Identifying hickories, walnuts, pecans and butternut
Hickories, walnuts, pecans and butternut all have large compound leaves and big nuts. Purdue Extension and Michigan State University Extension separate them by leaflet count, pith, leaf scar, bark and the husk that holds the nut.
Checked against the sources at the bottom of this page on October 16, 2026. Rules, fees and pay change: the source has the last word.
Michigan State University Extension's Upper Peninsula key notes that the walnut family has two genera in that region, Juglans (walnuts) and Carya (hickories). The trees have large, edible nuts in thick fibrous husks, male flowers in catkins and large compound leaves. The Purdue publication on butternut adds that pecan trees and other hickories are sometimes misidentified as butternuts.
Walnuts and butternut
Purdue Extension, writing with USDA Forest Service scientists, says all walnut species have chambered pith in the centre of the twigs. The color of the pith and the leaf scar separate butternut from black walnut. Butternut leaf scars carry a thick band of hairs that resembles a moustache. Black walnut leaf scars do not.
| Feature | Butternut (Juglans cinerea) | Black walnut (Juglans nigra) |
|---|---|---|
| Leaflets | Purdue: 9 to 17. Michigan State: 11 to 17, leaves 15 to 30 inches long | Michigan State: 15 to 23, leaves 12 to 24 inches long, finely toothed |
| Pith | Dark chocolate-brown | Light brown (Purdue), tan (Michigan State) |
| Leaf scar | Hairy "moustache" above the scar | No moustache |
| Bark | Mature bark platy and ash-gray with dark gray fissures. Young bark smooth, gray or greenish-gray | Mature bark dark brown, heavily ridged or blocky. Young bark brown, ridged or flaky |
| Nut and husk | Elongated, oval, 1 1/2 to 2 1/2 inches, sticky hairy husk | Round, 1 1/2 to 2 inches, husk green, sticky and fuzzy, dark brown with age |
| Terminal bud | About a quarter to a third inch, fuzzy | Half the length of butternut |
Purdue adds that some butternuts have very dark gray bark that closely resembles black walnut bark, though it usually retains light gray platy surfaces on top of the ridges. The Silvics chapter on butternut by Rink says the tree is also called white walnut or oilnut, is short-lived and seldom reaches 75 years. Black walnut is also called eastern black walnut or American walnut. Michigan State gives butternut heights of 40 to 60 feet in its region.
Hickories and pecan
Purdue gives two ways to tell hickories from butternut. Hickory leaves normally have 9 or fewer leaflets, and the leaflets get larger toward the end of the leaf. Butternut leaflets are largest in the central part. A pecan leaf may have more than 9 leaflets, but they are also largest near the end. Hickory nuts sit in woody husks that split along four obvious seams, and the leaf scar has no moustache.
- Shagbark hickory: the Silvics chapter by Graney calls it probably the most distinctive hickory because of its loose-plated bark. Other names are shellbark, scalybark and upland hickory. The husk splits freely to the base into four valves along grooved sutures.
- Bitternut hickory: Michigan State gives 7 to 11 toothed leaflets, largest at the tip. Terminal buds are yellow with a powdery look. Leaf scars are heart-shaped, and the husk is four-part around a bitter nut.
Butternut and hybrids
Purdue reports that butternut has hybridized with Japanese walnut, and that hybrids have been planted for decades as butternut. It says butternut does not hybridize with black walnut. No single trait separates a butternut from a hybrid, so the publication gives a table of traits and a scoring key.
| Trait | Butternut | Hybrid |
|---|---|---|
| Pith | Very dark brown | Variable, more often medium or light brown |
| Lenticels | Small, round, abundant, evenly distributed | Large, often elongated along the branch |
| Leaf scar top edge | Straight or slightly convex | Almost always notched |
| Leaf fall | Early to mid autumn | Late autumn, may freeze green |
| Catkins | 2 to 4 3/4 inches | 5 to 10 inches |
| Nuts per cluster | One or two, sometimes 3 to 5 | Usually 3 to 5, sometimes 7 |
The Purdue key scores each of at least five traits as 0, 1 or 2. A total of 3 or less is probably a butternut, and more than 3 is probably a hybrid or heartnut. The publication calls the key a field guide that is not definitive, and says genetic testing may be the only reliable method for some trees. Hybrids were planted around farms, parks and yards. Trees in natural forest, or at least 300 feet inside a woodlot with no old home sites, are much more likely to be pure butternuts.
Purdue also reports that butternut is threatened everywhere by the butternut canker fungus and is rare in many places. Michigan State says most butternuts in the Upper Peninsula have cankers that show as cracks that are black inside.
Sources
- Purdue Extension and USDA Forest Service, Identification of Butternuts and Butternut Hybrids (FNR-420-W), Farlee, Woeste, Ostry, McKenna and Weeks, read October 16, 2026
- USDA Forest Service, Silvics of North America, Butternut (Juglans cinerea), Rink, read October 16, 2026
- USDA Forest Service, Silvics of North America, Black Walnut (Juglans nigra), Williams, read October 16, 2026
- USDA Forest Service, Silvics of North America, Shagbark Hickory (Carya ovata), Graney, read October 16, 2026
- Michigan State University Extension, U.P. Tree Identification Key: butternut, walnut, bitternut, read October 16, 2026