ArbNation Join free

Identifying elms, hackberries and zelkovas

Elms have leaf bases that sit unevenly on the stalk. Hackberry and zelkova differ in bark, fruit and family. Forest Research and the Morton Arboretum disagree on whether zelkova is affected by Dutch elm disease.

Checked against the sources at the bottom of this page on October 16, 2026. Rules, fees and pay change: the source has the last word.

The Woodland Trust gives one rule for the whole elm genus: all elm species have unequal leaf bases, where the leaf meets its stalk. The Morton Arboretum describes the American elm leaf the same way, as shorter on one side of the center vein than the other. The sources below give other features for four trees.

Four trees compared

Features as the Morton Arboretum and the USDA Forest Service print them
TreeLeafBark, fruit and form
American elm (Ulmus americana)Alternate, oval, pointed, doubly toothed margins, shorter on one side of the center veinSmall oval samara. Vase-shaped. In open stands trees usually fork near the ground and form wide arching crowns
Slippery elm (Ulmus rubra)Not described in the Silvics chapterIdentified by its "slippery" inner bark. Flowers appear before the leaves. Seeds are larger than many native elms
Hackberry (Celtis occidentalis)Simple, alternate, ovate, 2 to 4 inches long, dull and roughSmooth grayish bark when young, corky warts and ridges with age. Fleshy berry-like drupe, green turning deep purple-brown, persisting through winter. Oval, round or vase-shaped
Japanese zelkova (Zelkova serrata)Simple, alternate, ovate, sharply serrated, 1 1/2 to 2 inches, rounded bases, long-pointed tipsGrayish-brown bark with many lenticels, mottled and slightly peeling with age. Small drupe. Vase-shaped

Families

The Morton Arboretum puts American elm and Japanese zelkova in the elm family, Ulmaceae. It lists hackberry in the hemp family, Cannabaceae, formerly the elm family. Zelkova is native to Japan, eastern China, Taiwan and Korea. The Silvics chapter on American elm gives other names for it: white elm, water elm, soft elm and Florida elm. For slippery elm it gives red elm, gray elm and soft elm.

Size and age

American elm may reach 30 m to 38 m in height, according to the Silvics chapter by Bey. The chapter reports ages of 175 to 200 years, with some older than 300. Slippery elm is commonly medium-sized, may live to 200 years and may reach 40 m on moist, rich soils. The Morton Arboretum gives hackberry as 40 to 60 feet tall and 40 to 50 feet wide, and Japanese zelkova as 50 to 80 feet tall and 50 to 75 feet wide.

Dutch elm disease and the look-alikes

Forest Research describes Dutch elm disease as a destructive disease of elms in the genus Ulmus, caused by two related fungi and spread by elm bark beetles. English elm, field or smooth-leaved elm and wych elm are named as susceptible, and so are species of the related Zelkova genus. The Morton Arboretum says the opposite for Japanese zelkova: it is closely related to elms but resistant to Dutch elm disease. Hackberry is not named on the Forest Research page.

Forest Research lists the symptoms. Clusters of leaves turn yellow and wilt in early summer, shoots die back from the tips and some twigs bend into shepherd's crooks. Dark streaks show in the outer wood when bark is peeled from affected twigs.

Resistant cultivars

Forest Research puts the main hope for restoring large elms in identifying and breeding variants that resist or tolerate the fungus. The Morton Arboretum lists American elm cultivars and describes their resistance.

American elm cultivars, Morton Arboretum
CultivarDutch elm disease resistance
JeffersonExcellent. Vase-shaped. Considered sterile
New HarmonyExcellent. Vase-shaped
Lewis and ClarkExcellent. Vase-shaped
PrincetonGood. Fair resistance to elm leaf beetle. Vase-shaped
Valley ForgeExcellent. Vase-shaped

The Silvics chapter names the American Liberty elm, a variety selected from second-generation crosses of the most resistant parents. It reports that their resistance is still inferior to cultivars derived from Asian or European sources. The chapter also records horticultural forms of American elm with a narrow columnar head, upright branches or pendulous branches.

Sources