Hardwood log grades: how the Forest Service grades sawlogs and veneer logs
The Forest Service grades hardwood factory logs F1, F2 and F3 by diameter, length, clear cuttings on the best faces, sweep and end defects. Veneer logs follow separate interim specifications, and Purdue lists what veneer buyers look for.
Checked against the sources at the bottom of this page on October 16, 2026. Rules, fees and pay change: the source has the last word.
Forest Service General Technical Report NE-1, A Guide to Hardwood Log Grading by Rast, Sonderman and Gammon, is dated 1973 and was reprinted with minor changes in 1979. It was developed as a teaching aid and field reference. Ohio State Extension fact sheet F-74 summarises its factory log standards. Purdue Extension publication FNR-239 covers veneer quality. NE-1 states that no price relationship is implied between any grade in one class and any grade in another.
Four log-use classes
NE-1 sorts hardwood logs into four use classes. Ohio State Extension repeats the same four.
- Veneer: very high value logs and some relatively low value logs. NE-1 notes that many logs that qualify for factory grades 1, 2 and 3 can also be used as veneer.
- Factory: logs sawn into boards that are later remanufactured to remove defects and obtain clear cuttings. Grades follow National Hardwood Lumber Association lumber grading rules.
- Construction: logs sawn into ties, timbers and other one-piece structural items. Ohio State says these are often grouped into a single grade.
- Local-use: logs for crating, pallet parts, mine timbers, blocking and secondary farm buildings, with no standard specifications. Ohio State says grades in this class are rarely applied.
Factory log grades F1, F2 and F3
Ohio State Extension reports that the Forest Service measured thousands of factory logs over about 40 years, then studied the lumber sawn from them. It reads the results as three yield statements. At least 60 percent of the lumber from an F1 log grades #1 Common or better. From an F2 log the share is 40 to 60 percent. From an F3 log it is under 40 percent.
The grade rests on the grading face. A grader pictures the log in four quarters, picks the face where knots and defects bunch together, and sets that poorest face aside. The log grade follows the least of the remaining three faces. Clear cuttings are lengths free of defects across the full width of the face. Knots are the usual defect, and bumps on the bark count as knots hidden below.
| Grade, scaling diameter, position in tree | Length without trim | Clear cuttings on the grading face |
|---|---|---|
| F1, 13 to 15 in., butts only | 10 ft or more | 7 ft shortest, 2 at most, 83.3 percent of length |
| F1, 16 to 19 in., butts and uppers | 10 ft or more | 5 ft shortest, 2 at most, 83.3 percent |
| F1, 20 in. or more, butts and uppers | 10 ft or more | 3 ft shortest, 2 at most, 83.3 percent |
| F2, 11 in. or more, butts and uppers | 10 ft or more | 3 ft shortest, 2 at most, 66.7 percent |
| F2, 12 in. or more, butts and uppers | 8 to 9 ft | 3 ft shortest, 2 at most, 75 percent |
| F2, 12 in. or more, butts and uppers | 10 to 11 ft | 3 ft shortest, 2 at most, 66.7 percent |
| F2, 12 in. or more, butts and uppers | 12 ft or more | 3 ft shortest, 3 at most, 66.7 percent |
| F3, 8 in. or more, butts and uppers | 8 ft or more | 2 ft shortest, no limit on number, 50 percent |
The scaling diameter is measured inside the bark at the top end of the log. A butt log comes from the base of the tree above a 1-foot stump. Logs carry a few extra inches of trimming allowance, normally 4 to 6 inches, on top of nominal length. Ohio State puts the usual purchase increment at 2 feet, starting at 8 feet for F2 or F3, with 10 feet the minimum for F1.
| Limit | F1 | F2 | F3 |
|---|---|---|---|
| Sweep and crook allowance, log with less than one quarter of the end in sound defects | 15 percent | 30 percent | 50 percent |
| Sweep and crook allowance, log with more than one quarter of the end in sound defects | 10 percent | 20 percent | 35 percent |
| Maximum scaling deduction | 40 percent | 50 percent | 50 percent |
End defects follow their own instructions. Ohio State describes the log end as a heart center, the inner 40 percent of the diameter, and a quality zone, the outer 60 percent. Defects wholly inside the heart center are disregarded. An affected area counts only if it reaches both the inner and outer halves of the quality zone.
Ohio State ties the clear-cutting rule to lumber. A top-grade log needs 5/6, or 83.3 percent, of the grading face clear, the same as FAS lumber. An F3 log needs half. Ohio State also lists NHLA lumber thresholds: #1 Common needs 2/3 of the poorest face clear, #2 Common one half and #3 Common one third.
Tree grades
Ohio State Extension, citing Hanks (1976), says the grade of a standing hardwood tree for factory lumber is normally taken as the grade of its butt log. Tree grade is read on the best 12-foot section of the 16-foot butt log. Grade 1 needs a diameter at breast height of at least 16 inches. Grade 2 needs 13 inches and Grade 3 needs 10 inches. The minimum share of face length clear is 83.3, 66.7 and 50 percent.
Veneer logs
NE-1 states that at the time of writing no standard system for grading veneer logs was based on research. Interim specifications, recommended mainly for northern species such as beech, birch, maple, ash and cherry, were approved by the Chief of the Forest Service in March 1964 for timber appraisals in Region 9 and part of Region 8. NE-1 calls them a bridge until more studies supply yield data.
Purdue Extension lists the quality requirements veneer buyers apply to all species. A veneer log has four clear faces and no surface sign of interior defects. It is straight and well rounded, because bow, crook and an off-center pith spoil the grain pattern. Growth of six to nine rings per inch is usually acceptable. Purdue counts only 33 face veneer slicing operations in North America and notes that quality standards vary among companies and change over time.
Species have their own defects in the Purdue text. Gum spots are the most serious defect in cherry. Bird peck and pin knots matter in walnut, and mineral stain and color contrast matter in white oak. The Purdue paper prints no veneer grade table.
Sources
- USDA Forest Service, Rast, Sonderman and Gammon, A Guide to Hardwood Log Grading, General Technical Report NE-1, 1973, reprinted with minor changes 1979 (scanned PDF), read October 16, 2026
- USDA Forest Service Research and Development, Treesearch record for NE-1, read October 16, 2026
- Ohio State University Extension, Hardwood Log and Tree Quality, fact sheet F-74, January 20, 2012, read October 16, 2026
- Purdue University Extension, D. L. Cassens, Factors Affecting the Quality of Hardwood Timber and Logs for Face Veneer, FNR-239, read October 16, 2026