ArbNation Join free

Palm work hazards: frond collapse in California fatality investigations

Three California Department of Public Health documents record how dead palm fronds collapsed onto workers cutting from underneath. Two are case reports on single deaths and one is a worker fatality alert covering three.

Checked against the sources at the bottom of this page on October 16, 2026. Rules, fees and pay change: the source has the last word.

The California reports below are described as published. It is not training and does not teach the work. The documents come from the California Fatality Assessment and Control Evaluation (CA/FACE) program of the California Department of Public Health, which investigates fatal work injuries and makes prevention recommendations. No victim is named.

The February 2014 worker fatality alert

The alert, titled Tree Trimmers Suffocated by Palm Fronds, covers three workers who died between 2010 and 2012 while trimming palms in Southern California. In all three cases the workers climbed the tree and trimmed fronds from the bottom up, which put them directly beneath the fronds. Neither the workers nor their supervisors were certified tree workers. The workers were pinned by thick layers of dead fronds and suffocated.

The alert gives the mechanism. When a trimmer cuts or pulls on dead fronds, adjacent fronds or an entire ring of fronds may collapse and encase the worker, and the weight presses on the chest. It adds that California has over 45,000 palm trees, many of them mature, tall and carrying many years of frond growth.

Case 12CA006: June 9, 2012

A tree trimmer was working on a 50-foot palm in a private yard. It was the fourth palm he had climbed that day. He climbed under the dead fronds, about 40 feet up, and began to pull them off by hand. The remaining fronds collapsed onto him and pressed him against the trunk. A coworker called 911. The fire department and paramedics received the call at 4:46 p.m. and arrived within four minutes. The crew needed more help, and a second ladder truck and an Urban Search and Rescue task force were requested. Thermal imaging located him in the tree. Firefighters reached him at 5:31 p.m., and he was pronounced dead at the scene at 5:50 p.m. The cause of death on the certificate was mechanical asphyxia.

The company had been in business four years, did not have a current contractor's license in California and had no written injury and illness prevention program. The investigator named improper work practices, such as removing multiple years of growth from below, and a lack of correct equipment as the contributing factors.

Case 16CA007: December 4, 2016

A landscaper died trimming a palm of about 60 feet in a back yard. The tree carried many years of dead fronds. The skirt of fronds above him broke loose and slid down, compressing him against the trunk. The 911 call came at 9:56 a.m. and the local fire department arrived within six minutes. A neighbouring city sent a 75-foot ladder truck. The rescue took about 61 minutes, and he was unresponsive and without a pulse when firefighters reached him. The death certificate gives restrictive asphyxia.

The employer in this case was an individual with 25 years of landscape work who had never had specific training in trimming palms. There was no written injury and illness prevention program. Neither the victim nor the landscaper who hired him was certified. The report is dated October 30, 2017.

What the investigators recommend

All three documents make the same two recommendations to tree care companies and self-employed workers:

  • Palm trimming or removal is performed or supervised by workers trained and certified by bodies such as the Tree Care Industry Association (TCIA) or the International Society of Arboriculture (ISA).
  • Proper work procedures and equipment are used. The alert says fronds should be removed by workers using an aerial device and fall protection, or by climbing procedures that place the worker above the fronds. Report 16CA007 names an aerial lift and cutting fronds from above.

Report 12CA006 describes a climbing procedure developed by arborists in the San Diego and Los Angeles area. It suspends the worker from the top of the palm, which removes the need to work under the skirt. The report says only a trained and experienced tree worker should use it.

The documents also address people outside the crew. The alert tells homeowners to hire companies with a current tree service contractor's license, and adds that under certain circumstances homeowners may be liable for worker injuries on their property if they hire unlicensed trimmers. Both case reports recommend that fire departments in locations with palm trees develop rescue protocols for trapped palm trimmers.

Where this fits on the site

The full list of palm trimming reports is in palm tree trimming deaths in California. The 2016 case has its own page, and UF/IFAS pruning guidance is in palm pruning: what UF/IFAS says.

To correct or remove an entry, write to the address at the foot of this page.

Sources