ISA Code of Ethics and certification discipline: what happens after a complaint
ISA's Ethics Case Procedures set the steps from a written complaint to a hearing, an appeal and a sanction. Sanctions include private or public reprimands and revocation, and a suspension lasts six months to two years.
Checked against the sources at the bottom of this page on October 21, 2026. Rules, fees and pay change: the source has the last word.
ISA's Ethics Violations page says its Ethics Review Committee investigates unethical behavior reported by other arborists or the public. ISA's Code of Ethics page says the Credentialing Council implemented the code as a central guide and reference for arborists and tree care professionals. The code is part of the application process for all credential programs, and signing it is a requirement for ISA certifications and qualifications.
The Ethics Case Procedures cover credential holders, former holders who were certified when the events happened, and people seeking certification. They describe themselves as the only rules for processing possible violations. They are not formal legal proceedings, and parties may bring an attorney.
Filing and confidentiality
Any person, group or organization can file, and so can ISA's Compliance and Ethics Specialist. A complaint is a detailed written statement of the factual allegations. ISA's page says the complaint is confidential, but the complainant's name and the complaint information are shared with the person reported.
All materials are confidential until the case is closed, including the fact that the case exists. A complainant who breaks this can see the complaint terminated. A respondent who breaks it can face any sanction in the procedures. Legal counsel and witnesses are the exceptions, and final published rulings are not confidential.
ISA may consider a charge whatever the credential type, whenever the violation happened, and whether or not the respondent still holds a credential. A respondent who tries to give up the credential or withdraw an application during a case does not end it, because the committee may continue to a final resolution.
From charge to hearing
The Specialist weighs five things before a charge becomes a formal complaint. They are whether a proven complaint would breach the code, whether too much time has passed, whether reliable proof exists, whether the complainant will testify, and whether the charge looks justified. The Committee makes the final call on acceptance. A complainant can appeal a rejection within 30 days, and that decision cannot be appealed further.
An accepted complaint goes to the respondent as a confidential notice naming each alleged violation. The respondent has 30 days from the mailing date to respond in full, with the relevant documents. The Committee then votes on whether the case goes to a hearing or is dismissed. The complainant and the respondent each get an optional reply of ten days.
The Committee has twelve credential holders in good standing, drawn from Certified Arborists, Certified Tree Climbers and Board Certified Master Arborists. Hearings are informal. Parties can join by telephone, and no formal rules of evidence, oath or cross-examination apply. Parties pay their own expenses. The Committee decides by majority vote in closed session and issues a written Decision and Order.
Suspension before a decision
After a formal complaint, a respondent may be asked to sign a Voluntary Temporary Suspension Agreement and stop presenting as certified or endorsed by ISA. If the respondent does not sign, ISA can order a suspension until the case ends. The procedures list the grounds, which include an indictment or conviction under criminal law, a formal complaint or finding by a professional regulatory body or credentialing body, and litigation about the respondent's professional practice.
Sanctions
- A recommendation that the person be ineligible for certification or recertification, with any application denied.
- Specific training, supervision or instruction.
- A private reprimand and censure, or a public one, with conditions.
- Certification probation for up to three years.
- Suspension for no less than six months and no more than two years. The Committee decides whether the renewal clock stops, whether the holder can recertify during the suspension and whether CEUs can be earned.
- Revocation of certification.
Appeals and afterwards
An adverse Committee decision can be appealed in writing within 30 days of the mailing date. The grounds are limited to new information, a decision contrary to the information presented, a procedural error and a misapplication of the code. A complainant has no appeal when no violation is found. A separate Appeals Committee, drawn from members who did not hear the case, decides by majority vote.
A final decision may be published, but the Committee or ISA can deny a publication request and that cannot be appealed. ISA does not provide hearing transcripts. The Specialist may notify governmental or professional bodies of a discipline once the appeal period has passed. Five years after a final revocation order, a respondent may write to ask to reapply. After a suspension expires, the credential can be reactivated for the rest of the certification period, and a credential that lapsed during the suspension must be recertified by exam or by a decertification appeal.