Duty of care and arborist advice: the ASCA, Arboricultural Association and ISA codes
ASCA says due care may generally be defined as the level a reasonably prudent professional would show in the same or similar circumstances. The Arboricultural Association code requires insurance against claims, and the ISA code ties advice to the limits of the arborist's ability.
Checked against the sources at the bottom of this page on October 16, 2026. Rules, fees and pay change: the source has the last word.
This page reports what the official source says. It is not legal advice: ask the office named here. The wording comes from three professional-body documents: the ASCA Standards of Professional Practice of July 2024, the Arboricultural Association Code of Conduct and Ethics effective July 29, 2018, and the ISA Certified Arborist Code of Ethics. These are membership and certification rules. None of them is a court ruling or a statute, and none says what a court would decide in a negligence claim.
Due care in the ASCA standards
The American Society of Consulting Arborists (ASCA) requires members to strive to perform consulting services with due care. Standard 1.2 says due care varies with each assignment. It says due care may be defined as the level of care required of a reasonably prudent professional under the same or similar circumstances.
The foreword says ASCA does not warrant that members will follow the standards in any instance. It also says ASCA does not hold itself out as responsible for governing members' business practices or the quality of their work. The standards also cover several points that bear on advice and reports:
- Standard 1.1.E: members take only assignments reasonably within their technical competence, unless they obtain competent help and tell the client.
- Standard 2.1.A: each assignment is defined with the client, including the question to be answered, the level of thoroughness and the scope and limits of any report.
- Standard 2.1.D: conclusions rest on adequate data. Where data cannot reasonably be gathered, members disclose the limits and what they mean for accuracy or reliability.
- Standard 2.2.A: reports disclose and explain limits on authority, competence, scope, data, methodology and results, and limits on how the report is used.
- Standard 2.2.C: members do not misstate the degree of certainty of an opinion.
- Standard 2.2.E: members accept professional responsibility for their own work and conclusions.
- Standard 2.1.F: copies of reports and assignment records are kept five years after completion, or two years after a dispute proceeding ends, whichever is later, or longer if the law requires.
Arboricultural Association: care, limits and insurance
The Arboricultural Association code lists six principles. Due care and diligence is one, with competence, honesty, independent judgement, equality and respect, and professional behaviour. The code says it is not an exhaustive statement of the conduct expected of members, but sets many of the minimum standards that they must observe.
- Clause 1.2: members must know the limits of their competence and commit only to what they can deliver.
- Clause 3.2: members must not make or sign statements or reports contrary to their own bona fide professional opinions.
- Clause 4.1: members must discharge their duty to employers, clients, colleagues and others with due care and diligence.
- Clause 4.2: members must see that work by their employees and sub-contractors meets the same test.
- Clause 4.4: members must be open, transparent and objective, giving clear advice so the client can make informed decisions.
- Clause 4.9: members must take all reasonable care to avoid damaging the environment or creating any danger of death, injury or ill-health or damage to property.
- Clause 4.10: members engaging in arboricultural practice must, where applicable, be adequately insured against claims.
- Clause 7.4: the code applies even where the client has agreed or permitted otherwise.
The Association's web page for the code gives it as Version 1, effective from July 29, 2018. The PDF is marked January 2022.
ISA Certified Arborist Code of Ethics
The International Society of Arboriculture (ISA) code applies to certification candidates and certified arborists, whatever other body they belong to. Under part II.A, certificants must deliver safe and competent services with objective and independent professional judgement. They must recognise the limits of their ability and provide services only when qualified. The certificant decides those limits from qualifications, education, knowledge, skills and experience.
Part II.A.3 asks for a reasonable effort at appropriate referrals when the arborist cannot give competent help. Part II.C.1 requires health and safety procedures that protect clients, employees and the public from conditions where injury or harm is reasonably foreseeable. Part II.A.6 requires truthful representations in advertising, public statements and cost estimates.
The certification agreement printed with the code states that ISA certification is not licensure, registration or authorisation to practise or do business. In item 8 the certificant agrees to indemnify ISA and release it from third-party claims linked to the certification, the certificant's professional services or business activities.
Where the three documents stop
All three set conduct standards for members or certificants. The Arboricultural Association code refers to an examining group or committee for alleged breaches and sets a duty on every member to report alleged breaches to the Association. The ISA code ties certification to its Ethics Case Procedures. Neither document reproduces court rulings, and no court source was located for negligent tree advice. The wider comparison of the codes is in arborist codes of ethics compared.
Sources
- American Society of Consulting Arborists, Standards of Professional Practice, July 2024, read October 16, 2026
- Arboricultural Association, Code of Conduct and Ethics, version 1 effective July 29, 2018, web page, read October 16, 2026
- Arboricultural Association, Code of Conduct and Ethics, PDF dated January 2022, read October 16, 2026
- International Society of Arboriculture, ISA Certified Arborist Code of Ethics, read October 16, 2026