ArbNation Join free

Root-collar and root-flare defects: what the standards and agencies describe

Ohio, Missouri, Maryland and Minnesota agencies link a buried root flare to stem girdling roots, below-ground trunk rot and storm breakage. A Minnesota manual treats dead root flares as a sign of root and butt rot.

Checked against the sources at the bottom of this page on October 19, 2026. Rules, fees and pay change: the source has the last word.

The root collar is where the stem and the root system meet. The root flare is the part of it where the trunk widens as it passes into the topmost roots.

The root flare

The Ohio Department of Natural Resources article on planting trees too deeply describes the root collar as having a flare where it passes from stem wood to roots. Four to eleven large transport roots radiate from it. University of Maryland Extension describes the flare as the area at the base of the trunk where the topmost roots emerge, and notes that many trees widen and curve outward there like the base of a wine glass.

The Missouri Department of Conservation observes that trees that grew naturally flare out at the ground, pines excepted. A trunk that goes straight into the ground with no flare, it says, suggests that the roots are buried.

How the flare comes to be buried

Missouri reports that trees reach buyers with up to 12 inches of extra soil on top of their roots, and that a purchased tree may already carry six or more inches of soil above the roots. Ohio names two nursery practices, hilling soil around the base and setting liners deep in the beds. It adds that the roots can be several inches too deep when the soil line of the ball is planted level with the site. Maryland adds mulch piled against the trunk, which keeps the bark moist and can encourage new roots to sprout above the main supporting roots.

Decline, girdling and breakage

Ohio finds that buried roots decline in health, with reduced growth, atypical leaf size and colour, more disease and less cold hardiness. Trees in poor condition show decay, cracks and excess deadwood. Maryland lists lower bark rotting, reduced oxygen to the roots, disease and pest problems, and girdling roots. Missouri names below-ground trunk rot and root suffocation.

Maryland describes stem girdling roots as roots that grow around the base of the tree rather than outward. As they enlarge, they compress the water- and nutrient-conducting tissues. Ohio and Missouri also name them. Missouri puts the onset at about 10 to 20 years after planting. It cites a five-year University of Minnesota study in which more than 80 percent of the declining sugar maples had stem girdling roots.

Ohio cites research that as little as one inch of soil over the flare can disguise stem girdling roots, and that sugar maple health declined at four inches. In a survey of 302 street trees, transport roots of every species were buried under one to 11 inches of soil. Ohio also reports that after the 1998 windstorms in Minnesota, 73.3 percent of the lindens lost had broken at compression points from girdling roots, most of them below ground.

Stem-base decay in the Minnesota manual

The Minnesota Department of Natural Resources hazard tree manual lists dead root flares as indicators of root and butt rot. On most conifers, it says a crack arising between two root flares indicates root rot. In birch, cracks at the root collar indicate potential for breakage, and in fir, basal cracks arise from decayed roots.

The manual notes that roots can be severed by trenching, utility installation, road construction or lowering the grade, and that damage from construction can develop into root and butt rots which often lead to stem cracks and tree failure. It lists raising the grade as one cause of root death, and its photo of trees with raised grades notes a lack of root flares near the groundline.

Related pages

Girdling roots have their own page on stem girdling roots. Root loss and lifting are on root damage and root plate lifting, and planting depth is covered in the guide to planting depth and root flare.

Sources