Guarantees on tree work: reasonable care and skill under the UK Consumer Rights Act, Australian Consumer Law and NZ Consumer Guarantees Act
The UK Consumer Rights Act 2015, the Australian Consumer Law and New Zealand's Consumer Guarantees Act all treat a service contract as carrying a term of reasonable care and skill. Each sets its own remedies.
Checked against the sources at the bottom of this page on October 16, 2026. Rules, fees and pay change: the source has the last word.
This page reports what the official source says. It is not legal advice: ask the office named here.
At a glance
| Country | Law | Core term |
|---|---|---|
| United Kingdom | Consumer Rights Act 2015, sections 49 to 57 | Reasonable care and skill (section 49) |
| Australia | Australian Consumer Law | Due care and skill |
| New Zealand | Consumer Guarantees Act | Reasonable care and skill |
United Kingdom
Section 49 of the Consumer Rights Act 2015 treats every contract to supply a service as including a term that the trader must perform the service with reasonable care and skill. Section 50 makes anything said or written to the consumer by or for the trader about the trader or the service a term of the contract. The consumer must have taken it into account when deciding to enter the contract, or when deciding anything about the service afterward. Section 51 adds a term that the consumer pays a reasonable price, and no more, when no price is fixed. Section 52 adds a reasonable time for performance when none is fixed. Both are questions of fact.
Section 54 sets two remedies when a service does not conform to the contract: repeat performance (section 55) and a price reduction (section 56). Under section 55 the trader must repeat the service within a reasonable time and without significant inconvenience to the consumer, and must bear any necessary costs, including labour and materials. A consumer cannot require repeat performance if completing the service in conformity with the contract is impossible.
Section 56 defines the price reduction as an appropriate amount, which may be the full price, including a refund of anything paid above the reduced amount. A consumer who has both rights is entitled to a price reduction only if repeat performance is impossible, or the trader failed to provide it in a reasonable time and without significant inconvenience. A refund must be given without undue delay and within 14 days of the trader agreeing to it. It goes back by the same means of payment unless the consumer agrees otherwise, with no fee. Section 54(6) leaves other remedies open.
Section 57 makes a term not binding on the consumer to the extent that it would exclude the trader's liability under section 49 or restrict it so that the consumer could not recover the price paid. The Act is on legislation.gov.uk, up to date for changes known to be in force on or before October 15, 2026.
Australia
The Queensland Government's Office of Fair Trading describes three consumer guarantees under the Australian Consumer Law that apply to any service bought from a business in Queensland. The supplier guarantees due care and skill, meaning care taken to avoid loss or damage and a level of professional skill or knowledge. The supplier guarantees the service is fit for the purpose the consumer outlined before the job started. And the supplier guarantees to finish at the agreed time, or within a reasonable time if the contract set none. What counts as reasonable depends on the service: building a house takes longer than lopping a tree.
The guarantees apply to services costing AU$100,000 or less, and to services for personal or household use at any price. They do not apply to services a consumer would normally use for business, to transport or storage of work-related goods, or to insurance contracts. The fit-for-purpose guarantee does not apply when the supplier says the service is unlikely to achieve the consumer's intended result and the consumer hires anyway, or when the supplier is a qualified architect or engineer.
The remedy depends on whether the failure is major or minor. A failure is major in three cases. The consumer would not have acquired the service had they known the nature and extent of the problem. Or the service is substantially unfit for its normal purpose and cannot easily be made fit in a reasonable time. Or the supplier created an unsafe situation. For a major failure the consumer chooses: cancel and claim a refund, or keep the contract and claim compensation for the difference in value. For a minor failure the supplier chooses, usually by fixing the problem free of charge within a reasonable time.
New Zealand
The Consumer Protection website of the New Zealand Government says the Consumer Guarantees Act applies to products and services bought from a business for personal or household use. Work must be carried out with reasonable care and skill, meaning the standard of a competent person with average skills and experience. A service must be fit for the particular purpose requested. If the provider cannot guarantee the outcome, it must say so before starting. If no timeframe is agreed, the work must finish within a reasonable time, and if no price is set, the consumer pays a reasonable price.
The Act does not apply to products or services bought for business use when the businesses agreed in writing that it does not apply. When a service fails a guarantee and can be fixed, the consumer can require the supplier to fix it within a reasonable time. If the supplier refuses or fails, the consumer can have it fixed elsewhere and recover the costs, or cancel. If it cannot be fixed or the failure is of "substantial character", the consumer can cancel and ask for a refund, and can claim compensation for further loss or damage. A business that tries to contract out of the Act commits an offence under the Fair Trading Act.
Sources
- UK Parliament, Consumer Rights Act 2015, Part 1 Chapter 4 (services), legislation.gov.uk, Open Government Licence v3.0, read October 16, 2026
- Queensland Government, Consumer guarantees your services must meet (Australian Consumer Law), read October 16, 2026
- New Zealand Government, Consumer Protection, Consumer Guarantees Act, read October 16, 2026