Duty of care for trees in England: the Occupiers' Liability Acts and Witley v Cavanagh
Two Acts set the duty an English occupier owes to people hurt on land, visitors under the 1957 Act and everyone else under the 1984 Act. The Court of Appeal applied the standard to an inspected lime tree in 2018.
Checked against the sources at the bottom of this page on October 16, 2026. Rules, fees and pay change: the source has the last word.
This page reports what the official source says. It is not legal advice: ask the office named here. The duty on English tree owners comes from two Acts of Parliament, on legislation.gov.uk, and from common law, which the Court of Appeal applied in Witley Parish Council v Cavanagh [2018] EWCA Civ 2232. The Arboricultural Association and the National Tree Safety Group describe that case.
Occupiers' Liability Act 1957, section 2
Section 2 applies in England, Wales and Northern Ireland. It gives every occupier a "common duty of care" to all visitors. The Act defines that duty as taking "such care as in all the circumstances of the case is reasonable to see that the visitor will be reasonably safe in using the premises" for the purposes the visitor is invited or permitted to be there.
The circumstances include the care a visitor would ordinarily be expected to take. Subsection 3 gives two examples: an occupier must be prepared for children to be less careful than adults, and may expect a person in the exercise of a calling to guard against the special risks that go with it.
Subsection 4 adds that a warning does not absolve the occupier unless it was enough to let the visitor be reasonably safe. It also covers work done by an independent contractor. The occupier is not answerable for faulty work if it was reasonable to hire that contractor and the occupier took such steps as were reasonable to check the contractor was competent and the work was done properly. Subsection 5 removes any duty for risks the visitor willingly accepted.
Occupiers' Liability Act 1984, section 1
Section 1 applies in England and Wales and covers people who are not visitors. It replaces the common law rules for them. An occupier owes such a person a duty only if three things are true:
- the occupier is aware of the danger or has reasonable grounds to believe it exists;
- the occupier knows or has reasonable grounds to believe the person is in the vicinity of the danger, or may come into it;
- the risk is one against which, in all the circumstances, the occupier may reasonably be expected to offer the person some protection.
Where the duty exists, it is to take such care as is reasonable in all the circumstances to see that the person does not suffer injury by reason of the danger. Subsection 5 lets a warning discharge the duty in an appropriate case, as can steps to discourage people from running the risk. Subsection 6 excludes risks the person willingly accepted.
The common law standard in tree cases
The National Tree Safety Group's landowner summary, hosted by Forest Research, sets out the duty owed outside the Acts. The owner, and anyone who controls how the tree is managed, owes a duty of care at common law to all people who might be injured by the tree. The duty is reasonable care to avoid acts or omissions that cause a reasonably foreseeable risk of injury to persons or property.
The summary reports that courts have set the standard as that of "the reasonable and prudent landowner". The tree owner is not expected to guarantee that a tree is safe. It also reports that the courts have not defined the standard of inspection more precisely, and that they appear to treat it as proportional to the size of the landowner and the resources available to it, in terms of expertise. For trees in a frequently visited zone, it quotes the Health and Safety Executive's 2007 sector information minute: "a system for periodic, proactive checks is appropriate".
Witley Parish Council v Cavanagh
The Arboricultural Association hosts the National Tree Safety Group's comment on the Court of Appeal decision. The case concerned a large, mature lime tree leaning over a road. It fell after a storm and seriously injured the driver of a passing bus. The tree later turned out to have structural decay, which the claimant said an earlier inspection could have found.
The tree had been inspected on a three-year cycle. The experts agreed that cycle was normally adequate for roadside trees. The council was still held liable, because it had not inspected the tree on a two-year cycle.
| Point | Recorded |
|---|---|
| Court and citation | Court of Appeal, [2018] EWCA Civ 2232 |
| Tree | Large mature lime, leaning over a road, structural decay found after the fall |
| Inspection history | Three-year cycle, which the experts agreed was normally adequate for roadside trees |
| Outcome | Council liable for not inspecting on a two-year cycle |
The National Tree Safety Group's view is that the case is not a radical departure from standard industry guidance, including its own, and that it turns on its own facts. It adds that zoning is material in safeguarding the public. Some trees in places with high levels of use may warrant more frequent and thorough inspection than trees elsewhere. Species, life stage, condition and size inform the decision.
Whether inspections are two-yearly or more frequent depends on individual circumstances. Three-yearly or less frequent inspections may be appropriate in others. The Group also said it intended to comment on the court's remarks about how the likelihood of harm is assessed, in its forthcoming revision of the guidance. The Arboricultural Association page carries the Group's own caution that its content is general guidance and not legal advice.
Sources
- UK Parliament, Occupiers' Liability Act 1957, section 2, latest revised version on legislation.gov.uk, read October 16, 2026
- UK Parliament, Occupiers' Liability Act 1984, section 1, latest revised version on legislation.gov.uk, read October 16, 2026
- Arboricultural Association, Witley Parish Council v Cavanagh judgement and implications (National Tree Safety Group comment), read October 16, 2026
- National Tree Safety Group, Common sense risk management of trees: landowner summary, undated PDF on Forest Research, read October 16, 2026