Experience rating and the mod: what California, Washington and British Columbia say about workers' compensation
A workers' compensation premium can be adjusted up or down by a firm's own claims history. California, Washington and British Columbia each describe that adjustment, in an insurance guide, an administrative code and WorkSafeBC pages.
Checked against the sources at the bottom of this page on October 9, 2026. Rules, fees and pay change: the source has the last word.
This page reports what the official source says. It is not legal advice: ask the office named here. It covers three places and says nothing about any tree firm's own number.
California: the experience modification
The California Department of Insurance says the base premium comes from a classification code and its rate, applied per USD 100 of payroll, and is then modified by rating plans and by an experience modification. The modification is calculated from payroll and loss information that insurers must send each year to the Workers' Compensation Insurance Rating Bureau (WCIRB). The bureau uses a mathematical formula approved by the department, which takes into account the employer's payroll and losses, both paid losses and loss reserves, for an experience period.
The modification compares the employer's loss history with all other employers in the same industry that are similar in size. Generally, a modification below 100 percent reflects better-than-average experience and one above 100 percent reflects worse-than-average experience. The bureau can issue modifications from reported losses without unaudited payroll, which the guide says typically produces a higher modification than in earlier years. For the audit side, see the guide to workers' compensation premium audits.
Washington: the rule in the administrative code
In Washington, the rules sit in chapter 296-17 of the Washington Administrative Code. WAC 296-17-855, filed November 26, 2025 and effective January 1, 2026, sets the basis as a comparison. On one side are the actual losses charged to an employer during the experience period. On the other are the expected losses for an average employer reporting the same exposures in each classification. The comparison is weighted for how credible the employer's own experience is, given its volume. The expected losses are summed over the three years of the experience period, using the classification expected loss rates in its tables.
| Point in WAC 296-17-855 and 296-17-870 | What the rule says |
|---|---|
| Factor | The credible actual primary loss plus the credible actual excess loss, divided by the expected loss |
| Primary loss | For a claim of less than USD 28,180 the full value of the claim is primary loss; above that, a formula in the rule splits the claim into primary and excess parts |
| Claims without disability benefits | Actual losses are first reduced by the lesser of USD 4,100 or the total cost of the claim. The rule says USD 4,100 is twice the average case incurred cost of these claims during the three-year period |
| Which claims count | Claims with a date of injury during the experience period, evaluated on the valuation date, June 1, seven months before the effective date of premium rates |
| Changes after the valuation date | No claim value is revised between valuation dates, with listed exceptions such as a mistake other than error of judgment, a third party recovery, a second injury claim, or a claim later found noncompensable. No retroactive adjustment is made for rating periods more than ten years before the status change |
British Columbia: the experience rating adjustment
WorkSafeBC states its premium formula as the industry's base premium rate, plus or minus the firm's experience rating, times the firm's assessable payroll. A firm with claim costs lower than the average for similar sized businesses in its rate group can earn discounts of up to 50 percent over time. One with higher than average claim costs may face surcharges of up to 100 percent over time. The discount or surcharge is called the experience rating adjustment, and it is applied to the base rate to give the net premium rate.
A worked example: a base rate of 3.00 percent with a 10 percent discount gives a net rate of 2.70 percent. On an assessable payroll of CAD 100,000 the premium is CAD 2,700, a difference of CAD 300. WorkSafeBC's premium rate letter confirms the classification, gives the base premium rate, shows any experience rating adjustments, and gives the net premium rate and the maximum assessable earnings per worker.
Side by side
| Place | Name | How it is stated |
|---|---|---|
| California | Experience modification | A comparison to similar sized employers in the same industry; below 100 percent is better than average |
| Washington | Experience modification factor | Credible actual losses over expected losses for the same classifications |
| British Columbia | Experience rating adjustment | A discount of up to 50 percent or a surcharge of up to 100 percent on the base rate over time |
None of the pages gives any tree service's modification or rate. For the published class codes and rates, see workers' comp for tree work in the US.
Sources
- California Department of Insurance, workers' compensation insurance guide, experience modification, read October 9, 2026
- Washington State Legislature, WAC 296-17-855, experience modification, filed November 26, 2025, effective January 1, 2026, read October 9, 2026
- Washington State Legislature, WAC 296-17-870, evaluation of losses for experience rating, read October 9, 2026
- WorkSafeBC, know how much coverage costs, read October 9, 2026
- WorkSafeBC, premium rate letter, read October 9, 2026