ArbNation Join free

Opposite or alternate: the branching test and the species it separates

Most tree species have alternate leaves and buds. Virginia Tech's rule of thumb is that opposite leaves point to maple, ash, dogwood, the family Caprifoliaceae or horse chestnut, and Colorado State's key lists the genera on each side.

Checked against the sources at the bottom of this page on October 15, 2026. Rules, fees and pay change: the source has the last word.

The test

Virginia Tech's Basics of Tree ID defines the test by the twig. Leaves grow on alternate or opposite sides of it, and most species are alternate. Buds usually sit where the leaf meets the twig, so the buds follow the leaves. As buds grow out, the branching pattern follows the same arrangement. The University of Maryland winter key uses the same idea on the bare twig, with leaf scars in place of leaves: "leaf scars opposite" sends the reader one way and "leaf scars alternate" the other.

Colorado State Extension adds a third class for its tree key. Northern catalpa has whorled leaves, with three buds per node.

The opposite short list

Virginia Tech says that if leaves grow on opposite sides of a twig, there is a very good chance the tree is a maple, ash, dogwood, a member of the family Caprifoliaceae, or horsechestnut, also called buckeye. Students use the acronym "MAD Cap Horse".

Colorado State's Front Range key splits the genera it covers this way.

Leaf and bud arrangement in the Colorado State key
ArrangementGenera and groups listed
OppositeMaples (Acer), buckeyes (Aesculus), ash (Fraxinus)
AlternateHackberries, hawthorns, walnuts, apple, poplars, cherries, pears, oaks, mountain ashes, lindens, elms, and legumes from several genera
WhorledNorthern catalpa

Two pairs in that list are easy to mix up. Mountain ash (Sorbus) sits in the alternate group, and true ash (Fraxinus) sits in the opposite one. The key files maples under opposite simple leaves and excludes boxelder (Acer negundo), which it files under compound leaves.

Telling the opposite groups apart

The Colorado State key goes on to separate the opposite trees by leaf type. Maples with simple leaves split on the buds: silver maple has large clusters of brown buds and deeply lobed leaves, Norway maple has stout branches, a large terminal bud and milky sap, and sugar maple has scaly, pointed buds. Horse-chestnut has palmately compound leaves. Boxelder has three to five leaflets, waxy twigs and double samaras hanging in chains. Ash has five or more leaflets, buds covered with short hairs, and single samaras.

The Maryland winter key gives twig features for the same trees. Of its opposite entries, the ash group (Fraxinus) has many bundle scars joined in a line, broadly rounded buds and fairly stout twigs. White ash has a U-shaped leaf scar with the lateral bud in the notch. Green ash has a rounded terminal bud and an oval leaf scar. In the maple group, sugar maple has a quite pointy brown terminal bud, red maple has many bud scales on a reddish blunt bud, and silver maple has bud scales in two vertical rows. Boxelder has fuzzy white buds on green to purplish twigs with a gray or bluish coating.

Alternate groups in the same key

Colorado State sorts alternate trees first by simple or compound leaves. Oaks have pinnately lobed simple leaves, clustered terminal buds and acorns. Elms have unequal leaf bases, and hackberry has a similar base with a purple drupe and warty gray bark. Redbud has heart-shaped leaves with zigzag twigs and pod fruit. Lindens have heart-shaped leaves with a banana-shaped bract. Black walnut has a terminal bud with chambered pith, and honeylocust has no terminal bud and zigzag twigs.

For pages on single species, see sugar maple, boxelder and white ash. Bark and conifer keys are on the guides to bark identification and conifers.

Sources