Growths, lumps and swellings on branches and trunks: causes the extension services give
Extension services at Minnesota, Wisconsin, Connecticut and Utah State sort lumps on trees into burls, galls, cankers and witches' brooms. Each leaves a different shape, and the cause is not always known.
Checked against the sources at the bottom of this page on October 16, 2026. Rules, fees and pay change: the source has the last word.
The agencies below describe how each growth looks, what is known of its cause and what they say about cutting it out.
Burls
The University of Minnesota's diagnostic page for linden describes burls as large round to semi-circular swellings along the main trunk or large branches. Many buds or sprouts may sit on the burl. Burls keep growing as the tree grows. They do not kill trees directly, but they can reduce a tree's health and lifespan, and Minnesota gives no known cause.
The University of Connecticut's Home and Garden Education Center calls burls sound, hard, woody swellings on trunks, branches or roots. They often look like rounded or ridged masses, and normal bark covers the outside. Connecticut says the exact cause is a mystery. The growth comes from abnormal cell division in the xylem, and it can be triggered by environmental injury, insect feeding or infection by fungi or bacteria. Some are thought to be genetic. Most are not a concern to the health of an otherwise normal tree, and Connecticut does not recommend removing them, because removal does more harm than leaving the burl.
Utah State University Extension describes a burl as a woody gall that grows slowly, with highly figured wood prized by woodworkers. Burls often carry small branches with leaves on their surface and are common on boxelder.
Galls
The University of Wisconsin's Division of Extension defines galls as growth from excessive, disorganized cell division in response to infection or irritation by bacteria, fungi or insects, or sometimes environmental stress. In some cases, galls caused by insects are a place for the insect to lay eggs. Some trees are genetically more prone to them. Small galls can stay small, or grow into large burls. Golf-ball-sized galls on hickory, caused by Phomopsis, can kill a branch as they encircle it. Burls on oaks are often caused by fungi or bacteria, and the trees can live with them for life. Wisconsin adds that many galls can be pruned out.
Minnesota's diagnostic page for willow lists two galls and a gall borer, besides a witches' broom covered below:
- Willow pine cone midge gall: a light green, pine-cone-shaped growth about one inch long at the end of a twig, where a bud would be. Old galls turn light brown and stay on over winter.
- Crown gall, caused by Agrobacterium tumefaciens: a round to irregular woody overgrowth at the soil line or on roots, with small round galls sometimes on branches. Young galls are soft and light green or white, and old ones hard and dark.
- Poplar gall borer: the twig swells where larvae feed under the bark. Branch tips die or break above the gall. The larvae are up to one inch long, creamy-white and legless. The borer is also found on aspen and poplars.
Witches' brooms
Utah State describes a witches' broom as a proliferation of abnormal growth, usually on twigs near branch ends, that looks like a broom head with many short branches from one point. The shoot it grows from dies because the vascular system is disrupted, and the canopy turns stunted and dense. Utah State ties brooms to sycamore anthracnose on London planetree, to fir broom rust on subalpine fir and to dwarf mistletoe on lodgepole pine. On hackberry it calls the cause unclear. Minnesota lists a willow witches' broom caused by an aster yellows group phytoplasma, with stunted leaves and twigs that often die over winter.
Cankers
Minnesota's linden page lists perennial nectria canker (Neonectria galligena) beside burls. It appears as sunken dark brown cankers on the trunk or branches, with red to reddish orange raised bumps at the edge occasionally. Cankers become crater-like cavities with age, and girdling cankers kill branches and twigs.
Cutting growths out: where the agencies differ
Wisconsin finds many galls easy to prune and gives about 8 inches down the branch as the cut point for gall removal. Utah State describes pruning below the point of attachment, after which a growth usually does not return on that shoot. It adds that the right cut on a large burl is hard to judge and that leaving growths in place is an option. Connecticut does not recommend removing burls.
Look-alikes at a glance
| Growth | What shows | Site page |
|---|---|---|
| Burl | Round woody swelling with bark on it, often with sprouts | Our page on burls |
| Gall | Disorganised growth on twigs, branches or roots, small to golf-ball size | Our page on tree galls |
| Pine cone gall | Light green cone-shaped growth at a willow twig tip | Our page on willow pine cone gall |
| Witches' broom | Dense cluster of short weak shoots from one point | Our page on witches' broom |
| Canker | Sunken dark brown patch, crater-like with age | Our page on tree cankers |
Sources
- University of Minnesota Extension, What's wrong with my plant: basswood and linden, unusual woody growth on trunk, read October 16, 2026
- University of Minnesota Extension, What's wrong with my plant: willow, unusual growth or swelling on trunk or branches, read October 16, 2026
- University of Wisconsin-Madison Division of Extension, Wintertime is a great time to look for galls on trees (content last validated 2024), read October 16, 2026
- University of Connecticut Home and Garden Education Center, Tree Burls, read October 16, 2026
- Utah State University Extension, Utah Forest Facts 041, Can Trees Get Cancer?, read October 16, 2026