ArbNation Join free

Is my ash worth saving? The extension canopy-loss thresholds

University extension publications put the line for treating an emerald ash borer infested ash at 50 per cent canopy thinning. A Texas publication puts the line for recovery at 30 per cent.

Checked against the sources at the bottom of this page on October 16, 2026. Rules, fees and pay change: the source has the last word.

Four extension publications give a canopy figure for ash trees infested with emerald ash borer (EAB). Three use 50 per cent. One uses 30 per cent. For the beetle itself, see emerald ash borer: what the agencies record.

The figures, by publication

Figures for canopy loss in infested ash
Publication and dateWhat it records
University of Wisconsin-Madison, Is my ash tree worth treating (XHT1215), revised January 29, 2026Research suggests insecticide treatments are more effective on infested ash with less than 50 per cent canopy thinning. Treatments are not recommended above 50 per cent, and those trees should be removed.
University of Wisconsin, Professional guide to EAB insecticide treatments (XHT1185), revised April 7, 2022The same 50 per cent line. Ash with more than 50 per cent thinning should be removed and destroyed under local, state and federal guidelines.
North Central IPM Center bulletin, Insecticide options for protecting ash trees (Herms and others), June 2009A tree that has lost more than 50 per cent of its canopy is probably too late to save. Trees above 50 per cent decline are unlikely to recover even if treated.
Texas A&M AgriLife Extension, EAB control: a guide for professionals (ENTO-PU-228), October 2024Infested trees with over 30 per cent canopy decline cannot be recovered with insecticide. A figure caption in the same guide shows ash with more than 50 per cent canopy loss.

Why a declining canopy matters to treatment

The 2009 bulletin explains the mechanism. Most insecticides used on EAB are systemic, so the tree must be healthy enough to carry them up the trunk and into the canopy. Larval galleries injure the phloem and xylem, and heavily infested trees can be girdled on large branches or the trunk.

The bulletin also reports that a tree whose canopy is already declining may keep deteriorating through the first year of treatment. In many cases the canopy begins to improve in the second year. The authors say the lag probably reflects the time the tree needs to repair its vascular system. Texas A&M repeats the second-year point, and adds that recovery may not show after the first year.

Where the 30 and 50 per cent figures differ

The Texas guide puts the lower figure in its text: with over 30 per cent decline, the inner bark and cambium are too damaged to transport food, and the xylem can no longer move water or insecticide. Insecticide on trees below 30 per cent decline can prevent further injury, but needs repeated applications and time for full recovery. The Wisconsin and 2009 bulletin figures are 50 per cent.

Signs the publications link to EAB

The University of Wisconsin article lists these symptoms of an infestation: canopy thinning starting in the upper tree, epicormic sprouting along the trunk, bark splitting and woodpecker damage. It reports that other diseases and insects can cause the same symptoms. Its specific signs are D-shaped exit holes about 3/16 inch wide, S-shaped larval tunnels under the bark, cream-coloured larvae up to 1.5 inches long and metallic green adults about 3/8 inch long.

The 2009 bulletin reports that ash with low densities of EAB often show few or no external symptoms. Because of that, the bulletin ties risk to distance from known infestations: within a quarantined county, or within 10 to 15 miles of a known infestation.

What else the publications weigh

The Wisconsin article lists value as a factor alongside canopy: health, shape, location, appearance through the seasons and shade. A tree with disease, structural damage or a bad location, near a power line for example, counts as lower value. It adds that the cost of yearly insecticide treatment is weighed against that value. The 2009 bulletin lists the cost of insecticide and application, tree size, likelihood of success, and removal and replacement costs.

The Wisconsin article also reports that ash trees are known to become brittle and hazardous relatively quickly. The treatment methods are compared in emerald ash borer treatment options. Removal and wood movement rules are in emerald ash borer regulation by country.

Sources