Hurricane performance of palms: the UF/IFAS survey tables
After Florida and Puerto Rico hurricanes, UF/IFAS counted palms still standing. Sabal palm held at 92 to 93 percent even in Andrew, while queen palm fell to 42 percent.
Checked against the sources at the bottom of this page on October 16, 2026. Rules, fees and pay change: the source has the last word.
Mary Duryea and colleagues at the University of Florida (UF/IFAS) have measured urban tree damage after hurricanes since Andrew in 1992. Three UF/IFAS publications carry the palm results: FR174 for the southeastern coastal plain, FR175 for tropical and subtropical species, and FR010 for the 1995 Florida Panhandle storms. Wind damage to the wider urban forest is in why trees fail in storms, and wind speed scales are in wind scales and tree damage.
How the numbers were taken
Teams surveyed front yards along street transects near landfall, within three to six days of each storm in FR174 and three to ten days in FR175. For palms they recorded height rather than trunk diameter and assessed leaf loss only. FR174 counts a tree as surviving if it is standing after the storm. A tree leaning at less than 45 degrees counts as not surviving. FR174's branch-loss recalculation was made for dicots and conifers, not palms.
FR174 reports 100 neighbourhoods and 18,200 trees sampled. FR175 reports 26 neighbourhoods and 3,678 trees for Georges in Puerto Rico, 17 neighbourhoods and 2,272 trees for Charley, and 7 neighbourhoods and 1,642 trees for Jeanne. Survival figures appear only for species with more than 20 trees per hurricane.
Survival of palms after four hurricanes
FR175 Table 1 gives the percentage of palms still standing. The Andrew figures come from a 1996 homeowner survey of 128 yards in Dade County. Sustained winds were 110 mph in Georges, 120 in Jeanne, 145 in Charley and 165 in Andrew. The abbreviation n/a marks a species with too few trees in that storm.
| Palm | Percent standing: Georges, Jeanne, Charley, Andrew |
|---|---|
| Sabal palm | n/a, 92, 92, 93 |
| Areca palm | 94, n/a, 97, 93 |
| Pygmy date palm | n/a, 100, 100, n/a |
| Manila palm | 89, n/a, 95, n/a |
| Royal palm | 93, n/a, 87, 63 |
| Coconut palm | 77, n/a, 77, 41 |
| Washington palm | n/a, 80, 92, n/a |
| Queen palm | n/a, 74, 69, 42 |
Taken together, palms stood at 88 percent in Charley against 77 percent for all other trees. In Jeanne the figures were 86 percent against 76 percent. FR175 cites Zimmerman and others for the reason: palms can lose all their leaves without losing the terminal meristem.
Species that moved the other way
FR175 notes that coconut survived poorly in Andrew and moderately in Charley and Georges. It records royal palm rising from 63 percent in Andrew to 87 percent in Charley, and links that to the deeper soils of the Gulf Coast. Washington palm survived at 92 percent in Charley and 80 percent in Jeanne. The authors compared heights: the Jeanne palms averaged 11 metres, with 42 percent over 10 metres, and the Charley palms averaged 4 metres, with 7 percent over 10 metres. They suggest wind resistance may decline above about 20 metres.
FR174 reports sabal palm among the best survivors in Ivan at 130 mph, and it lost only 27 percent of its leaves. FR175 names queen palm, melaleuca and Australian pine as non-native species with low survival.
Panhandle surveys of 1995
FR010 covers Hurricanes Erin, with 85 mph sustained winds, and Opal, with 125 mph. It counts 4,911 trees, and 11 percent fell in Erin and 13 percent in Opal. Sabal palm was one of the most wind resistant species, with 97 and 100 percent standing, and the one sabal recorded as fallen was knocked over by another falling tree. Pindo palm was 97 percent standing in one storm only, so the authors call that result preliminary. Palms, southern pines, oaks and dogwood had crown damage on fewer than 2 percent of trees.
The circular adds that sabal palm was the second most wind-resistant tree in Hurricane Camille in 1969 and was reported as immune to the hurricane-force winds of Hugo in 1989.
The expert survey
In June 2005 UF/IFAS mailed 240 surveys to members of the Florida chapter of the International Society of Arboriculture, the Florida Urban Forestry Council and University of Florida faculty. Eighty-five came back, 35 percent. Respondents rated species high, medium or low for wind resistance. FR174 and FR175 print the counts.
| Palm | Rated high | Respondents |
|---|---|---|
| Sabal palm | 99 percent (71) | 72 |
| Pygmy date palm | 98 percent (40) | 41 |
| Date palm | 94 percent (33) | 35 |
| Canary Island date palm | 89 percent (49) | 55 |
| Pindo palm | 79 percent (34) | 43 |
| Coconut palm | 63 percent (22) | 35 |
| Cuban royal palm | 61 percent (17) | 28 |
| Washington fan palm | 54 percent (29) | 54 |
| Queen palm | 10 percent (5) | 51 |
FR175 states that the experts ranked queen palm lowest among palms and royal and coconut palm intermediate, in line with the field results. FR174 notes that Canary Island date palm, rated high, is being planted more often in north Florida.
Sources
- Mary L. Duryea and others, University of Florida IFAS Extension, Selecting Coastal Plain Species for Wind Resistance, FR174 (FOR119), revised August 2026, read October 16, 2026
- Mary L. Duryea and others, University of Florida IFAS Extension, Selecting Tropical and Subtropical Tree Species for Wind Resistance, FR175 (FOR120), revised October 2026, read October 16, 2026
- Mary L. Duryea, University of Florida IFAS Extension, Wind and Trees: Surveys of Tree Damage in the Florida Panhandle after Hurricanes Erin and Opal, FR010 (CIR1183), April 1997, read October 16, 2026