ArbNation Join free

Hollow trees and remaining wall: what the literature reports on shell thickness

Two Arboriculture & Urban Forestry papers and a Royal Society Open Science paper test how remaining wall relates to hollow trunk failure. Natural England's standing advice treats hollowing as a feature of veteran trees.

Checked against the sources at the bottom of this page on October 19, 2026. Rules, fees and pay change: the source has the last word.

No paper below sets one wall thickness that applies to every hollow tree. Each states the limits of its own method.

Hurricane Hugo oaks in Charlotte, reported in 1992

E. Thomas Smiley and Bruce Fraedrich of Bartlett Tree Research Laboratories tested a strength loss formula on oaks after Hurricane Hugo. The oaks were mostly Quercus alba, Q. falcata and Q. phellos in the Charlotte, North Carolina area. Winds reached 90 miles per hour. They measured 54 oaks that broke, not windthrown, and compared them with standing oaks that had decay.

Of the 54 broken oaks, 52 had internal decay. Strength loss from decay ranged from under 1 percent to over 90 percent and averaged 33 percent. Standing control trees averaged 23 percent, and 4 of the 31 standing decayed trees tested were above 33 percent. The authors measured sound wood by drilling with a small bit until resistance dropped.

The formula descends from an engineering comparison of pipe strength. Wagener, in a 1963 US Forest Service paper on campground tree failure, modified it to allow for irregular trees. The Bartlett version adds a term for wood missing at a cavity opening.

The authors list other influences on failure: species, crown size and density, branching, lean, where the decay sits, site exposure and storm severity. They write that professional judgement still plays an important role.

Nineteen cut stems in Massachusetts, 2004

Brian Kane and H. Dennis P. Ryan III of the University of Massachusetts compared four published formulas with the actual loss in the stem's resistance to bending. They used photographs of cross-sections of 19 trees with cavities and decay. Decay was irregular and offset from the centre of the stem in most of them, not a neat hollow circle.

  • Wagener's formula returned values 9.6 percent lower than the actual loss on average, and Coder's 15.1 percent lower.
  • The Smiley and Fraedrich formula, which allows for cavity openings, was 0.5 percent lower on average, a gap that did not pass the authors' statistical test.
  • The wall-thickness ratio of Mattheck and Breloer overestimated 3 of the 19 trees and underestimated none. The trees with the largest cavity openings also had a thin remaining wall.
  • Several trees with a high loss in resistance to bending did not look to be in immediate danger by visual tree assessment. The authors suggest this may be due in part to woodlot growth, with branching typical of forest trees and shelter from neighbouring trees.

Kane and Ryan conclude that the formulas are only one of several tools, and that more studies are needed to find the loss likely to cause failure.

Flattening in hollow trunks, 2017

Yan-San Huang and colleagues in Taiwan modelled how hollow trunks break. Thick-walled trunks usually fail in bending under gale gusts. Thin-walled trunks can flatten in cross-section and crack, then split lengthways. The paper notes that hollowness is usually inspected by drilling resistance and sonic tomography.

For Taiwan red cypress the model puts the change from splitting to ordinary bending failure at a wall to radius ratio of 0.27. The other three species tested give critical ratios of 0.21 to 0.27. The authors say exact values may vary within and among species. A hollow trunk with a ratio of 0.3 keeps 76 percent of the bending strength of a solid trunk of the same outer radius. The equations do not apply to trunks with side openings or heart decay only.

The introduction says many hollow trees are cut from fear they will fall, yet many stand sound for decades. Hollow-bearing trees are removed faster than hollows form in many parts of the world.

Natural England on hollowing as a feature

Natural England and the Forestry Commission publish standing advice for planning decisions in England, published January 14, 2022. A veteran tree may not be very old, but it has significant decay features such as branch death and hollowing. These contribute to its exceptional biodiversity, cultural and heritage value.

The advice calls ancient and veteran trees irreplaceable habitats. It says planning authorities should refuse permission where development would cause their loss or deterioration, unless there are wholly exceptional reasons and a suitable compensation strategy. A tree's existing condition is not a reason to permit development.

Related pages are hollow trees as habitat and hollow trunks and cavities.

Sources