Fertilising trees at planting: a three-year trial and two extension positions
A Virginia trial on red maple and littleleaf linden found that fertilizer at the recommended rate did not speed establishment. Maryland extension does not recommend feeding a new tree, and Iowa extension calls it usually unnecessary.
Checked against the sources at the bottom of this page on October 16, 2026. Rules, fees and pay change: the source has the last word.
Fertilizer at planting is an old question with a tidy-sounding answer. A trial in Arboriculture & Urban Forestry measured it over three growing seasons. Two extension pages give their positions.
The trial
Susan Day and J. Roger Harris published the trial in Arboriculture & Urban Forestry, volume 33, issue 2, in March 2007. The title gives the finding: fertilization at recommended rates does not aid tree establishment in red maple (Acer rubrum) and littleleaf linden (Tilia cordata).
The trees were balled-and-burlapped, field-grown and landscape-sized. The team planted them on 24 March 2000 at the Urban Horticulture Research Center in Blacksburg, Virginia. The soil was a silt loam with pH 6.2, which the authors call relatively infertile and typical of the region.
There were 54 trees of each species, set 2.7 m apart in nine treatments in a completely random design. Treatments crossed three fertilizer timings with irrigation, plus one split spring and fall regime:
- fertilised each spring, with or without a dose at planting;
- fertilised each fall;
- not fertilised;
- each of those irrigated or not irrigated, and one unirrigated spring and fall split.
The rate was 1.5 kg of nitrogen per 100 square metres, which is 3 lb per 1000 square feet. The product was a slow-release, sulfur-coated fertilizer with a 4-month release time. Each tree got it broadcast over 1 square metre.
What the trial measured
The team took trunk caliper readings at the end of each season, converted to trunk cross-sectional area. It measured shoot extension for two seasons and leaf nitrogen in early summer of the second season.
The abstract reports that fertilization did not speed establishment and did not affect trunk growth, shoot extension or leaf nitrogen content. Fall fertilizing showed no advantage over spring. Fertilised trees showed no added drought stress, and fertilizer did not act differently on irrigated and unirrigated trees.
The authors list reasons the rate may have been too small to show a response. A transplanted root ball covers about 0.4 square metres of ground, against 10.4 to 18.6 square metres for an established tree of the same size. On a ground-area basis, an established tree would receive roughly 20 to 40 times as much fertilizer.
They also point to root loss at digging. Nitrogen uptake can be suppressed until roots regrow. New roots of red maple may not show in the backfill for 38 days after a spring transplant, and fringe tree roots for 110 days.
The limits the authors state
The paper says the result applies to these two species in moderately poor soil. It does not rule out sites where fertilizer helps: the authors write that there may be situations in which fertilizing at this time is beneficial, but these have not been fully defined.
They also suggest higher rates, foliar feeding or nutrient loading in the nursery as questions for later work. They add that improving soil with organic matter, reducing compaction and giving more soil volume may be better investments for establishment.
Two extension positions
| Source | Position |
|---|---|
| Maryland Extension, updated Feb. 17, 2023 | Not recommended at planting time. Most of a plant's energy goes to root growth during establishment, and nitrogen in that period seems to suppress root growth rather than enhance it. Healthy trees and shrubs in most landscapes need no fertilizer. Proper watering is the most important practice for establishment. |
| Iowa State Extension, updated Dec. 3, 2024 | Usually not necessary, because most Iowa soils supply enough nutrients during establishment. If a tree grows poorly 2 or 3 years after planting, fertilizer may help. Signs listed are sparse foliage, yellow-green leaves and short annual twig growth. |
The Maryland page cites research studies for its reasoning and does not name them. The Iowa page names none. Neither page describes its own trial.
Where the three agree and differ
All three point the same way for a newly planted tree: no gain from feeding at planting. The Day and Harris trial gives measured outcomes for two species. The extension pages give a position for a broader audience.
The trial's own introduction records that earlier work was mixed. Eleven bare-root species showed no growth response to nitrogen during establishment in one study, and silver maple responded in good clay loam but not in poor silt loam in another. The revised ANSI standard, the paper notes, recommends slow-release fertilizer for new transplants, where an earlier version recommended none.
Maryland, South Carolina and New Hampshire extension each describe feeding established trees; the guide to fertilizing trees and nutrient deficiencies puts the three services together.
Sources
- Day SD and Harris JR, Fertilization of Red Maple and Littleleaf Linden Trees at Recommended Rates Does Not Aid Tree Establishment, Arboriculture & Urban Forestry 33(2):113-121, March 2007, read October 16, 2026
- University of Maryland Extension, Fertilizing Trees and Shrubs and Nutrient Deficiency Symptoms, updated February 17, 2023, read October 16, 2026
- Iowa State University Extension, Yard and Garden, Should I fertilize a newly planted tree, updated December 3, 2024, read October 16, 2026