Fixing sidewalks around trees: the options Los Angeles, Seattle and New York City list
Three big-city departments publish lists of ways to repair a sidewalk beside a tree: ramping, bridging, flexible paving, a larger tree bed, shims. Each states its own limits and costs.
Checked against the sources at the bottom of this page on October 15, 2026. Rules, fees and pay change: the source has the last word.
This page reports what the official source says. It is not legal advice: ask the office named here. The pages below set out what city departments list and why. No repair is matched to any one tree.
Los Angeles: options for keeping a tree
The Los Angeles Bureau of Street Services (BSS) reported to the Public Works and Gang Reduction Committee on October 19, 2016. The Committee Chair's communication to Council, in Council File 14-0163-S11, summarises it. The Bureau says a very significant share of the City's damaged sidewalks is attributed to street tree conflict. At the committee meeting of October 24, 2016, a Bureau Urban Forestry representative said preserving the City's 70,000 street trees and improving access for people with mobility impairments may come into conflict.
The Bureau lists five ways to retain a tree that passes a risk check: tree well enlargement, sidewalk ramping, sidewalk minimizing, root pruning and sidewalk relocation. Relocation means a meandering sidewalk, which needs the adjacent owner to dedicate part of the private lot as public right-of-way through a legal process recorded with the County Assessor.
The same report sets removal triggers. Trees with crown dieback above 50 percent, or signs of xylella or other severe pest infestation, are removed. A tree with a foliated crown of 50 percent or more gets an International Society of Arboriculture Basic Tree Risk Assessment form. Extreme-rated trees are removed, and low to high-rated trees may be candidates for retention. Replacement runs at two trees for each one removed, and the report calls for root control barriers on new street tree plantings.
The Council recommendations in the same file go further. They direct the Bureau of Engineering to review alternative materials other than concrete, and to report whether angle cutting and grinding meets Americans with Disabilities Act rules. They also ask for a cost report on a proactive three-year root pruning programme for retained street trees.
Seattle: the solutions toolkit
The Seattle Department of Transportation (SDOT) Trees and Sidewalks Operations Plan, February 2015, rates each tool as proactive (new installations), responsive (maintenance) or both. It prints planning-level costs from the third quarter of 2014, excluding design and permitting. The table gives the plan's own use and limit statements for the surface and design tools.
| Tool | What the plan says | Limit and cost, as the plan states them |
|---|---|---|
| Asphalt | More flexible, cheaper and easier to repair than concrete; a short- to medium-term fix | Much shorter useful life; more upkeep; not used for a short segment between concrete sidewalk. Cost: US$22 per linear foot. |
| Pavers | Can be more flexible than concrete, leaving room for root growth under the walk | Poor fit where many utility structures must be cut around; some types need depth shallow roots cannot give. Cost: US$10 to US$50 per square foot. |
| Reinforced or thicker slab | Resists future uplift after a correction | Not a lasting answer where root growth is vigorous; may be barred where utilities will be added. Cost: US$60 per linear foot reinforced; US$40 for a 4 inch slab. |
| Shims | Temporary asphalt wedges to cut tripping hazards | Meant for lifts of 1 inch or less, at a 4 to 1 maximum slope. Cost: US$200 per location. |
| Beveling | Cutting down the raised edge of a panel; short term | Not for uplift greater than 1 inch. Cost: US$200 per location. |
| Bridging | The walk spans the root zone on piers, beams or boardwalk, so roots grow in soil without lifting it | Needs a handrail if the drop to adjacent grade exceeds 18 inches; metal decks need a non-slip surface. Cost: US$225 per linear foot. |
| Tree pit sizing | Seattle's minimum pit is 24 square feet of open area, usually 4 by 6 feet or 5 by 5 feet; an existing pit can be enlarged | Variations get site-specific review. Cost: US$15 per square yard to enlarge. |
| Steel plates | Anchored over an existing root that should not be pruned, to restrain upward expansion | Non-standard in Seattle and needs SDOT approval; not over an underground utility. Cost: US$500 to US$1,000 per site. |
| Foam underlay | Rigid foam between existing roots and new concrete; roots compress it before affecting the slab | Not for fast-growing roots; non-standard and needs SDOT approval. Cost: US$150 to US$250 per location. |
| Modified gravel layer | Open-graded gravel base to discourage rooting under the pavement | Needs at least 4 inches of depth; not where the dig would damage critical roots. Cost: US$0.70 per square foot at 4 inches. |
| Root pruning | Removing roots that cause uplift, with a qualified arborist | Not where it would badly harm the tree; SDOT approves roots over 2 inches in the dripline. Cost: US$500 to US$2,000 per tree. |
SDOT's Sidewalk Repair Program page lists the temporary measures it uses: painting the sidewalk as a warning, placing asphalt shims, beveling uplifts and closing the sidewalk. It says the City repairs permanently only where the City is responsible, and that a backlog leaves many qualifying locations unrepaired.
New York City: repair strategies
NYC Parks runs a Trees and Sidewalks Program for severe root damage next to one-, two- and three-family homes that are owner-occupied and not used commercially. An inspector rates each site from 1 to 100 on vertical lift, passable width, tree condition, foot traffic, number of damaged flags and number of trees. A site rated under 80 is not repaired by Parks. A site at 80 to 90 is waitlisted, and one at 90 to 100 is expected to be repaired within three years. A site is inspected once every three years.
Parks describes four repair strategies, used alone or together.
- Tree bed expansion. Damaged flags around the tree are removed and the bed enlarged. Parks calls this the most common repair for preventing future damage and notes that it also adds permeable surface. Sidewalk clearance must still meet accessibility standards.
- Ramping. The new sidewalk slopes gradually over the root system, with extra base where needed, to avoid cutting roots.
- Strengthening. Rebar or wire mesh in the concrete can reduce uneven lifting and cracking.
- Curving. Where the tree sits in a lawn pit, damaged concrete is replaced with a sidewalk arcing around it.
A homeowner may instead hire a contractor under a Tree Work Permit and a Department of Transportation sidewalk permit, and may file a claim with the Comptroller within 90 days of the repair. Parks says the Department of Transportation no longer issues violations or liens to owners of qualifying homes where only City trees caused the damage.
A ten-year trial of under-pavement treatments
E. Thomas Smiley planted London plane trees beside new sidewalks in Charlotte, North Carolina, in 1996 and removed the pavement in 2006. Reporting in Arboriculture and Urban Forestry in May 2008, he found minimal lifting or cracking with the panel barrier, gravel and foam treatments. Structural soil laid only 10 centimetres (4 inches) thick gave the largest roots, the greatest lifting and a large number of cracks, though the study notes that structural soil is normally installed about 60 centimetres (24 inches) deep. Roots crushed the foam as they grew. Smiley concluded that treatments installed when the sidewalk or tree goes in are the preferred way to cut pavement damage next to damaging species. More on the barrier results is in root barriers.
Sources
- City of Los Angeles, Council File 14-0163-S11, Communication from Chair, Public Works and Gang Reduction Committee, November 30, 2016, read October 15, 2026
- City of Seattle, Seattle Department of Transportation, Trees and Sidewalks Operations Plan, February 2015, read October 15, 2026
- City of Seattle, Seattle Department of Transportation, Sidewalk Repair Program page, read October 15, 2026
- New York City Department of Parks and Recreation, Trees and Sidewalks Program page, read October 15, 2026
- E. Thomas Smiley, Comparison of Methods to Reduce Sidewalk Damage from Tree Roots, Arboriculture and Urban Forestry 34(3), May 2008, read October 15, 2026