Identifying birches, alders and hornbeams
Birches, alders and hornbeams share the birch family, Betulaceae. Cornell Extension names doubly serrate leaf margins and winged nutlets as the family marks, then separates birches, hornbeams and hophornbeams by bark, buds and fruit.
Checked against the sources at the bottom of this page on October 21, 2026. Rules, fees and pay change: the source has the last word.
This page draws on Cornell Cooperative Extension, the Woodland Trust and the USDA Forest Service. It does not identify trees from descriptions or photos and does not say what should be done with any tree. Single trees have their own pages: silver birch, paper birch, red alder and hornbeam.
What the family shares
Cornell's Peter Smallidge calls the doubly serrate leaf margin the most notable feature across the birch family. A doubly serrate leaf has large and small teeth mixed together. The second shared feature is a small hard seed, a nutlet, carried on the wind by a leafy bract whose shape depends on the genus. Cornell lists four genera in New York: Betula (birches), Carpinus (American hornbeam), Corylus (hazelnut) and Ostrya (eastern hophornbeam). Alders (Alnus) are not covered in the Cornell sheet.
Birches compared
| Tree | Bark and twig | Leaf and fruit |
|---|---|---|
| Paper birch, Betula papyrifera | White, papery, exfoliating bark. Twigs lack the wintergreen aroma. | Nine or fewer lateral veins, broadest at the base, coarsely doubly serrate. Strobili hang down on a stalk. |
| Sweet birch, Betula lenta | Black bark in plates. Twigs and foliage smell of wintergreen. | Usually more than nine veins, small serrations, hairy petioles. Strobili upright and stalkless. |
| Yellow birch, Betula alleghaniensis | Yellow or bronze, papery bark. Large old trees develop plates. Wintergreen aroma. | More than nine veins, hairy petioles, hairs on the veins of the lower leaf surface. Strobili upright and stalkless. |
The buds of all three birches may sit on spur shoots, where a stunted bud makes two leaves that look paired. A single bud sits with the pair, which sets it apart from opposite leaves on ash or maple. The buds of all three pull away from the twig, so they are divergent. Juvenile stems of Betula, Ostrya and Carpinus all have smooth brownish bark.
Hornbeam and hophornbeam
Cornell separates American hornbeam (Carpinus caroliniana) from eastern hophornbeam (Ostrya virginiana), which is most likely to be confused with it. Neither forms spur shoots.
| Feature | American hornbeam | Eastern hophornbeam |
|---|---|---|
| Mature bark | Smooth, bluish, tight and fluted, hence blue beech and musclewood | Finely shredded and peeling |
| Leaf | Waxy smooth above, hairy petiole, veins not branched | Finely hairy above, smooth petiole, veins often branched |
| Bud | 1/8 inch, minimally divergent or pressed to the twig | 1/4 inch, more divergent, with vertical striations on the scales |
| Fruit | Paired nutlet with lobed bracts | Single nutlet in an oval wing |
| Site | Moist soils or near streams | Drier soils |
The British trees
The Woodland Trust describes silver birch (Betula pendula) as a deciduous tree up to 30 m, with white bark year-round, small triangular toothed leaves and twigs that are smooth with small dark warts. The bark turns black and rugged at the base and develops diamond-shaped fissures. The Trust names downy birch (Betula pubescens) as the tree it could be confused with, and the two hybridize easily. New shoots on silver birch are hairless and warty, while those of downy birch are smooth and covered in soft hairs.
The Trust describes common hornbeam (Carpinus betulus) as a tree of up to 30 m with pale grey bark with vertical markings. The twigs are brown-grey and slightly hairy. The seed is a nut of 3 to 6 mm in a leafy bract with three lobes. Its leaves look pleated, and the Trust sets them against beech, which has wavy edges rather than doubly serrated ones. Leaf buds press close to the twig.
The USDA Forest Service Fire Effects Information System lists silver birch among the common names of paper birch, Betula papyrifera, a North American tree. The Woodland Trust's silver birch is a different species.
Red alder
The Fire Effects Information System describes red alder (Alnus rubra) as the largest American alder, a fast-growing, short-lived deciduous tree, usually with one straight trunk. Mature trees are usually 80 to 100 feet tall. The bark is thin, smooth and gray-whitish mottled, often covered in green moss. Male and female flowers sit on the same tree in catkins, and the female catkins turn woody and cone-like. The tree grows along the Pacific Coast from southeast Alaska to southern California. The system adds that red alder and white alder are difficult to tell apart where they grow together, and that in winter identification rests on many subtle points.
Sources
- Cornell Cooperative Extension, ForestConnect, Peter Smallidge, Doubly-serrate margins, and these trees all look alike as seedlings and saplings (August 2022), read October 21, 2026
- Woodland Trust, Silver birch (Betula pendula), British trees, read October 21, 2026
- Woodland Trust, Hornbeam (Carpinus betulus), British trees, read October 21, 2026
- USDA Forest Service, Fire Effects Information System, Betula papyrifera, Uchytil 1991, read October 21, 2026
- USDA Forest Service, Fire Effects Information System, Alnus rubra, Uchytil 1989, read October 21, 2026