ArbNation Join free

Phenology of bud break and leaf-out: chilling, forcing and photoperiod

Bud break in temperate trees follows winter cold, spring warmth and, for a few species, day length. In 2012, white ash in a Kansas garden leafed out 21 days earlier than in other years.

Checked against the sources at the bottom of this page on October 16, 2026. Rules, fees and pay change: the source has the last word.

Phenology is the timing of recurring plant events such as bud break and leaf-out. Research on temperate trees points to three drivers: winter chilling, spring forcing temperature and photoperiod. The sources weigh them differently.

The three drivers

A 2022 paper in Frontiers in Forests and Global Change calls chilling, spring forcing temperature and photoperiod the most important drivers of spring phenology in temperate trees. Chilling is previous exposure to cold. Forcing is spring warmth, with temperature assumed to be higher than 5°C. Photoperiod is day length.

The USA National Phenology Network summarises past studies this way: temperature is the dominant factor in the timing of leafing in temperate plants.

Chilling and forcing trade off

Harrington and Gould, of the USDA Forest Service and the Washington Department of Natural Resources, tested 11 Pacific Northwest tree species. Their 2015 paper finds that plants add up chilling and forcing units at the same time during the dormant season. A well-chilled plant needs less forcing to burst bud than a poorly chilled one.

The same trials found species that must have chilling. Douglas-fir, western hemlock, western larch, the pines and the true firs did not burst bud normally with no or very little chilling, even under long photoperiods. Pacific madrone and western redcedar needed less forcing after chilling, but many plants burst bud without any.

The authors add a nursery point. Stock held for a long time in cold storage collects a great deal of chilling, so very little forcing can start bud burst.

Photoperiod

The Frontiers paper ran a climate-chamber test on nine species from East Asia (near Beijing) and Central Europe (near Zurich). It used two chilling levels (0 or 56 days at 2°C), four forcing temperatures (5, 10, 15 and 20°C) and two day lengths (8 or 16 hours). Bud burst of most species was marginally affected by day length, if at all. European beech was the exception.

The authors conclude that photoperiod plays a subordinate role to chilling and forcing for most of the species tested. They also found that species near Beijing responded more readily to forcing than species of the same genus near Zurich, whatever the chilling level.

Where the timing came from

The USA National Phenology Network reports on white ash grown in a common garden in Kansas. Seeds from 43 populations across the species range were planted there in 1976. In 2012, the earliest spring on record, the trees leafed out an average of 21 days earlier than in other years.

Trees tracked the leaf-out timing of the place their population came from, and southern populations leafed out earlier than northern ones. The Network notes the risks of early leaf-out: later frosts and freezes can hit the new growth, and the plant can fall out of step with the pollinators it relies on.

Warmer winters

Harrington and Gould built budburst equations for each of their species and ran them for 2080 with winter temperatures 3.2 to 5.5°C higher than today. For Douglas-fir, budburst came up to 74 days earlier across much of the study area. In some southern parts of its range it came up to 48 days later, because the chilling fell short. Every other species in the trials budburst earlier.

The Frontiers authors expect leaf-out to keep advancing for opportunistic species with low chilling and photoperiod needs. They expect a lack of chilling and photoperiod limits to slow the more conservative species.

Driver, what it is and what the sources record
DriverWhat it isWhat the sources record
ChillingCold exposure in autumn and winterMore chilling means less forcing needed (Harrington and Gould, 2015); obligate in Douglas-fir, western hemlock, western larch, pines and true firs
ForcingSpring warmth, usually above 5°CDominant for leafing in temperate plants (USA National Phenology Network); 21 days earlier leaf-out in 2012 for white ash
PhotoperiodDay lengthMarginal for most species tested; European beech responded (Walde and others, 2022)

Sources