ArbNation Join free

Post-hurricane tree damage and public perceptions: the AUF research

After Hurricane Hugo, 30 percent of Charleston residents named the urban forest as the most special thing the storm damaged. After Sandy, a survey with 1,173 responses found homeowners still perceived trees positively.

Checked against the sources at the bottom of this page on October 21, 2026. Rules, fees and pay change: the source has the last word.

Charleston after Hurricane Hugo

R. Bruce Hull IV of the Hazard Reduction and Recovery Center at Texas A&M University published a study of Charleston, South Carolina in Arboriculture & Urban Forestry in March 1992. Hurricane Hugo made landfall in 1989. In the spring and summer of 1990, three trained interviewers ran 185 twenty-minute telephone interviews in ten Charleston neighborhoods of about 100 homes each. Of 346 households called, 63 refused and 98 were businesses, had moved or could not be reached after 15 recalls.

Residents named a physical feature of the city that Hugo damaged and that was special to them. The 185 interviews produced 2,213 coded responses. The abstract says over 30 percent of residents named the urban forest as the most significant damaged feature, and the results text gives 30 percent. Churches came almost as often, at 27 percent. Respondents' own homes were a distant third at 13 percent.

Features residents named as special and damaged by Hurricane Hugo, Charleston study
FeatureShare of residents naming it
Urban forest (trees, forested parks)30 percent
Churches27 percent
Own home13 percent
Public buildings6 percent
Historic structures6 percent
Retail structures5 percent
Homes of friends or neighbors3 percent
Places of employment1 percent
Other8 percent

Residents were more articulate about trees than about anything else. Over 44 percent of all codeable reasons explained why the urban forest was special, against 23 percent for historic structures and 16 percent for churches. More than 10 percent of respondents said they had taken the urban forest for granted before the storm. Nobody said that about any other feature. The Charleston roofs were hurt too, with about 80 percent needing repair of some type.

The abstract lists the values residents gave for trees, as shares of all 2,213 responses.

  • Positive emotions: 11.6 percent. Negative feelings came up twice, both about safety.
  • Community image and aesthetics: 9.5 percent.
  • Energy conservation and other economic reasons: 6.4 percent.
  • Personal values and memories: 5 percent.
  • Environmental quality: 3.4 percent.
  • Leisure opportunities: 2.3 percent.
  • Functional concerns: 1 percent.

Long Island and New Jersey after Hurricane Sandy

Alexis Alvey, Nina Bassuk and Jason Grabosky presented an abstract at the 2015 International Society of Arboriculture annual conference, in the Arboriculture Research and Education Academy session. Hurricane Sandy hit the East Coast in October 2012, and Long Island, New York and New Jersey were among the worst hit areas. An electronic survey went to homeowners less than six months after the storm. It drew 1,173 responses.

The homeowners rated urban trees positively despite the storm. Agreement was strong with positive statements about trees, especially their environmental and aesthetic benefits. Their biggest worry was trees disrupting power or damaging homes in future storms. That worry did not turn into a view that trees are dangerous, or that the risks outweigh the benefits.

Opinions on future tree care were weak. Homeowners agreed that properly cared for trees are less dangerous, yet they were ambivalent about having tree health checked or pruning more often. Over half planned to plant trees on their properties soon, especially small ones.

Florida homeowner association leaders and hurricanes

A University of Florida IFAS Extension fact sheet by Francisco Escobedo, Robert Northrop, Michael Orfanedes and Anna Iaconna compares mail surveys of homeowner association leaders in two Florida counties. Hillsborough County received 641 surveys in 2007 and Broward County 578 in 2008. Returns were 22 percent in Hillsborough and 27 percent in Broward. Broward was directly affected by the 2004 and 2005 hurricane seasons. Hillsborough was not directly affected by hurricane force winds in those years.

Hurricane damage was the biggest concern for both groups. Three of Broward's four top cost concerns were hurricane related, and two of Hillsborough's four. The national survey it compares against (Lohr and others, 2004) listed storm damage to power lines as the only storm concern. Neither Florida county put environmental benefits such as noise and dust reduction in its top four benefits, which the national survey did.

Top four costs of urban trees, ranked, as the fact sheet prints them
RankBroward County leadersHillsborough County leadersNational survey
1Hurricane damage from treesHurricane damage from treesAllergies
2Damage to sidewalks, roads, driveways and foundationsFalling branches and trees on power linesBlock signage
3Falling branches and trees on power linesDamage to sidewalks, roads, driveways and foundationsCause cracks in the sidewalk
4Falling branches and trees on property and carsBlock signageDamage to power lines

Broward leaders showed more interest in planting than Hillsborough leaders. The fact sheet says this might be due to Broward's lower canopy and its tree losses from the recent hurricanes. In both counties, leaders rated hurricane damage, root damage to infrastructure and the cost of maintaining trees as very important when weighing new planting or protection programs.

Sources