Western gall rust, comandra rust and pine-pine rusts: what the agencies record
Western gall rust passes from pine to pine and makes round galls on two- and three-needle pines. Comandra blister rust needs a second host, bastard toadflax. The USDA Forest Service, UC IPM and the University of Arizona record both.
Checked against the sources at the bottom of this page on October 21, 2026. Rules, fees and pay change: the source has the last word.
At a glance
| Item | Western gall rust | Comandra blister rust |
|---|---|---|
| Fungus | Cronartium harknessii | Cronartium comandrae |
| Second host | None; pine to pine | Comandra pallida, bastard toadflax |
| Pines named | Shore, lodgepole, Aleppo, Bishop, Monterey, ponderosa, Scots | Ponderosa and Mondell (Afghan) pine |
| Sign on the pine | Round galls on branches and trunks | Orange blisters on bark; dieback |
| Regulated | Not named as regulated or notifiable in any of the three sources | |
Western gall rust: hosts and signs
The USDA Forest Service Alaska Region says the fungus causes spherical galls on the branches and main stems of two- and three-needled pines. In Alaska the hosts are shore pine and lodgepole pine. UC IPM adds Aleppo, Bishop, Monterey, ponderosa and Scots pine for California. UC IPM notes infections are often within 10 to 20 feet of the ground. Young galls are 2 to 3 inches across near dead branch tips, and galled stems may ooze sap. Beyond a gall, the foliage may be stunted and bushy, and the tip may die back or break off.
Some pines are infected at the base of the main stem. If they live long, they can develop a large depression on one side of the lower trunk, called a hip canker. The Forest Service saw the fungus forming spores at the edge of a diamond-shaped bole canker in Gustavus in 2017, which suggests it causes that canker type.
Western gall rust: how it spreads
Unlike many rusts, western gall rust spreads from pine to pine and needs no alternate host, the Forest Service records. In spring the galls release orange spores. UC IPM says wind carries them, and that wet shoots let them infect the terminals of the youngest branches or the main stem tip. The two sources differ on needles. UC IPM records the needles do not become infected. The Forest Service reports spores infect pines through newly emerged foliage, and the fungus then moves from the leaf to the branch.
The infection is perennial. UC IPM says the fungus lives as long as the infected tissue does, which is a few to many years on branches and the life of the tree for infections at the stem base. The Forest Service adds that in British Columbia and the Pacific Northwest, infection comes sporadically in cool, wet "wave years".
Damage and look-alikes
The Forest Service says the disease does most harm on young pines infected on or near the main stem, where it contributes to topkill. Stem infections can let decay fungi in and are common points of stem breakage. The rust seldom kills branches directly. Twig beetles, the Douglas-fir pitch moth and Nectria fungi invade the galls and can girdle branches or stems. UC IPM finds galls on major limbs or the trunk can lead to structural failure.
UC IPM says dying branch tips from the rust resemble pitch canker and certain twig-feeding insects. The galls near the dead tips tell it apart. The guide to pitch canker of pine covers that disease.
Western gall rust in numbers
| Measure | Forest Service, Southeast Alaska |
|---|---|
| Shore pines with the rust, monitoring plots | Almost 90 percent |
| Live pines infected, 46 permanent plots | 85 percent |
| Pines with a gall on the main stem | 34 percent |
| Pines with dead tops tied to stem galls | 25 percent |
| Mapped from the air, 2025 update | 80 acres in 13 locations |
The Forest Service calls the rust extremely widespread with a stable rate over time. Shore pine is not managed for timber in Alaska, so the disease is not actively managed there. Branch death linked to secondary fungi and insects has risen.
Comandra blister rust
The University of Arizona fact sheet, AZ1310, calls comandra blister rust a native disease on ponderosa pine in Arizona. It also hits Mondell pine, which is introduced for landscapes and Christmas trees. The fact sheet says it can kill ponderosa saplings but is not important on mature ponderosa. On Mondell pine it causes branch dieback and kills trees of all ages. Swollen areas develop in branches and trunks, and orange blisters develop as the bark splits. On the alternate host, comandra, the rust shows as orange or rusty pustules on leaves after summer rains.
The fungus has five spore forms and needs both hosts. Spores from comandra infect pine needles after rains in late spring or after the late summer monsoon, and they travel only about one mile. The pine spores that follow in April and May infect comandra, not pine, and can travel many miles. The sheet says humid, moist conditions favor the disease. The disease was severe on Mondell pine in oak habitat near Prescott and Sedona, where comandra is common. It had not been seen in Christmas tree plantations in the Sulfur Springs Valley.
On control, the fact sheet says Mondell pine should not be planted within a mile of comandra. Fungicides may suppress the fungus on pine but have not been shown to kill it, so the sheet does not recommend them. Removing lower limbs and using drip irrigation may reduce humidity but are not reliable controls, it adds.
Stalactiform blister rust, a second pine rust
The Forest Service names stalactiform blister rust, Cronartium coleosporioides, as another stem rust in Alaska. It was confirmed by molecular test near Haines and suspected near Gustavus. The fungus lives part of its life on pines and part on plants of the Scrophulariaceae and Orobanchaceae, especially paintbrush in the genus Castilleja. The guide to white pine blister rust covers another pine rust.
Sources
- USDA Forest Service, Alaska Region, Forest Health, Western Gall Rust (Robin Mulvey, last updated February 27, 2026), read October 21, 2026
- University of California Statewide IPM Program, Western Gall Rust, Home and Landscape pest notes, read October 21, 2026
- University of Arizona Cooperative Extension, Comandra Blister Rust, AZ1310 (Mary W. Olsen, May 2009), read October 21, 2026