ArbNation Join free

Likelihood matrices compared: ISA risk matrices, QTRA probability ranges and VALID ratings

The ISA form uses four-step labels and two matrices, QTRA uses numeric ranges and a calculator, and VALID uses four traffic-light ratings. Older forms summed points instead.

Checked against the sources at the bottom of this page on October 15, 2026. Rules, fees and pay change: the source has the last word.

This page reports what the official source says. It is not legal advice: ask the office named here. The systems below are described in the wording of their owners.

ISA Basic Tree Risk Assessment form

The ISA's instructions for the Basic Tree Risk Assessment form say the form is meant for a basic, Level 2 assessment. It records four inputs on page 1: likelihood of failure, likelihood of impact, consequences, and the target. Page 2 combines them through two matrices.

Matrix 1, the likelihood matrix, combines the likelihood of failure with the likelihood of impact. Matrix 2, the risk matrix, combines that result with the consequences. The rating for the whole tree is the highest found for any failure type and target. The form's residual risk line can also read none, and the instructions apply none only if the tree is recommended for complete removal.

Category labels on the ISA form
StepCategories, in the form's order
Likelihood of failureImprobable, Possible, Probable, Imminent
Likelihood of impactVery low, Low, Medium, High
Matrix 1 result: failure and impactUnlikely, Somewhat likely, Likely, Very likely
ConsequencesNegligible, Minor, Significant, Severe
Matrix 2 result: risk ratingLow, Moderate, High, Extreme

QTRA probability ranges

The Quantified Tree Risk Assessment Practice Note, version 5, sets three inputs in broad ranges: Target, Size and Probability of Failure. Target has six ranges, Size has four, and Probability of Failure has seven. The assessor estimates the probability that the tree or branch fails within one year.

QTRA Probability of Failure ranges
RangeProbability within one year
11 in 1 down to more than 1 in 10
21 in 10 down to more than 1 in 100
31 in 100 down to more than 1 in 1,000
41 in 1,000 down to more than 1 in 10,000
51 in 10,000 down to more than 1 in 100,000
61 in 100,000 down to more than 1 in 1,000,000
71 in 1,000,000 to 1 in 10,000,000

A calculator or software turns the three ranges into a Risk of Harm, shown as a probability rounded to one significant figure and colour coded as a traffic light. In the Practice Note's Tolerability of Risk framework, the broadly acceptable region tops out at an annual risk of death of 1 in 1,000,000, and the unacceptable region starts at 1 in 1,000. QTRA's About page prints advisory thresholds at 1 in 1,000, 1 in 10,000 and 1 in 1,000,000. It pairs the labels Unacceptable, Tolerable and Broadly Acceptable with separate wording for risks accepted by agreement and risks imposed on others. Under that wording a broadly acceptable risk is already ALARP.

VALID traffic-light ratings

In its own summary, the What is VALID PDF, the group applies ISO 31000 and the Tolerability of Risk framework. It names four traffic-light ratings. Red is Not Acceptable, and those risks will be reduced to an acceptable level. The first amber is Not Tolerable: the risk is not ALARP and is reduced, at lower priority than red. The second amber is Tolerable: the risk is ALARP and is not reduced, though it may need more frequent assessment. Green is Acceptable, and those risks are not reduced. VALID leads with a strategy and uses an app for detailed assessments.

Older numeric forms

A University of Florida extension paper, ENH1226, compares three forms used in North America. Its authors write that the two older forms produce a numerical rating from ratings that are qualitative or subjective, so they are not quantitative methods. The newer ISA method replaced the numbers with descriptive categories to remove the false sense of accuracy.

Rating scales on three forms, from ENH1226
FormLikelihood of failureFinal rating
ISA Tree Hazard EvaluationLow, Medium, High, Severe (1 to 4 points)Number from 3 to 12
USDA Forest Service Community Tree Risk EvaluationLow, Moderate, High, Extremely High (1 to 4 points)Number from 3 to 10, plus up to 2 optional points
ISA Tree Risk Assessment BMPImprobable, Possible, Probable, ImminentLow, Moderate, High, Extreme, from a series of matrices

The paper states that no concrete threshold on a numeric rating sorts one tree as safe or hazardous. It treats the numbers as a way to rank trees in a population.

One council's use

Torbay Council's 2010 tree risk strategy adopted QTRA and sorts land into three risk zones. It cites the Health and Safety Executive limit of 1 in 10,000 per year for members of the public who have a risk imposed on them in the wider interest. It puts the UK value of statistical life at about £750,000 to £1,000,000. The QTRA Practice Note applies £1,500,000.

Sources