ArbNation Join free

Felling dead and dying ash: brittle wood in extension, forestry and TCIA publications

Ash killed by emerald ash borer dries out and turns brittle, and four US sources record limbs breaking without warning, crowns breaking up on the ground and canopy decline thresholds of 20 to 25 percent and 50 percent.

Checked against the sources at the bottom of this page on October 16, 2026. Rules, fees and pay change: the source has the last word.

This page draws on Purdue and South Dakota extension material, the Virginia Department of Forestry and Tree Care Industry magazine. It is not training and does not teach the work. It is not a diagnosis of any tree and does not say what should be done with one.

Why the wood turns brittle

A Purdue forestry extension blog post from January 2019 explains that ash use a thin ring of conducting tissue to move water from the roots to the whole tree. Emerald ash borer grubs chew just beneath the bark and damage it. The tree dries quickly, and the structural wood becomes prone to cracking. Internal breaks are often hidden by the bark, so limbs can break and fall at any point along the branch at any time. The post calls it not uncommon for sizable limbs to snap 30 feet off the ground on a calm day.

The Virginia Department of Forestry (DOF) describes the S-shaped larval galleries as drying out the inner tissue and making it very brittle. As the tree dies over two to three years, it keeps losing moisture and becomes drier and more brittle each month. The Tree Care Industry magazine article puts the usual time from infestation to death at two to five years, usually at the early end.

The Purdue post adds that the threat is not limited to dead ash. It cites a comparative study of ash in Ohio showing that structural integrity can begin to decline while trees are mostly green with two thirds of the canopy intact. The post sets a line at 30 percent canopy loss, beyond which it says to plan removal because delay makes the tree more brittle.

Thresholds for canopy decline

Thresholds printed in the four sources
SourceWhat it records
Purdue Extension, Got Nature? blog, January 24, 2019A tree that has lost more than 30 percent of its canopy is to be planned for removal
South Dakota Department of Agriculture and SDSU Extension, Tree Pest Alert, July 8, 2020No climbing in trees with more than 20 to 25 percent canopy decline. Such trees come out by aerial lift or a knuckle boom mounted grapple saw. Above 50 percent decline, boom mounted grapple saws are named the best means, and manual felling is called too unpredictable
Virginia Department of Forestry, Field NotesNo percentage given. Most arboriculture companies do not allow personnel to climb a dead ash to begin felling
Tree Care Industry magazine, July 1, 2023The author places the dead ash he describes in the critical-risk class of a four-class scheme of low, moderate, high and critical risk. He writes that climbing trees in that condition is not recommended, and names an aerial lift or other access method instead

Dead ash in the South Dakota alert

The South Dakota alert was written by the state's forest health specialist, who is also the extension forester. It says ash killed by the borer have wood properties that differ from healthy ash, so failure is unpredictable. Ash wood splits more easily than most, though a borer-killed tree of any kind dries out quickly and may fail sooner than expected.

The alert states that dead falling ash have killed people and damaged property, landing on people walking or driving and collapsing on houses. It also reports risk to arborists: infested trees have fallen unpredictably while being felled, and one collapsed from the vibration of the soil as an aerial lift was driven up to it. The alert adds that this means more care in removals, which raises the price.

Dead ash in the Virginia and TCI pieces

Virginia DOF relays accounts from tree fellers of branches of dead ash breaking and falling during cutting, and of the entire crown "exploding" as it hits the ground. It says there must be increased safety awareness when felling borer-killed ash. A DOF project felled dead ash in woods beside trails at a camp. Most had not leafed out in 2020, only smaller branches of 2 inches or less broke apart on impact, and the trunks did not break or crack. DOF's main takeaway on milling is to do it as soon as possible for the safety of the feller and the integrity of the wood.

The magazine article is by a certified tree care safety professional. He writes that borer-killed ash can be left brittle but hard, so a stem can sound and feel strong when struck with a mallet while its condition is the opposite. Drilling the stem can also mislead, because the tree appears solid with no cavities or rot. He calls this a false sense of security. He writes that critical-risk ash usually break off within the first 10 feet or so of the ground, especially during negative rigging when the stem oscillates as a piece comes over.

The same article describes one removal of a dead ash about 60 feet tall and 20 inches across at breast height. It had been dead six to eight years. Its basal roots were severely compromised, more than 60 percent of them significantly decayed. A full tree-risk assessment was done with a staff arborist from the Tree Care Industry Association before any climbing.

Sources