ArbNation Join free

Leaving a tree stump: what South Dakota, Iowa State and Illinois extension pages record

Iowa State Extension says to evaluate a decaying stump regularly and remove it when it could harm people or property should it fall. Illinois Extension lists leaving a dead stump as an ecologically valuable option.

This page is for tree owners. It reports what the named sources say and is not advice about your tree: for that, ask a qualified arborist or one of the offices under Who to call.

Checked against the sources at the bottom of this page on October 19, 2026. Rules, fees and pay change: the source has the last word.

This page reports what the official source says. It is not legal advice: ask the office named here. No extension page used here calls a stump a hazard in itself or sets a legal duty to remove one. The wording below is from South Dakota State University Extension, Iowa State University Extension and Outreach, and University of Illinois Extension.

Where the pages mention risk

Iowa State's page on tree stumps is the only one of the three with a safety test for a stump left in place. It says dead stumps are important sources of food and shelter for insects, birds and other wildlife, and suggests leaving one in areas that are isolated or where there is little risk of damage to property or people. Whatever the reason for leaving it, the stump's structural stability is an important consideration. A decaying stump is evaluated regularly and removed when it poses a risk to people or property should it fall.

Illinois Extension lists "do nothing" as an ecologically valuable option. Dead trees are tough to find in a developed area, it says, and can be a refuge for wild animals. A tall stump left in place, or a shorter one, can be dressed as a fairy house or hold flower containers. South Dakota State University Extension does not discuss leaving a stump. Its page covers professional grinding and natural decay.

The options each page names

Stump options as each extension page prints them
OptionWhat the pages record
GrindingGrinds the stump and large surface roots, usually to 8 to 12 inches deep (SDSU, Iowa State); grinding services charge by the inch or by the stump size; chips and a filled hole usually cost extra (SDSU, Iowa State)
Natural decayA decade or more (SDSU); 10 years or more depending on soil moisture, wood-decay fungi and species (Iowa State)
Accelerated decayOne to three years after drilling 1-inch holes and adding about 4 ounces of slow-release fertilizer to each (SDSU, Iowa State). Illinois cites University of Georgia work giving about 25% faster decay for chemicals and up to 50% for enhanced natural decay
DiggingLabour-intensive; realistic on smaller stumps, under about 12 inches across (Iowa State); the Illinois author would not go much over a 6-inch trunk by hand
Pulling or pushing with machineryNeeds heavy equipment and a place to operate it (Illinois); chains that slip or break while pulling can cause great harm to people and property (Iowa State)
BurningListed as a method to avoid by Iowa State, with accelerants leaching into the soil and fires that burn for days; Illinois says to check local ordinances on open burning

Sprouting and what follows

Some stumps resprout after the tree is cut, as Iowa State and Illinois Extension both record. Both describe herbicide with glyphosate or triclopyr applied to the stump while the cut is fresh, and Iowa State adds imazapyr and puts it on the living cambium tissue, a ring just below the bark. Iowa State names picloram as a product that leaches and remains active in soil. It adds that herbicide poured in drilled holes well after removal does not help decay and can harm nearby plants.

Both pages also describe what grinding leaves behind. Iowa State says the shavings change the soil's structure, moisture-holding capacity and nutrient balance, which makes it hard for new turf or plants to grow. Illinois says wood mixed into the soil can tie up nitrogen as it breaks down.

SDSU opens its page with a comment on the tree, not the stump: removing trees and disposing of the brush is a hazardous undertaking, best performed by professionals who have the training and equipment to remove them safely.

For the wider picture, see the guide to stump removal options, the guide to stump sprouting by species and the guide to carpenter ants and termites in stumps and trees.

Who to call

Sources