Birch dieback and maple decline: what the agencies record
Birch dieback and maple decline are slow crown declines with more than one cause. The USDA Forest Service, University of Wisconsin Extension and the US Geological Survey record the stresses, the fungi that follow and the root freezing behind some episodes.
Checked against the sources at the bottom of this page on October 21, 2026. Rules, fees and pay change: the source has the last word.
These are descriptions of declines in the sources, not a diagnosis of any tree. The tree dieback page covers the general pattern.
Maple decline: a long record
David Houston's history of sugar maple decline for the USDA Forest Service (1999) says only a few episodes of sugar maple dieback or decline were recorded in the first half of the 20th century. The last 50 years brought many reports from both cities and forests. A defoliation-triggered decline in Wisconsin in the late 1950s, called maple blight, prompted the first multidisciplinary study. That research and later investigations gave the conceptual framework for a model of sequential, stress-initiated cause and effect.
| Setting | Stresses named |
|---|---|
| Urban maples | Soil compaction, drought, impeded soil water, toxic road deicing salt |
| Forest and sugarbush maples | Insect defoliation or drought, alone or together |
| Eastern Canada, northern New England, New York | Root freezing in thaw-freeze periods and deep cold, especially with little or no snow cover |
Houston adds that mortality of stressed trees is often caused or hastened when opportunistic secondary organisms invade roots or twigs, especially Armillaria root rot fungi and probably Xylaria. Southern Quebec had serious maple decline in the 1980s and 1990s that was first blamed on atmospheric deposition. Houston reports that root freezing is believed responsible, and that atmospheric deposition has been discounted as a direct cause. The long-term and perhaps complex effects on tree health of deposition-hastened changes in soil chemistry, especially in soils susceptible to acidification, were the primary subjects of the investigations then current.
Collar rot and basal canker in Wisconsin
University of Wisconsin Extension publication A2532, Maple Decline: Collar Rot and Basal Canker Complex (1997), reports sugar maples along streets, in parks and around homes that lose vigour and die slowly a few years after the crown symptoms appear. Trees of any age seem susceptible, and as many as 80 percent of the maples in some places showed signs. The authors say the phenomenon is not fully understood. Their research found many Wisconsin maples declining because of fungal invasion of the root or lower trunk.
The symptoms they list include early fall colour on one to several branches, usually on one side or in the upper crown, with smaller and fewer leaves that turn red or yellow early, and a heavy seed set. More branches show symptoms each year, and trees may survive from one to several years. Affected trees usually lack a trunk flare and surface buttress roots. Sugar maples are especially susceptible and Norway maples are less so.
At the root collar, the publication lists deep bark cracks, loose bark that sounds hollow when tapped, patchy discolouration and oozing. Basal cankers have loose bark, and the exposed cambium is tan, dark brown or reddish instead of white or light green. They run from 1 to several inches around, with 1 to 30 or more on one tree. Girdling roots can produce the same crown symptoms as collar rot, and often occur with it.
Two soil fungi appear to be involved. Phytophthora citricola, a water mold active in wet periods, is associated with collar rot. Fusarium, which does not need wet conditions, is associated with basal canker. The authors say how the fungi invade is not yet known. The publication says buttress roots of affected trees are nearly always several inches too deep, and says the problem apparently arises in part because transplanted trees develop their roots several inches below the soil surface. It names mechanical damage, roadside salt and micronutrient disorders as other causes of decline, and says no control measures have been developed for trees already showing decline.
Birch dieback: a Nebraska study and the record behind it
The USGS Open-File Report 2009-1221 (Stroh and Miller) studies paper birch in the Niobrara River Valley of north-central Nebraska. More than 30 sites lie along about 80 kilometres of river. The birch there are relict populations that have persisted since the Wisconsin glaciation. Dieback of canopy-sized birch probably began around or after the early 1980s. Crown dieback begins in the upper crown at the tips of fine twigs and moves toward the trunk.
The report summarizes earlier cases. From 1935 to the mid-1940s, dieback of birch in Nova Scotia and Maine killed 67 percent of the paper and yellow birch in Maine. No clear reason was found, and likely causes included low winter temperatures, late spring freezes and other climate abnormalities. Armillaria root fungus and the bronze birch borer were present in healthy and dying birch, but neither was the primary cause. Dieback in eastern and upper Midwestern forests has been associated with infection by the silver-leaf fungus Chondrostereum purpureum, with cold winter temperatures and minimal snow cover, and with early spring thaws followed by hard frosts. The report dates birch dieback episodes in eastern forests from 1976 to 1995, in Appalachian forests from 1983 to 1989, and in midwestern forests from 1954 to 1963 and 1977 to 1993.
The report ties crown dieback to rootlet death. An early spring thaw and freeze, with March growing degree days above 50 followed by April or May temperatures below minus 4 °C, is enough to injure roots and cause dieback in paper birch, citing earlier research. In the Nebraska data, freeze and thaw conditions capable of injuring rootlets were more frequent in 1978 to 2007 than in 1948 to 1977, a rise the report calls significant. Stands with temperatures like those at the Nature Conservancy station held a smaller share of living trees, and upper-river sites had healthier trees than north-bank sites.
Where the sources differ
The Wisconsin publication says many Wisconsin maples are declining because of fungal invasion of the root or lower trunk. The Forest Service history puts the start of decline on a stress, with fungi following. The USGS birch report says Armillaria and the bronze birch borer were not the primary cause of the older dieback. None of the three gives a single cause for all cases.
Sources
- USDA Forest Service, Houston, History of sugar maple decline, in Sugar maple ecology and health (GTR-NE-261), 1999, read October 21, 2026
- University of Wisconsin-Extension, Heimann, Worf, Kuntz and Drilias, Maple Decline: Collar Rot and Basal Canker Complex (A2532, SR-09-97), read October 21, 2026
- US Geological Survey, Stroh and Miller, Paper Birch Decline in the Niobrara River Valley, Nebraska (Open-File Report 2009-1221), 2009, read October 21, 2026