Poisoned, drilled and girdled trees: the Criminal Damage Act 1971 and what councils and extension services record
Section 1 of the Criminal Damage Act 1971 makes destroying or damaging another person's property an offence in England and Wales. Extension services describe how herbicide injury shows up in a tree.
Checked against the sources at the bottom of this page on October 16, 2026. Rules, fees and pay change: the source has the last word.
This page reports what the official source says. It is not legal advice: ask the office named here.
The offence in England and Wales
Section 1(1) of the Criminal Damage Act 1971 makes it an offence to destroy or damage property belonging to another "without lawful excuse". The person must intend to destroy or damage such property, or be reckless as to whether it would be. Section 1(2) covers property of any owner, including the person's own, where the person intends, or is reckless, that the damage endanger the life of another. Section 1(3) says an offence committed by fire is charged as arson.
Section 4 sets the punishment on conviction on indictment. For an offence under section 1(2), and for arson, it is imprisonment for life. For any other offence under the Act, which includes section 1(1), it is imprisonment for a term not exceeding ten years.
The Act's wording is about property. Poison, drilling and girdling are not named in sections 1 or 4.
Vandalism as a council describes it
Dudley Council's page on dangerous trees splits tree vandalism into two forms. Opportunistic vandalism is snapping side branches, breaking off crowns and uprooting or pulling whole trees out of the ground. Premeditated vandalism is ring barking with knives and chisels, drilling, sawing off the branches or crowns of young trees, and poisoning roots. In its words, tree vandalism is "a social problem, not a tree problem", and damaging a public or protected tree is illegal.
Only a qualified arboriculturist can establish the danger a potential hazard presents.
Herbicide injury in extension publications
Mississippi State University Extension publication 3117 is written for landowners who contact extension agents about tree damage. It lists possible sources of damage: fungal, bacterial and viral organisms, animals, insects, weather and natural mortality. Accidental herbicide exposure is not to be discounted, especially near agricultural crops. Where a misuse of herbicide is known, damage is usually easy to assess. In other cases the cause is usually not known, and landowners ask the Extension Service.
The publication names the details an agent wants: the date of nearby herbicide applications, the products used, the type of application and how the herbicide reached the property, whether by direct spraying, runoff or drift. It asks for clear close-up photographs taken as soon as damage is seen, and for a record of how the damage progresses, because most herbicides do not kill trees instantly. It also points to the condition of adjacent vegetation, since many herbicides are selective and leave grasses, broadleaf weeds or woody species unharmed.
Publication 3273 from the same service covers herbicides commonly found in landscapes. It says identifying a specific herbicide from vegetation and soil analysis is possible but expensive and limited, as the test covers one compound at a time. Most people rely on the visible damage. Its notes on symptoms include chlorotic and puckered foliage, leaf distortion, purpling, necrosis, and, for one herbicide group in heavy drift, stem girdling at the soil line with swelling above that point.
The Nebraska Forest Service lists common signs of herbicide injury as deformed foliage (cupping, curling, twisting, puckering), stunted stems and shoots, discoloured foliage, leaf scorch, defoliation, and branch dieback or death of the whole tree. It says damage from weather, insects and diseases can be confused with herbicide damage. Local extension offices, the Nebraska Forest Service and the Nebraska Department of Agriculture may help identify injury, and the service collects damage reports. It states that it is not a regulatory agency.
Some of the worst herbicide damage builds slowly over several growing seasons, in the Forest Service's words.
Trees under a preservation order
A tree under a preservation order in England is covered by a separate offence, set out in penalties for felling a TPO tree. Sections 1 and 4 of the Criminal Damage Act name no reporting route for a poisoned tree.
Sources
- legislation.gov.uk, Criminal Damage Act 1971 section 1, destroying or damaging property, read October 16, 2026
- legislation.gov.uk, Criminal Damage Act 1971 section 4, punishment of offences, read October 16, 2026
- Dudley Council, Dangerous trees (vandalism section), read October 16, 2026
- Mississippi State University Extension Service, Forest Environments: Identifying Herbicide Damage and Selecting Herbicides, publication 3117, read October 16, 2026
- Mississippi State University Extension Service, Common Landscape Herbicides and Their Effects on Trees, publication 3273, read October 16, 2026
- Nebraska Forest Service, Herbicide Damage to Trees, read October 16, 2026