Identifying poplars, aspens, cottonwoods and willows
Poplars, aspens, cottonwoods and willows all belong to the willow family, Salicaceae. The Woodland Trust gives the leaf, bark, twig and flower features of three of them, and the US Forest Service Silvics chapters cover two North American trees.
Checked against the sources at the bottom of this page on October 16, 2026. Rules, fees and pay change: the source has the last word.
The Woodland Trust lists black poplar and aspen as native to Britain and crack willow as non-native, native to Europe and Western Asia. Eastern cottonwood and black willow are North American. The features below come from the Woodland Trust's tree guides and from the Silvics of North America chapters.
Poplars and aspen in Britain
The Woodland Trust describes black poplar (Populus nigra) as a tree of up to 30 m that can live for 200 years. The bark is dark brown and often looks black, thick, with many fissures and burrs. Twigs are lumpy and brown. Leaves are shiny, green and heart-shaped with long tips, and they carry a mild scent of balsam. Young leaves have fine hairs that drop off by autumn. Buds spiral round the twig and sit close against it.
Black poplar is dioecious: male and female flowers grow on separate trees. Male catkins are red and female catkins yellow-green. The seeds are fluffy and cotton-like and fall in late summer. The Trust names white poplar (Populus alba) as the look-alike, with rounder leaves than the black poplar's more triangular ones.
For aspen (Populus tremula) the Trust gives a height of up to 25 m. The leaves are round with large, irregular, blunt teeth. The leaf stalks are flattened and flexible near the blade, which is why the leaves flutter in the slightest breeze. Young leaves are coppery before turning green, then yellow or occasionally red in autumn. The bark is grey and often pitted with diamond-shaped lenticels. Older trees may be covered in lichen, which makes the trunk look black. Twigs are dark brown, slender, shiny and knobbly, with buds that spiral and sit close to the twig. Catkins open in March and April, and aspen spreads by suckers from the root system into clonal colonies.
Crack willow
The Woodland Trust says crack willow (Salix fragilis) is hard to tell apart from white willow. It grows to 25 m. The bark is dark brown with deep fissures that deepen with age. Twigs are slender, shiny and yellow-brown, and they snap with a crack. Buds are narrow, hairless and pressed to the twig. The leaves are long, slender, dark glossy green above and blue-green below. They are longer than white willow leaves and lack the fine silky white hairs on the underside. Catkins appear before the leaves, and the Trust says other willow species all freely hybridise, with crack willow often hybridising with white willow. It is found along rivers, lakes and watercourses and is regularly planted to stabilise banks and dykes.
Cottonwoods and black willow in North America
The Silvics chapter on eastern cottonwood (Populus deltoides) lists the other names southern cottonwood, Carolina poplar, eastern poplar, necklace poplar and alamo. It calls the tree one of the largest eastern hardwoods and the fastest-growing commercial forest species in North America. Heights of 53 to 58 m have been reported. It grows on moist, well-drained sands and silts near streams, from southern Quebec west into North Dakota and southwestern Manitoba, south to central Texas and east to northwestern Florida and Georgia.
Flowers open from February to April before the leaves appear. Male flowers are reddish and 8 to 13 cm long. Female flowers lengthen to 15 to 30 cm. The western variety, plains cottonwood, has leaves broader than long, slightly smaller and more coarsely toothed than the typical variety. The two varieties intergrade where their ranges overlap.
The Silvics chapter on black willow (Salix nigra) calls it the largest and the only commercially important willow among about 90 native North American species. Twenty-seven of those species reach tree size in part of their range. Black willow is short-lived and fast-growing, and it is tied to wet soils near water, especially floodplains. Catkins usually appear at or just before leafing out. The tallest trees are 43 m.
Hybrids and look-alikes
| Tree | Look-alike or hybrid named | Source |
|---|---|---|
| Black poplar | White poplar, with rounder leaves | Woodland Trust |
| Aspen | Black poplar, listed as another poplar not to be confused with it | Woodland Trust |
| Crack willow | White willow, hard to tell apart; other willow species all freely hybridise and crack willow often hybridises with white willow | Woodland Trust |
| Eastern cottonwood | Hybridises freely with plains cottonwood; its hybrids with Populus nigra are the best known; hybrid swarms with Populus balsamifera, P. tremuloides and P. grandidentata are reported | Silvics, Populus deltoides |
| Black willow | Natural willow hybrids are not common and are hard to verify; the Silvics lists Salix alba, S. amygdaloides and four other willows as hybrid partners | Silvics, Salix nigra |
Where the trees are covered on this site
Poplar and willow pests have their own register in what attacks poplar and aspen and what attacks willow. Species pages cover eastern cottonwood, quaking aspen and black willow.
Sources
- Woodland Trust, Black poplar (Populus nigra), A-Z of British trees, read October 16, 2026
- Woodland Trust, Aspen (Populus tremula), A-Z of British trees, read October 16, 2026
- Woodland Trust, Crack willow (Salix fragilis), A-Z of British trees, read October 16, 2026
- USDA Forest Service, Silvics of North America, Populus deltoides (eastern cottonwood), mirrored by Virginia Tech Dendrology, read October 16, 2026
- USDA Forest Service, Silvics of North America, Salix nigra (black willow), mirrored by Virginia Tech Dendrology, read October 16, 2026