Ice and snow damage to trees, prune now or wait: three extension notes
SDSU Extension and an Ontario note advise letting ice melt off a tree, and Missouri Extension says a hasty removal can lose a tree that would have recovered. They differ on how much crown loss is too much.
This page is for tree owners. It reports what the named sources say and is not advice about your tree: for that, ask a qualified arborist or one of the offices under Who to call.
Checked against the sources at the bottom of this page on October 19, 2026. Rules, fees and pay change: the source has the last word.
The facts on this page come from the named extension services. It is not training and does not teach the work. The sources are South Dakota State University Extension publication 06-1001-2013, University of Missouri Extension guide G6867 and an Ontario Extension Note from the LandOwner Resource Centre, copied on a University of Kentucky site.
Ice on the tree
SDSU Extension describes knocking ice off bent trees as a common reaction that can break branches and harm evergreens such as pines and spruce. Its position is that it is best to let the ice melt and the tree resume its shape. It names de-icing salts, which are toxic to plants, and flame sources, which burn buds, as things to keep away from the tree.
The Ontario note makes the same point. Some trees stay frozen into the snow crust after a storm. The note advises against removing ice and snow in general, says winter trees are brittle, and warns that striking branches with a blunt object breaks more than it saves. For some conifers, such as pine, it says that trying to release a frozen top can do more damage.
Wait or cut
Missouri Extension frames the first days as patience. Hasty decisions, it says, can remove trees that could have been saved. Where a damaged tree poses no immediate physical risk, its advice for an owner who is unsure is to keep the tree. The Ontario note adds that winter dormancy makes further injury from insects and disease less likely than in the growing season. It sees no need to rush to remove trees that pose no short-term safety hazard, and calls it wise to wait for the growing season before deciding on removal.
Missouri sorts the outcome into three categories: keep it, wait and see, and replace it. A tree with slight damage goes in the first group. A tree in the second group has only its damaged limbs pruned, with a final decision later. A tree already weakened by disease, with a split trunk or with more than half the crown gone belongs in the third.
How much crown loss the notes accept
| Publication | Threshold |
|---|---|
| SDSU Extension, young trees under 15 feet | Corrective pruning if few limbs or the tip are broken; removal may be best if the tree is broken near the base or more than one-third of the limbs are broken |
| SDSU Extension, mature trees | Removal may be better if the top third of the canopy is broken out or more than half of the limbs are broken |
| Missouri Extension | At least 50 percent of the crown intact is called a good rule of thumb for survival |
| Ontario Extension Note, crown loss | 0 to 25%: little effect; 26 to 50%: will survive; 51 to 75%: fair chance; over 75%: may survive depending on species |
| Ontario Extension Note, bent stems | Under a 20-degree bend: will recover; under 60 degrees: good chance; over 60 degrees: low chance |
The Ontario note also says hardwoods with less than 75 per cent crown damage are expected to recover, although it may take three to six years. Missouri adds that a 2 to 3 inch wound on a 12 inch limb will seal over with new bark within a couple of years.
Pruning timing and the cut itself
The Ontario note says pruning can be done at any time with a few exceptions. Elms are never pruned in the growing season because open wounds attract the elm bark beetle that spreads Dutch elm disease. The note lists spring pruning of hardwoods as one to avoid, because sap flow attracts insects, and has early-flowering hardwoods pruned after flowering so the bloom is kept. Conifers can be pruned at any time, with less sap and resin flow in the dormant season.
SDSU notes that maples and birch pruned at this time of year bleed a clear, slightly sweet sap, which it calls not harmful and which stops when buds expand. SDSU and Missouri describe broken limbs cut back to the trunk or the larger limb they grow from, with no stub left. The Ontario note says not to leave a long broken stub and not to prune flush to the main stem. SDSU and Missouri reject topping, and Missouri cites professional arborists calling it one of the worst things done to a tree. SDSU and the Ontario note reject wound paint and prepared compounds, and SDSU says dressings can raise the risk of decay by keeping the interior moist.
For a broken leader on a young tree, SDSU describes trimming back to the highest upright limb that is at least half the diameter of the adjacent trunk, where the leader is under about three-quarters of an inch across. The Ontario note describes a cut at about 45 degrees below the break and above the first live branch of at least one-third the size of the stem. For a deeply split mature tree, SDSU says removal is the best option, and that tree support systems are best left to professional arborists.
Hazards of the clean-up
SDSU describes pinned branches that can act as a "spring pole", releasing quickly and striking the person cutting, and trees that roll when a broken branch is freed, crushing a worker under 5 to 10 tons of wood. It calls tree work among the highest-risk professions in the United States and lists helmet, hearing, eye and cut-resistant protection for chainsaw use. Missouri says bent trees and branches over 6 inches in diameter are removed by someone with more experience than the weekend woodcutter, because the stored strain is undetectable to the untrained eye.
All three publications point to professionals, arborists among them, for large or hazardous work. SDSU and Missouri warn about door-to-door offers after a storm. All three list liability insurance and workers' compensation coverage among the credentials of a company to hire, and ISA certification is named in each. Missouri notes that a tree between the street and the sidewalk is usually city-owned and the city's responsibility.
Related guides cover ice and snow hazards in tree work and pruning after storms.
Who to call
- Your local utility: trees touching or near power lines, which are never approached
- A certified arborist: assessment and pruning or removal of large or hazardous storm-damaged trees
- Your city forestry office: street trees, which are usually the city's responsibility
Sources
- South Dakota State University Extension, What to do about the ice storm-damaged trees?, John Ball, publication 06-1001-2013, read October 19, 2026
- University of Missouri Extension, First Aid for Storm-Damaged Trees, Hank Stelzer, G6867, reviewed May 2017, read October 19, 2026
- LandOwner Resource Centre, Ontario, Extension Note: Caring for Ice-Damaged Trees, 1999, copy hosted by the University of Kentucky timber damage site, read October 19, 2026