ArbNation Join free

Electrical impedance tomography and the other decay detection methods

The ISA manual puts seven decay tests under advanced assessment, from increment boring to radar and X-ray. Makers, a journal study and a government planning file describe what each one measures and where it falls short.

Checked against the sources at the bottom of this page on October 16, 2026. Rules, fees and pay change: the source has the last word.

The named journals, agencies and makers are described here as published. It is not training and does not teach the work.

The ISA list of decay tests

The International Society of Arboriculture's Tree Risk Assessment Manual (Dunster and others, 2013) groups decay testing under Level 3, advanced assessment. An arborist's report on the NSW planning portal reproduces the list. It names increment boring, drilling with a small-diameter bit, resistance-recording drilling, single-path sonic or stress wave, sonic tomography, electrical impedance tomography, and radiation by radar, X-ray and gamma ray. The manual adds that listing a technique is not an endorsement of it.

At Level 2, the same report lists a visual inspection using binoculars, a mallet, probes or shovels.

What each method is described as measuring

Decay detection methods and what the sources record
MethodWhat the source says it measuresLimit the source records
Increment boringA maker's brochure: 5 mm (about 1/5 in) cores from trees and intact timber, taken by hand or with a portable drillThe brochure lists limited usability in deteriorated timber
Resistance drillingWang and Allison: relative resistance, as drilling torque, while a rotating needle with a 3 mm tip and 1.5 mm shaft is driven in at constant speed. Prolonged low resistance marks decay, cavities or cracks. A maker's brochure adds that profiles give information on the extension trends of internal stem decayWang and Allison: because it requires drilling into the tree, the test is considered minimally invasive
Single-path stress waveWang and Allison: transit time between two probes. Waves travel slower in decayed wood and around hollowsVelocity varies widely even in intact stems, and no standard reference velocity is available
Sonic tomographyA maker's page: shows the full extent of a defect graphicallyWang and Allison, citing a maker's manual: tomographs cannot tell decay from crack-induced acoustic shadows
Electrical impedance tomographyOne maker lists acoustic and impedance tomography under seeing inside the trunk. Another lists resistance tomography among its measurement methodsNicolotti and others, quoted by Wang and Allison: of electric, ultrasonic and georadar tomography on urban trees, ultrasonic proved the most effective

Names for electrical methods

The ISA list says electrical impedance tomography. One maker's tree inspection page says resistance tomography. Another maker lists impedance tomography beside its acoustic tools. None of the opened pages defines the method.

Wang and Allison quote a 2003 study by Nicolotti and others that applied electric, ultrasonic and georadar tomography to urban trees. The methods had different degrees of success. Ultrasonic tomography was the most effective for finding internal decay and estimating the size and shape of the anomaly.

Methods tested together

Wang and Allison tested two century-old red oaks in Madison, Wisconsin, with visual inspection, a single-path stress wave timer, acoustic tomography and resistance microdrilling. The trees were then felled and a disk was taken at each test location.

  • Visual inspection and the single-path timer found a general problem but without specificity.
  • The tomograph showed the general location and size of the defect in each cross-section.
  • Microdrilling was needed to pinpoint defects and to separate decay from cracks.

In tree No. 307 the disks showed heartwood decay at all three elevations tested, along with major internal cracks.

Sources