ArbNation Join free

Falling-tree liability in three US states: natural conditions and reasonable care

Connecticut, Ohio and Maine decisions all start from the Restatement rule that a landowner owes nothing for natural conditions. Ohio splits rural from urban roadside land, and Maine asks whether decay was readily observable.

Checked against the sources at the bottom of this page on October 19, 2026. Rules, fees and pay change: the source has the last word.

This page reports what the official source says. It is not legal advice: ask the office named here. The sources are one legislative research report, one intermediate appeals court decision and one trial court order. The two Connecticut cases are trial-court rulings.

The Restatement rule behind all three

The Restatement (Second) of Torts, section 363, as the Maine court quotes it, has two parts. Subsection (1) says that, apart from subsection (2), neither a possessor of land nor a vendor or lessor is liable for physical harm caused to others outside the land by a natural condition of the land. Subsection (2) makes a possessor of land in an urban area liable to people using a public highway if the possessor fails to use reasonable care against an unreasonable risk from trees near the highway. Comment e says that in an urban area reasonable care may require inspecting all trees that could endanger travellers. It also says reasonable care at least requires steps against a danger the possessor actually knows of.

Section 364 of the Restatement deals with artificial conditions on land. The Maine court cites Maine's highest court for the point that a duty can arise there when the possessor realizes or should realize an unreasonable risk.

Three states side by side

Falling-tree liability rules as the opinions and the report state them
StateRecordRule as stated
ConnecticutOffice of Legislative Research report 2017-R-0221, October 31, 2017No appellate or Supreme Court case found; two Superior Court cases apply the natural-condition rule
OhioFirst District Court of Appeals, 2024-Ohio-4551, September 18, 2024Rural owners owe no duty to inspect roadside trees; urban owners owe reasonable care, including inspection
MaineLincoln County Superior Court, CV-2016-003, August 23, 2017No duty for natural conditions; liability on this fact pattern turns on actual or constructive knowledge of a defect

Connecticut

The Office of Legislative Research of the Connecticut General Assembly wrote that the law is largely common law rather than statute. It found no Connecticut appellate or Supreme Court case on a private owner's liability for a tree falling onto neighbouring private land. Two unpublished Superior Court cases, from 2016 and 2017, relied on the Restatement and found no liability between private owners for a natural condition, including a falling tree. In the 2016 case the neighbours had told the defendant's real estate agent before the fall that the tree was decayed.

The report notes a bill in 2014, Public Act 14-125, that would have made the tree owner liable for removal costs if the owner did not act within 30 days of written notice. The governor vetoed it. The report says later versions passed the Judiciary Committee but none became law. The report states that OLR Report 2020-R-0279 updates it. Connecticut General Statutes 52-560 separately sets payment of three times the tree's reasonable value for cutting a tree on another person's land without permission.

Ohio

The Ohio opinion describes a tree that fell from adjacent land onto a vehicle on a Hamilton County road on October 28, 2018. The trial court gave summary judgment to the landowner on the finding that the area was rural. The First District reversed and sent the case back.

It restated the rule from the Ohio Supreme Court's 1984 decision at 15 Ohio St.3d 402. A rural landowner has no duty to inspect trees growing next to a road, unless the owner has actual or constructive knowledge of a patently defective condition. An urban landowner has a duty of reasonable care, including inspection. For suburban areas the label is a question of fact. The factors are the location of the highway, its size and type, and the number of people using it. The court did not decide whether the road was rural or urban. It held that genuine issues of material fact remain under either standard, among them whether the landowner had constructive notice of the defect, and left the label to the trier of fact.

Maine

The Maine order concerns a large part of a roadside tree that broke off and landed on a car on June 28, 2014. It cites two Maine Law Court decisions for the rule that a landowner owes no duty to protect off-premises travellers from natural conditions. It notes that the Law Court has not decided whether the urban-area exception in section 363(2) applies in Maine.

The court then turned to the prevailing view in other states. It cites a 1985 New York decision, 66 N.Y.2d 349, which held that no liability attaches unless there is actual or constructive knowledge of the defect, and that decay must be readily observable. It quotes a New Hampshire decision on a landowner who knows or should know a tree is decayed. The test is what a reasonable landowner could observe, not what an arborist would. The expert's view that the rot was obvious to him did not count. The court granted summary judgment for the landowner on all counts.

Sources