ArbNation Join free

American chestnut restoration programmes: breeding, transgenic trees and plantings

The American Chestnut Foundation breeds blight-resistant chestnuts by backcrossing and genomic selection, and SUNY-ESF's transgenic Darling line was deregulated by USDA-APHIS on August 28, 2026. The EPA review is still open.

Checked against the sources at the bottom of this page on October 21, 2026. Rules, fees and pay change: the source has the last word.

This page draws on The American Chestnut Foundation (TACF), SUNY-ESF and the Federal Register. It is not a diagnosis of any tree and does not say what should be done with one. The blight itself is covered in the American chestnut species page.

The problem the programmes address

TACF's science plan says chestnut blight, caused by the Asian fungus Cryphonectria parasitica, killed an estimated four billion American chestnuts over the past 100 years. The species survives mostly as stunted sprouts from surviving root systems. TACF's breeding page adds that the fungus makes cankers that girdle the trunk and kill the tree down to its roots, and that a second disease, Phytophthora root rot (PRR), pushed the species toward extinction too.

Earlier attempts

TACF's restoration page lists a series of earlier methods and says no single one will save the tree.

  • 1900s: USDA sent the plant explorer Frank Meyer to China to find a replacement for the American chestnut.
  • 1920s to 1940s: USDA and others bred all available chestnut materials together. The results did not meet every ecological need.
  • 1950s: Ralph Singleton and Albert Dietz exposed thousands of seeds to radiation, hoping for resistance by mutation. The planting is still on display at Sugarloaf Mountain, Maryland.
  • 1970s: Scientists found hypovirulence, where a virus reduces the virulence of the blight fungus.
  • 1980s: Charles Burnham proposed backcross breeding.
  • 1990s: TACF set up a state chapter network of citizen scientists across the eastern United States.

Backcross breeding

TACF's science plan reports 30 years of backcross breeding to capture blight resistance from Chinese chestnut. It involved over 50,000 trees and produced about 500 trees with an average of only 12 percent Chinese chestnut DNA and at least some resistance. The plan calls that output too small and too weakly resistant for restoration without more breeding. Genetic analysis showed that blight resistance is controlled by many more than two or three genes, which explains the modest success.

Recurrent genomic selection

TACF's breeding page names recurrent genomic selection (RGS) as its main strategy. A computer model links a tree's DNA profile to field-measured disease responses such as canker size. The model picks the most resistant parents, and the top 10 percent of their offspring become the parents of the next round.

  • Model data: more than 5,500 trees assessed across 100 orchard locations from 2018, and about 5,000 trees genotyped with Virginia Tech.
  • Crosses: controlled crosses began in 2023, with American ancestry kept above 70 percent.
  • Four tracks: three backcross-hybrid tracks aim at blight resistance, at blight and PRR together, and at PRR. A fourth aims at blight resistance in offspring of large surviving American chestnuts with 100 percent American ancestry.
  • Speed breeding: lighting and fertiliser treatments are being tested to bring flowering forward to one to two years instead of the usual five to eight.

TACF scores resistance on a scale where 0 is the average of wild-type American chestnut and 100 is the average of Chinese chestnut. Its simulations for the first round put the top 10 percent at 82 for blight in track 1 and at 69 for blight and 40 for PRR in track 2. Track 3 reaches 49 for PRR, and the large-surviving-tree track reaches 61. TACF's 2026 totals are 115 crosses, 6,878 trees genotyped, 2,150 seedlings inoculated and 5,403 trees planted.

Transgenic Darling trees

TACF's science plan describes the transgenic approach as inserting a wheat gene for oxalate oxidase, an enzyme that breaks down the oxalic acid the fungus uses as a toxin. The Darling line was developed at SUNY-ESF in 2016. TACF reports that years of testing showed varying blight resistance, higher mortality and other performance problems it links to the gene running all the time. Partners are testing lines that switch the gene on only near a wound.

The Federal Register notice of August 28, 2026 gives the regulatory result. USDA-APHIS found that Darling 54 American chestnut is unlikely to pose a greater plant pest risk than the nonmodified comparator, so it is no longer regulated under 7 CFR part 340. APHIS received ESF's petition on January 21, 2020, and logged 4,337 comments on it and 174,116 on the revised petition and draft assessments.

The sources name the line differently. The notice says the original petition referred to Darling 58, but a 2016 labeling error meant nearly all the offspring tested were Darling 54, and ESF amended the petition in August 2024. TACF's restoration page still uses the Darling 58 name.

What is still under review

SUNY-ESF's regulatory page says the Darling trees are still under review by the Environmental Protection Agency, because the gene is tied to a pathogen and falls under pesticide rules. ESF is also seeking an exemption from pesticide registration. It expects the first phase to bring temporary limits on distribution of seedlings, possibly by region, and says the timing is hard to predict. The FDA does not need to review the trees to allow distribution, though ESF filed nutritional analyses.

Plantings and trials

TACF runs silvicultural and reintroduction trials that compare canopy treatments, planting stock, spacing, planting season, site preparation and wildlife protection. The trials use wild-type trees, hybrids and, in limited and highly regulated cases, transgenic trees. Germplasm Conservation Orchards hold nuts and grafts from the surviving southern trees, where genetic diversity is highest. With mine-reclamation partners TACF has helped plant more than 1.8 million seedlings of high-value hardwoods, American chestnut among them, on nearly 3,000 acres in eight states since 2009.

Sources