ArbNation Join free

Mycorrhizae and the 'wood wide web': peer-reviewed studies versus popular claims

Common mycorrhizal networks are proven to exist, but a 2023 review found no strong evidence that they benefit trees and seedlings. The authors of the older studies disagree.

Checked against the sources at the bottom of this page on October 16, 2026. Rules, fees and pay change: the source has the last word.

A common mycorrhizal network, or CMN, forms when fungal threads connect the roots of several plants underground. The popular name is the "wood wide web". A 2023 paper in Nature Ecology & Evolution by Justine Karst, Melanie Jones and Jason Hoeksema tested three claims that spread through popular media.

The three claims tested

Karst and her co-authors reviewed field studies for each claim. Their abstract calls the first two insufficiently supported, because field results vary too widely, have other explanations or are too limited to generalise from.

Karst, Jones and Hoeksema (2023), Nature Ecology & Evolution
Popular claimFinding of the review
CMNs are widespread in forestsNot enough evidence. Too few forests have been mapped.
Resources move through CMNs from adult trees to seedlings and raise seedling survival and growthResources can move underground, but CMNs do not necessarily carry the flow. Across 26 studies, evidence for a benefit and for a harm was roughly equal, and a neutral effect was reported most often.
Mature trees send resources and warning signals to their offspring through CMNsNo peer-reviewed, published field study backs it.

Citation bias

The same paper looked at how CMN research is cited. It found that unsupported claims have doubled in the past 25 years, and that a bias toward citing positive effects may hide what is known about CMN structure and function in forests.

The paper concludes that knowledge of CMNs is too sparse and unsettled to inform forest management. The University of Alberta news release of February 13, 2023, quotes Karst on the point: it is premature to base forest practices and policies on CMNs without further evidence.

The response from the older studies

Suzanne Simard, Teresa Ryan and David Perry answered in an opinion article in Frontiers in Forests and Global Change, published January 21, 2025. They write that CMNs were first found in the laboratory in 1969 and have been studied for five decades with microscopy, DNA sequencing and isotope tracing. Their view is that the evidence shows CMNs connecting trees with other trees and with compatible seedlings and shrubs.

They point to four questions: whether CMNs exist in forests, whether they move nutrients, carbon, water or chemical signals, how that transfer varies, and whether membership in a CMN affects tree performance. For the fourth they call the results context dependent.

The response also faults the Karst paper. It calls the literature search narrow and incomplete, says the paper chose 18 studies on subjective grounds, and says its sample grew to 273 by counting each publication year.

One experiment is argued in detail. In the 1997 study of paper birch, Douglas-fir and western redcedar, 18 percent of the carbon isotope reached the redcedar, which the authors read as transfer through the network and, to a lesser degree, through soil.

Where the two sides meet

Both sides accept that CMNs exist and that belowground transfer can occur by more than one pathway. The Frontiers authors say transfer runs through CMNs, mycorrhizal roots and soil at the same time. Karst and colleagues say transfer can happen without a CMN being the cause.

The disagreement is over how much the studies show about benefit to seedlings and about signalling between trees. The Karst paper and the response were both published in peer-reviewed journals, and the response names the Karst paper as one of three critiques it answers.

Forest management

The Alberta release says the researchers see overblown claims as a risk to how forests are managed. The Frontiers authors describe their work as having shifted scientists' view of forests from separate competing trees to connected systems.

Sources