ArbNation Join free

General Duty Clause citations in tree care: the section 5(a)(1) wording and two review cases

Section 5(a)(1) of the OSH Act is the General Duty Clause. An OSHA letter lists four elements, and two OSHRC decisions show a tree-care citation vacated in 1984 and one affirmed as willful in 2019.

Checked against the sources at the bottom of this page on October 16, 2026. Rules, fees and pay change: the source has the last word.

This page reports what the official source says. It is not legal advice: ask the office named here. Two decisions of the Occupational Safety and Health Review Commission (OSHRC) on tree-care citations follow. For the standards OSHA applies to tree crews, see OSHA standards for tree work.

The statute

Section 5 of the Act is 29 U.S.C. 654. Paragraph (a)(1) covers each employer. The employer "shall furnish to each of his employees employment and a place of employment which are free from recognized hazards that are causing or are likely to cause death or serious physical harm to his employees." Paragraph (a)(2) separately requires compliance with the standards issued under the Act. Paragraph (b) puts a matching duty on each employee to comply with the standards, rules and orders that apply to his own actions and conduct.

The four elements

OSHA's 1992 letter came from the Directorate of Compliance Programs. It concerned fall protection in steel erection. The letter calls the general duty clause the appropriate provision to cite for steel erection fall hazards where the fall distance is less than 25 feet. In it OSHA writes that Review Commission and court precedent has established four elements:

  1. The employer failed to keep the workplace free of a hazard to which employees of that employer were exposed.
  2. The hazard was recognized.
  3. The hazard was causing or was likely to cause death or serious physical harm.
  4. There was a feasible and useful method to correct the hazard.

The letter adds that if all four are present, a citation could be issued. The 2019 decision below states the same test in slightly different words: a hazard, recognition by the employer or its industry, likelihood of death or serious physical harm, and a feasible and effective means to eliminate or materially reduce it.

Two tree-care decisions

ItemSecretary of Labor v. Davey Tree Expert CompanySecretary of Labor v. Countryside Tree Service
Docket and dateOSHRC Docket No. 77-2350, Commission decision dated March 30, 1984OSHRC Docket No. 16-2022, administrative law judge decision dated September 27, 2019
WorkFelling tree limbs along a high-voltage transmission line right-of-wayTree removal by a five-person crew at three residential sites on May 4, 2016
Hazard allegedElectrocution from a limb touching the lineBeing caught in the rotating parts of a wood chipper
OutcomeCitation vacated; the judge's vacation affirmedWillful citation under section 5(a)(1) affirmed, with four serious personal protective equipment items
PenaltyThe decision states no penaltyOSHA proposed US$124,709 for the willful item and US$17,102 for the serious items; the judge assessed US$66,986 in total, of which US$49,884 is the section 5(a)(1) item

The 1984 Commission decision

The Commission described a limb that tore and swung into the line during cutting, electrocuting the employee holding the saw. It held that the Secretary must show the hazard was recognized and preventable. The Secretary's broad definition, electrocution from a limb touching a high-voltage line, did not tell the employer its obligations. The Commission instead defined the hazard as electrocution from a tree limb contacting a power line because of the actions of employees in removing the limb.

Chairman Rowland and Commissioner Buckley found no proof the industry or the company recognized a hazard in that removal method. Commissioner Cleary disagreed with that definition. All three found the Secretary had not shown the feasibility and likely utility of the abatement measures put forward. Insulating a 240,000 volt line and de-energizing it were not shown to be feasible; the job ran 4 to 6 months on lines supplying over three million people. The Commission found the company's training and safety program adequate on the record, and that the employees' judgment turning out wrong did not by itself prove more should have been done.

The 2019 judge's decision

The decision defines the hazard by the physical agent, the chipper, and not by the abatement. The judge held that manufacturers' instructions and voluntary industry standards with explicit safety warnings may be probative evidence of recognition. Here the manufacturer's warnings and ANSI Z133-2012 section 8.6 on chipping showed a caught-in hazard, and the judge also found it obvious. The citation named abatement by following the manufacturer's guidance and conforming to cited subparagraphs of ANSI Z133-2012.

The judge found the willful classification proved and cut the proposed willful penalty by 60 percent, citing the small size of the business. The judge's order does not show whether the Commission later reviewed it.

To correct or remove an entry, write to the address at the foot of this page.

Sources