ArbNation Join free

Ice storm response: what forestry studies report about damage and cleanup hazards

The National Weather Service defines an ice storm as damaging ice, usually a quarter inch or more, in freezing rain. Extension and Forest Service notes describe broken crowns, spring poles and rolling trunks in the cleanup.

Checked against the sources at the bottom of this page on October 19, 2026. Rules, fees and pay change: the source has the last word.

The named extension notes and agencies are described here as published. It is not training and does not teach the work.

The National Weather Service definition

The National Weather Service (NWS) glossary uses "ice storm" for occasions when damaging ice accumulations are expected during freezing rain. Significant accumulations pull down trees and utility lines, with loss of power and communication. They also make walking and driving extremely dangerous. The NWS puts significant accumulations at usually a quarter inch or more.

An ice storm warning is issued when freezing rain produces a significant and possibly damaging accumulation. The glossary says the criteria vary from state to state. A warning is usually issued when more than a quarter inch of ice is expected in an area.

Damage in the Forest Service note

The Forest Service Northeastern Area note "Ice Storm Response", December 2008, is hosted by Connecticut DEEP. It reports that a coating of ice adds significant weight to a tree. Stems and branches break, and some trees bend completely over. The whole tree may fail if the ground is soft or the roots are defective. Hardwoods and conifers of all ages can be affected.

The note adds that ice storms kill some trees but many damaged trees survive. Over time, damaged trees may develop more decay and discoloration. Some damage does not show at first:

  • Hidden cracks may make branches droop when leaves open in spring.
  • Stem decay and cracks can reduce structural soundness, so that the tree or large branches become hazardous.
  • Root damage may not show until twigs and branches in the upper crown start dying after two or three growing seasons.
  • Stressed, dying and dead trees attract borers and bark beetles.

The note lists the hazards that come first: dead trees, leaning trees, trees with broken or cracked stems or extensive broken roots, and large dead or broken limbs still attached to the tree.

The cleanup hazards the extension notes name

South Dakota State University Extension Forestry and the South Dakota Department of Agriculture Forest Health describe a hazard specific to ice damage. Many broken trees have branches pinned to the ground under the weight of the rest of the tree. Cutting a pinned branch may release the pressure and create what the note calls a spring pole, a branch that returns quickly to its original position and strikes the person pruning, or their saw.

The same note reports that trees have been known to roll when a broken branch is freed, crushing the worker beneath 5 to 10 tons of wood. It calls tree work among the highest risk professions in the United States, and says chainsaw injuries are common when tree owners attempt storm cleanup. The protective equipment it lists for chainsaw use is a helmet, hearing protection, eye protection, cut-resistant chaps, boots and gloves.

The Connecticut note carries a caution for homeowners. Removing large trees or limbs is dangerous work. It names climbing a ladder with a chain saw or climbing into a damaged tree as things not to do, and says never to touch a tree near electrical wires. Most tree work should be done by professional arborists, it says, especially when climbing is involved or the tree leans on other trees or structures.

An extension note from the Ontario Ministry of Natural Resources and the LandOwner Resource Centre, hosted by the University of Kentucky, makes a related point. Branches that appear well wedged in the crown can fall without warning at any time, with serious injury and damage as the result.

Ice on the tree and the thaw

The Ontario note covers trees that stay ice-covered or frozen into the snow crust after the storm. It says it is usually advised not to remove the ice and snow, though each tree is different. It is often best to let a tree thaw before any attempt to straighten it. For some conifers, such as pine, trying to release a frozen top could cause more damage.

The note warns against striking branches with a blunt object to remove ice. Trees are fairly brittle in winter, and with the added rigidity of the ice, more branches break than are saved. The South Dakota note names the same practice, knocking ice off, as a common reaction that can break branches and harm evergreens such as pines and spruce. It also warns against de-icing salts, which it calls toxic to plants, and against melting ice with a blow torch or other flame.

Crown loss and recovery figures

The Ontario note's assessment figure ties recovery to crown loss and bend. The ranges are printed on its figure, and the note says healthy trees without major structural damage, such as split trunks and broken crowns, may recover with time.

Recovery by damage, Ontario Ministry of Natural Resources note
DamageOutlook printed in the note
0 to 25 percent crown lossLittle effect
26 to 50 percent crown lossWill survive
51 to 75 percent crown lossFair chance of survival
More than 75 percent crown lossMay survive depending on species
Bend of less than 20 degreesWill recover
Bend of less than 60 degreesGood chance of recovery
Bend of more than 60 degreesLow chance of recovery

The South Dakota note sets its own thresholds. For young trees under 15 feet, it says breakage near the base or of more than one-third of the limbs may make removal the better course. For mature trees, it points to loss of the top third of the canopy or more than half of the limbs. The two notes use different measures, so the figures do not line up.

Sources