maintenance, and the classes rest on test averages that may not reflect extreme microclimates. WoodSolutions also cautions against comparing a Class 1 rating under one standard with ratings under others such as EN 350 or AWPA.

Where the two systems differ

The handbook sorts species into four groups without service lives. AS 5604 gives four classes with years above and in the ground. The two lists cover different species and cannot be matched row by row. A species named in one is not placed in the other. Decay by fungus and rot type is in white, brown and soft rot compared.

Sources