ArbNation Join free

Natural target pruning and the Shigo school: what the research record says

Biology-first pruning in North America traces to Alex Shigo's USDA Forest Service work on how trees wall off wounds. Tests of his branch collar cut gave mixed results, and a 2010 review of 201 studies says the work supports the collar approach to removal cuts.

Checked against the sources at the bottom of this page on October 16, 2026. Rules, fees and pay change: the source has the last word.

This history of one idea in pruning does not say how any cut should be made, and it takes no side between schools. Pruning standards are in the pruning standards guide, and the biology behind the idea is in the compartmentalization guide.

The sequence of papers

WorkWhat was found, and who reports it
Shigo and Larson, 1969, photographic summary of discoloration and decay patternsObservational, not experimental. One finding was that covering pruning wounds with dressings neither improved closure nor reduced decay. Reported by: Clark and Matheny, 2010.
Shigo and Marx, 1977, Compartmentalization of decay in treesCalled the seminal report. It introduced the CODIT concept. Reported by: Clark and Matheny, 2010.
Shigo and others, 1979, flush cuts in black walnutLinked flush cuts to internal decay and other defects. The authors noted that late in a tree's life care must be taken not to remove the branch collars at the bases of dead and dying branches. Reported by: Clark and Matheny, 2010.
Shigo, 1984 and 1985, compartmentalization and how branches attach to trunksThe papers where the CODIT model culminated. Clark and Matheny say the vast bulk of this work was observational. Reported by: Clark and Matheny, 2010.
Neely, 1988, Journal of Arboriculture 14(11), closure of conventional and Shigo cutsFour-year test on pin oak, sycamore and Norway maple branches of 25 to 35 millimetres. Shigo-cut wounds were 4 to 6 percent wider than the branch, conventional cuts 32 to 51 percent wider. Callus grew faster at conventional cuts, and after the second growing season more conventional cuts than Shigo cuts had closed completely. Reported by: Arboriculture and Urban Forestry, abstract.
Neely, 1991, Arboriculture and Urban Forestry 17(8), branch pruning wound closureTen species, branches of 50 to 75 millimetres. Conventional cuts made wounds 30 to 50 percent larger than Shigo cuts, with little closure of Shigo wounds in the first year. After four years conventional wounds were smaller than Shigo wounds on six species, about the same on one, and larger on three. Reported by: Arboriculture and Urban Forestry, abstract.
Lonsdale, 1993, UK research note on beechFour-year-old wounds on European beech: wood discoloration spread more beneath flush cuts than beneath cuts at the natural stem and branch junction. There was no difference between target cuts and stub cuts in that respect. Flush cuts grew callus fastest but closed proportionately less because of their size, and the note says the fastest occlusion came with cuts between target and flush. Reported by: Arboricultural Advisory and Information Service, research note.

Who Shigo was

Tree Care Industry Magazine's October 1, 2021 tribute by a retired city forester describes Shigo as the USDA Forest Service's chief research scientist in the late 1970s and early 1980s. His compartmentalization work and his proposed natural target pruning contrasted at that time with Dan Neely's ideas on flush cuts. Shigo had retired from the Forest Service by September 1986, when the author attended the first of his New Tree Biology workshops. He was dubbed the father of modern arboriculture. The tribute lists his books and gives October 2006 as the month he died. The Shigo Collection, run by Davey Tree with the ISA Southern Chapter, records that he joined the Forest Service in 1958, retired from it in 1985 as Chief Scientist, and died on October 6, 2006, aged 86.

What a 2010 review concluded

Clark and Matheny compiled 201 research publications for the International Society of Arboriculture in a review published in 2010. Shigo and Dirk Dujesiefken are the most frequently cited authors. Research by Shigo, and by Dujesiefken, has supported the branch collar, natural target approach to choosing where a removal cut goes. Shigo's 1990 booklet on pruning near electric utility lines is recorded as not research-based but a key element of utility practice, since largely superseded by Kempter's 2004 best management practices summary. The review stresses that Shigo was neither the only scientist interested in tree response to wounding nor the first, and names foresters before him.

Where the papers differ

The two Neely papers measure the same thing and differ on the long-run result, and the UK note found the quickest closure at neither extreme. Lonsdale's note records that earlier practice was divided between stub cutting and flush cutting. Flush cutting had come to be viewed with disfavour because it injures tissue that belongs to the parent stem.

Sources