Failure after construction, trenching and grade change: what BS 5837, ISA and AUF describe
BS 5837 covers trees in design, demolition and construction. The ISA brochure says construction damage can take years to show, and a trial published in Arboriculture & Urban Forestry in 2025 measured stability lost when roots were cut.
Checked against the sources at the bottom of this page on October 19, 2026. Rules, fees and pay change: the source has the last word.
The standard, the brochure and the journal paper below are described as published. It is not training and does not teach the work.
BS 5837 in the BSI catalogue
BSI Knowledge lists BS 5837:2012, Trees in relation to design, demolition and construction. Recommendations, published April 30, 2012. Its status is current and under review, and it supersedes BS 5837:2005, which is withdrawn. The committee is B/213.
BSI describes the standard as recommendations on tree care, aimed at a harmonious and sustainable relationship between construction or existing structures and the trees around them. It lists arboriculturists, architects, builders, landscape architects, land managers, contractors and statutory undertakers as people the standard is relevant to. The recommendations can be applied whether or not planning permission is required.
The catalogue entry gives the scope and the changes from the 2005 edition.
The ISA consumer brochure
The International Society of Arboriculture brochure Avoiding Tree Damage During Construction, 2021 edition, says construction damage to trees may take many years to show and can be deadly. Small injuries that accumulate over time can start a decline that is hard to reverse.
- Root damage comes from grading, trenching, paving, altering drainage patterns, and adding or removing soil within the critical root zone. If too many roots are damaged, the tree is affected.
- Soil compaction from heavy equipment slows root growth, limits water penetration and lowers the oxygen roots need.
- Equipment can break branches, tear bark and wound the trunk. The brochure says these wounds weaken the tree and let decay fungi in, and that the root collar is especially vulnerable.
- Heat from running machinery or burning material damages bark and foliage. Spilled fuel and runoff from cleaning concrete trucks change soil chemistry and reduce root growth.
- Removing neighbouring trees can expose the remaining trees to sunscald stress or structural failure.
The brochure says damage can come after the project too. Planting, irrigation, lighting and planting soil installed close to a tree can have a devastating effect, and damage despite good plans may take years to become apparent.
It lists options an ISA Certified Arborist might suggest at the design stage. Driveways and walls can be realigned, grading reconfigured, footings or paving made to bridge over roots, and utilities rerouted or tunnelled under roots. Before excavation, an arborist can prune roots out of the way or cut them cleanly.
Trenching and stability in Arboriculture & Urban Forestry
Jason Miesbauer, Andrew Koeser and Brian Kane published Impact of Trenching on Root Loss and Tree Stability in January 2025. They trenched 30 red maples with trunk diameters of 9.9 to 17.0 cm in Gainesville, Florida. Each trench was about 1.8 m long and 46 cm deep, at 1, 3 or 5 times trunk diameter from the base. They pulled each tree to a 1 degree tilt before and after.
| Trench distance | Average root volume lost | Bending stress lost |
|---|---|---|
| 1 times trunk diameter | 13.3 percent | 45.2 percent |
| 3 times trunk diameter | 4.1 percent | 35.2 percent |
| 5 times trunk diameter | 2.5 percent | 22.3 percent |
The authors found a positive link between root volume loss and loss of bending stress (r squared 0.5466). Their model puts about a 2 percent stress reduction on each percent of roots lost. The loss in stress was more than 3 times the root volume lost at 1 times diameter, and more than 8 times at 3 and 5 times diameter.
They conclude that cutting at 3 times trunk diameter reduced stability about as much as cutting at 1 times. Cutting within 5 times diameter on one side is therefore more likely to result in instability. They add that even a small volume of root loss can meaningfully reduce stability. The trial measured tilt in the elastic range and did not pull trees to failure.
The paper reviews earlier work. Miller and Neely (1993) followed 98 trees damaged by utility trenching on a campus. Impacts on growth fell as the trench moved away from the trunk. Fini and co-authors (2020) found that trenching 40 cm from the trunk on two sides cut uprooting resistance in horse chestnut and linden for the full 51 months of monitoring.
Related pages are trees and construction, digging and trenching near a tree and BS 5837 in outline.
Sources
- AUF, Arboriculture & Urban Forestry, Miesbauer, Koeser and Kane, Impact of Trenching on Root Loss and Tree Stability, 51(1), January 2025, pp. 94-102, read October 19, 2026
- BSI Knowledge, BS 5837:2012, Trees in relation to design, demolition and construction. Recommendations, catalogue entry, read October 19, 2026
- International Society of Arboriculture, TreesAreGood brochure, Avoiding Tree Damage During Construction, 2021 edition, read October 19, 2026