ArbNation Join free

Girdling roots and stem-girdling roots: what extension services and research describe

Girdling roots circle or press on the trunk and can cause crown dieback, trunk cracks and tree death. Extension services and a University of Florida study trace them to container production, planting depth and mulch on the root ball.

Checked against the sources at the bottom of this page on October 16, 2026. Rules, fees and pay change: the source has the last word.

This page draws on extension publications and a journal study. It is not training and does not teach the work. It is not a diagnosis of any tree and does not say what should be done with one. The other conditions are compared in structural defects in trees.

Definitions

The University of Florida publication ENH1246 says roots that circle or girdle the lower trunk can make a tree unstable by reducing the extent of its root area. Girdling roots can compress the stem, causing crown dieback and decay or structural weakness at the base. Its photo of a circling root on a live oak ties the defect to improper container nursery production.

The Colorado State Forest Service planting guide says girdling roots encircle or confine the trunk, causing significant crown dieback or tree death. It says they act like a boa constrictor on the trunk, cutting off water and nutrient transport, and that many tree failures follow girdling roots that nobody dealt with at planting.

The University of Florida hurricane publication FR172 calls them stem girdling roots. Death can occur when a root encircles most of the trunk. It lists them among its signs for removal when they come with dead spots and cracks in the trunk, because such trees are less stable.

Container production

Penn State Extension explains the start of the problem. Nursery trees grown in light plastic containers send roots to the container wall, where they turn. In no time the container is full of circling roots and the plant is pot-bound. Several years after planting, those roots begin to girdle or strangle the stem, in the end killing the tree or shrub. Penn State names air-pruning containers, and containers painted with a copper hydroxide solution, as ways nurseries cut circling roots.

It also says a tree planted a little deep in its container develops more root defects. When planted deeper again in the landscape, the root system often grows up and then circles or girdles the stem with time.

Planting depth in the nursery

Gilman, Harchick and Paz tested depth in a University of Florida study in Arboriculture and Urban Forestry in 2010. They planted magnolia, red maple and elm cuttings either shallow (13 mm) or deep (64 mm) into small containers, then shallow or deep into larger ones. The results:

  • Elm and magnolia showed more stem girdling roots the deeper they went into the first container. On elm, 69 percent of the trunk circumference was girdled when deep, against 36.1 percent when shallow.
  • Maple was not affected at that stage because it grew new roots from the buried stem. Planting maple and elm deep into the next size led to more girdling.
  • More than two thirds of the trunk circumference of maple and elm touched girdling-root bark when planted deep into the second container size. For even-depth trees it was just over one third.
  • Most root defects sat below the substrate surface. A visible root flare did not predict whether defects existed.

The authors call planting depth most important at the move into the second container size. They link girdling to main roots being turned downward and then up and around by the container wall.

Flare, mulch and cutting

The Colorado guide starts with finding the root flare, since a graft point and roots grown from adventitious buds are not the root flare. In its photo the true flare lay about 3 inches below the soil line, with many adventitious and girdling roots above it. The guide says mulch on top of the root ball can increase the potential for circling roots and lets moisture sit against the trunk. The guide sets mulch at the edges of the root ball, 3 to 4 inches deep at most. See also planting depth and root flare and mulch depth and volcanoes.

Colorado calls an older advice, slicing through the circling roots, ineffective because new roots keep circling. Penn State says research shows it is best to sever circling roots with a sharp knife, handsaw or spade, or to shave the container-grown root ball, because cut roots regenerate quickly into the landscape soil.

Sources